One of the longest-running debates I see among newsletter senders is whether to ignore or to pore over notifications and feedback signals from subscribers. It seems like such a simple choice at first, but it quickly grows to engulf mental health, financial stability (if you have paid subscriptions), creative autonomy and fulfillment, relationship-building, and a dozen other weighty topics, all influenced by how often you get updates about the performance of your newsletter.
Pay attention to every unsubscribe or social media mention and you might be able to turn that data into better writing or art, but at the cost of sleeping soundly. “@Buttondown having email notifications for unsubscribes on by default is devastating to my ego,” Pavel of Product Picnic recently posted to Bluesky, echoing what Buttondown founder Justin Duke himself wrote when announcing the emails filled with sad GIFs back in 2017, “I hate learning about unsubscribed folks. It stresses me out.”
Cut yourself off from performance data, however, and sending will be both less stressful and less informed. “Sometimes it’s easy to be stuck in your own head and come up with a bunch of ideas and assertions, and it’s not until later when people read it and give you feedback that you realize you missed something obvious,” Charlie Jane Anders said in one interview. “There were comments on every one of those posts that were really helpful to me when it came time to revise the essays for the book.”
Is opening yourself up to the flood of opinions on the internet a net positive for sending a newsletter, though? One experiment, repeated multiple times, has tried to determine whether or not we acclimatize to the ominously named “repeated psychosocial stress,” and the results probably weren’t what you’d expect.
Can you desensitize yourself to difficult feedback?
While I don’t claim to be an expert on this subject, I am someone with a little (a lot) of anxiety who’s interested in being less...that way. And the experiment on this topic that fascinates me the most goes like this: A group of individuals are asked to speak in front of an audience, once per day for several days, and have their stress (read: cortisol) levels measured after each speech. But across different iterations of the experiment (some with twins, some with soldiers, etc.), what seemed to keep happening is that two distinct groups emerged.
Some participants in the stress acclimation experiment had spiked cortisol on day one, but were back to baseline for their speeches on days two through five. They were “low responders.” The other group, the “high responders,” was stressed throughout and never stopped dreading the stage. This hits home because we’ve all seen LinkedIn posts preaching that if you can just “grind through it,” you’ll become better at dealing with direct feedback. And there’s at least some evidence that’s not true.
Interestingly, one variation of the experiment seemed to indicate that whether a participant would adapt or not was tied to how much they ruminated and self-reflected after the previous speech. And that lines up with my personal experience. Individual comments or unsubscribes don’t send me spiraling, it’s the worrying that what I just sent will result in some future avalanche of bad news. The stress that my inbox could start pinging with unhappy replies at any time. Once I learned how to deal with the unpredictability of notifications rather than the occasional negativity, sending a newsletter became much less stressful.
The case for disabling or delaying notifications and feedback
You might hear people who don’t stress and obsess about subscriber input saying that it gets easier. They’d likely say there’s no reason to scale back your notification settings because you’ll toughen up. But one survey of 542 content creators found that diagnosed anxiety actually went up, not down, as tenure increased. That sounds to me like something you should be trying to prevent rather than adapt to. And turning off notifications is one of the easiest ways to avoid over-monitoring and stressing yourself out.
Still, there are a lot of performance-related alerts to customize and you probably don’t want to turn them all off. Turn off unsubscribes and complaints, sure. And maybe social and web mentions. But why would you ever disable new subscriber emails? Few things will motivate and inspire you to write as much as learning about new signups. Personally, I want to know everything as long as I know the day and time it’s going to arrive.
By turning on weekly reports, you’ll know exactly when potential criticism will arrive in your inbox, giving you a chance to prepare and plan accordingly. And, if you’re worried subscribers can’t wait a few days for you to reply to their questions, set up an autoresponder to let them know it’ll take some time for you to get back to them. No more sad GIFs or late-night replies as you try to go to bed!
In the survey of 542 content creators, peer-support networks and creator communities were the fourth-most-requested mental-health resource, surpassed only by three financial-stability requests. With backing from experienced creators, the idea of receiving feedback out of the blue is way less stressful, either because they can help you interpret it, or in some cases, filter it out. I recently interviewed one sender with more than 30,000 subscribers who told me she has a friend she sometimes asks “Would you just go through and clean out all the unhelpful replies? I just don't wanna deal with it today. I don't wanna be stuck in my head.” If you don’t already know someone who can fill that role, groups like The Check-In or even your most dedicated subscribers are no-brainers.
