How much money is enough? (vol 1)
My dear reader.
For the past 11 months I have been spending down my savings.
This was intentional — after starting to divest from the stock market in June of 2024 I decided to repurpose a big chunk of that money to cover a year-long sabbatical in 2025, during which the majority of my tiny business (except for this newsletter, and sometimes even that) has been closed.
The most honest thing I can tell you about my gap year is that the reality has been much different from the initial fantasy. Mostly that’s because 2025 wound up being defined by two major things, both agonizing and both entirely outside of my control. The first, my father’s cancer diagnosis and death (and the subsequent need to relocate my disabled mother and take over all the details of her life and care). The second, my country’s rapid fall into authoritarianism alongside a general worsening of worldwide collapse. (What a time to be alive, right?)
So no, the day-to-day of gap year didn’t look at all the way I envisioned when I first planned it, and yet of course I still unearthed so much about myself through this experience.
In the realm of work and money, this week I’d like to tell you about the five most useful things I’ve learned through 11 months of low/no paid work.
1.There can be so much freedom in decoupling your job from your identity
The business of self-employment can be a real mindfuck, especially my kind of self-employment where so much of the business is, well, me.
When you spend many hours each week (for many many years) selling yourself and the offerings you’ve created with your brain and body, it’s easy for the line between person and product to blur. It is not an exaggeration to say that these past 11 months of no business, coming at the end of two and a half years since leaving social media and deciding to no longer post any personal photos on the internet, has fundamentally changed my own understanding of myself. My identity and personhood now feel fully decoupled from my job in a way that I genuinely never thought would be possible. I no longer care about looking cool on the internet, no longer need people to think I’m aspirational or attractive or interesting or smart or or or. The part of me that was constantly seeking that kind of validation from the online world (and therefore through my job), the part of me that wanted to be seen as “special” in this very public way, is simply… gone.
I still need a job, because I still need to earn money. But in decoupling my job from my identity I am now able to ask more generative questions, such as: Given that I need to earn, what is the most pleasurable, most relationally connective, and most values-aligned way to do that? Right now the answer is: writing this newsletter each week, which I am devoted to doing as well as I can – out of respect for you, the reader, whose attention and support I do not ever take for granted, as well as respect for myself and the craft/lineage of honest storytelling that I am honored to be a part of.
In order to stop supplementing from savings though, either the income from this newsletter will need to grow or I’ll need to add other offerings in 2026 to reach my monthly ‘enough’ number. So the freedom I’ve gained this year isn’t the freedom from work, it’s the freedom of no longer feeling like my job needs to define me. I finally (finally!) feel like who I am is not dependent on how I earn the money I need in order to survive inside of capitalism, and this is an absolute blessing, let me tell you.
2.“Investment” doesn’t need to mean what capitalism tells us it means
If capitalism excels at anything it is taking the wonders of an abundant, lush, complex, interdependent world and narrowing it down into the equation of: money = good, more money = better, most money = best.
Through the lens of capitalism, nothing is worth anything until it is turned into money. An old growth forest? Meh. Lumber? Money. Clean water? Shrug. A place to quickly and easily dump toxic factory waste? Profitable. Taken to its most extreme we get the current commercialization of self, where it feels like we aren’t allowed to have non-monetized hobbies anymore, as if our lives/selves are the new strip mine and we must extract every bit of “value” that we can.
And so of course in this context investing means turning our money into more money, no matter the long-term consequences. Which isn’t to say that many of us don’t sincerely need more money — gross inequality is a feature of capitalism, not a bug, and I am wholly uninterested in judging individual people and what they choose to do to survive. What I judge, harshly, are the systems that got us here and the fact that the stock market (extractive, exploitative) can be blasting off while millions (literally, millions) of people cannot afford groceries. How is that a “strong” economy? Make it make sense!
So this past year, while earning much less than usual and relying on my savings to pay my bills, I thought again and again about how I might reimagine and expand what it means to invest for the future (my own personal future, as well as our collective future). Because having more money by itself is meaningless. What even is money? What most of us actually want is what money gives us access to under capitalism — housing, healthcare, nutrition, education, entertainment, socialization — and through a massive reduction in earning this year (and in the number of hours worked) I’ve become more curious than ever about how to invest in these outcomes outside of the current monetary system.
If the purpose of investing under capitalism is to put your money somewhere with the hope that that money grows into more money, then how can I grow more of what I actually want (the things money gives us access to) with a different, non-monetary input? What happens when I invest time, or energy, or attention. When I invest love and care. When showing up for each other becomes the new startup capital to be cherished and nurtured. Where might that lead us instead?
3.Money is not always the answer
It has become embarrassingly clear to me that the first solution I reach for in any kind of problem-solving situation is money. A friend and I call this spending at the problem.
A recent example:
I am rehabbing a leg injury1 right now, and last week I heard the hosts of a popular running podcast mention a supplement they take to aid recovery. My first thought was: “I should buy that!” When actually what I should do is just continue on with the unsexy daily work of physical therapy. Buying yet another supplement is not going to magically fix my leg. Spending at my injury is not the answer here.