Whether you turn off notifications, batch and schedule them for a specific time, build give-and-take editing relationships, or have friends moderate incoming criticism, you’re not chickening out. You’re creating a sustainable sending habit that accounts for your mental wellbeing. I would still recommend that you at least experiment with increasing your exposure to input from subscribers, though. It might even make you less anxious.
The case for confronting criticism head on
After an embarrassing classroom incident as a kid, Jia Jiang was terrified of rejection. When he went searching for ways to overcome that anxiety as he got older, he said Google served him up “a bunch of rah-rah inspirational articles about ‘Don’t take it personally, just overcome it!’ Who doesn’t know that?” Eventually he stumbled across Rejection Therapy and decided to seek out rejection at least once per day, 100 days in a row. He would ask strangers for $100 or fast-food workers for a free “burger refill” and document every attempt on his blog. To his surprise, it only took a few days before the stunts stopped spiking his anxiety, similar to the “low responders” from the public speaking experiment.
“I found if I just don't run, if I got rejected, I could actually turn a ‘no’ into a ‘yes,’” Jiang says. “And the magic word is, ‘why.’” The best example of that for a newsletter is someone who unsubscribes. Your first assumption is probably that you wrote something the unsubscriber found offensive or uninteresting. But maybe they just chose that day to cut back on their email habits. Or they unsubscribed because they added your newsletter’s RSS feed to their reader instead! You can’t crash out over feedback signals until you know what actually motivated them, and you can’t know that until you engage with them.
Custom unsubscription reasons are one of the most underutilized performance indicators across Buttondown accounts. Go to your Subscribing settings and create a list of reasons that are specific to your newsletter and its content—and don’t forget to include an option that lets people indicate nothing was wrong and they’re just moving on.
Alternatively, you could proactively seek out uncomfortable reviews by embedding a survey in your newsletter that asks something like “If you could change one thing about this newsletter, it would be...” and creating a handful of multiple choice responses based on the the things you worry about most. Being the one to suggest what might not be working gives you more control over the feedback and softens the blow. But you could add even more levity by creating sarcastic and silly feedback responses for things you actually are worried about. The funny thing is, most of the time, you’re probably worrying about entirely the wrong things.
Clinical psychologist Joanna Arch commented in a recent interview on how many anxiety-ridden people think that their catastrophizing “will prevent the bad outcome from happening or mentally prepare them if it does.” The catch is that “we don’t actually anticipate most of the bad things that happen in our lives.” So, yeah, opening yourself up to other people’s opinions about your work is awkward and discomforting. But ruminating in your own head, without external input from others, makes it significantly harder to work through problems. So if you’re going to worry regardless, the least you can do is base it on concerns that exist outside of your head and in the real world.
All of this is to say nothing of the fact that confronting more criticism inevitably means uncovering more praise! “It was challenging at times, but I learned a lot from the process,” Emma Vivian wrote about the stress of publishing an algorithm-driven newsletter. At the same time, “there was validation, too. Comments that made me feel good about my writing, along with my efforts to cultivate optimism—despite my catastrophising tendencies.” Each new avenue for people to weigh in on your writing or your art has the potential to show you your own blind spots and to expose you to encouragement and positivity.
What’s the best way to enlarge your feedback surface area? “Comments make my thinking better in public. They surface edge cases, they add links I missed, and they keep me honest,” Dwayne Charrington explained when adding comments to his blog. You can do the same for your newsletter by adding comments to your archives and connecting integrations to automatically post newsletter issues to social media for even more feedback opportunities.
Even if you’re one of the supposed high responders who never acclimatize to “psychosocial stress,” there’s something to be said for a sort of Inbox Zero philosophy to dealing with newsletter notifications as they arrive. Snoozing a comment or a reply to deal with it later lets it live amongst the other clutter in your brain, taking up space until some unknown future time. So while it might be uncomfortable in the moment, at least you can be done with it and free up some RAM.
Either approach is completely rational
Whether you prefer to minimize or maximize your newsletter notifications, email will always be a less stressful creative channel than social media. There is no algorithm (on Buttondown, at least) forcing you to adopt a certain style of writing or draw the comic style du jour. Whatever kind of newsletter you want to send is the right kind, which is why everyone should start a newsletter.
If your reason for sending is to find your tribe and express some essential part of you, ignore the haters, disable stressful notifications, and forge ahead. Subscriber growth is not the answer to all of life’s questions. If, on the other hand, you want to be pushed and challenged into new creative territory, that’s fine too.
It’s your list, and your newsletter. You get to make the rules.
| Image | Credit |
|---|---|
| Header photo | New York Said via Unsplash |