Similarly, a big focus for me over the past year has been learning to distinguish between a problem I am actually trying to solve vs a problem I am being told I should solve. For example, I have recently started using a stationary bike for low-impact cross training, and the painful crotch feeling of doing this without padded shorts is… oh god. If I’m going to continue cycling then yes, to me, this is an actual problem and yes, I will likely use money to solve it.
But (for a different example) the beauty industry’s “problem” with my aging face? I am personally not interested in solving that (nor many of the other problems that corporations spend billions of dollars telling us we have) and so one of the most fun little rebellion projects I’ve undertaken in gap year is to get as free from advertising as possible. Unsubscribing from every single shopping-related newsletter. Paying close attention to where these “buy buy buy” messages come into my life (much less often without social media though), and trying to opt-out.
4.Choosing not to earn hasn’t just changed the way I spend, it changes the way I think
One of the most insidious functions of capitalism is the way it frames having or not having money as the only worthwhile question. Meaning: if you have the money for something, great! Buy it! The only reason not to buy, in this paradigm, is if you don’t have the funds, and even then there’s an entire predatory industry of credit and debt ready to step right in. The question under capitalism is always: how do I get more money so I can buy more stuff? And then once you spend spend spend, the cycle continues. By design. And the people who are enriched by this are certainly not us.
In response, something I’ve changed this year is that instead of asking myself “do I have the money to afford this?” I am now first asking “am I willing to work more hours to replenish this money if I do spend it in this way?” Sometimes the answer is yes, but most of the time it’s not.
5.Removing myself from the culturally-sanctioned morality of being a “hard worker” is both terrifying and liberating
One of the most fascinating parts of gap year has been watching different people’s reactions to the fact that I am currently choosing not to work. I can see it on someone’s face and hear it in their voice when they think this decision of mine is reckless or indulgent, or that it somehow makes me less valuable/relevant/interesting.
It says something about our cultural norms that most conversations (in the sauna at the gym, for example) putter out after I give people an unimpressive and unsatisfactory answer to their “so, what do you do” question by saying “for work? oh, I’m taking some time off from working right now.” They don’t tend to ask follow-up questions because I have broken the conventional script. And so I don’t get to tell them about learning to grow potatoes this summer. I don’t tell them about my afternoon naps. I don’t tell them about the fears I had to process about divesting from both the stock market and the fantasy of traditional retirement in order to give myself permission to take this year off. I don’t tell them about the many unpaid hours of navigating the Medicare system on behalf of my mother. I don’t tell them that I now know the names of the people who work at the library. I don’t tell them about the food donation program I’ve started in my neighborhood, to help make it easier for busy families to stock our local food pantry. I don’t tell them how much better my eyes feel with less screen time. I don’t tell them about playing with my dogs or reading fantasy novels or being able to be more present and available to my friends because I am well-rested.
I don’t tell them any of this, because they don’t ask and, honestly, I don’t need their approval. I don’t need capitalism’s approval. I know (more clearly than ever) how much money is enough for me, and I don’t need to keep striving for more and more and more (and to keep being a “hard worker” in a specific wage-earning context) in order to be worthy and whole.
Being able to take a year off from the majority of my paid work is, without a doubt, a massive privilege. Whether someone thinks that spending down my savings in this way is stupid or not doesn’t change the fact that I had the savings in the first place, which under such oppressive systems is a luxury many people cannot dream of.
But/and: if the people who at least somewhat benefit from the status quo aren’t willing to question it, where will we go but deeper down the same path? If we can’t disrupt the judgement someone feels toward me for choosing not to work for a while, how can we hope to change the systemic judgement and punishment of people who can’t work (and therefore can’t thrive and were never supposed to thrive) under the conditions of industrial imperialism? The system that says it’s shameful for me to not be working and earning at my “full potential” (barf) is the same system that treats as disposable anyone who isn’t a productive cog in the machine — such as anyone who is disabled, or who is an unpaid caretaker, or who is unhoused, or who is simply not “performing” at the level and in the ways capitalism demands.
Fuck all of that, is how I feel. Let’s rip it down brick by brick. And one of those bricks is the internalized voice that says our worth is our output, when of course it is not, and never was, and never will be.
There is so much more I could say on this topic of money and work and worth. You might have noticed that there’s a little “vol 1” after the title of today’s newsletter, and that’s because I envision this as a periodic series, one where we can continue to talk about money and enoughness together. Especially as material conditions shift and change for so many of us so rapidly — I know I’m not the only person in the US on non-employer-sponsored health insurance who logged into the open enrollment portal last week and saw a monthly cost increase of 112% next year. A hundred and twelve percent!
So more to come in this series for sure, and as always you are welcome to ask any questions in the comments, or share specific aspects of this topic you’d like me to write about in more detail.
With love & hope & radical solidarity,
Nic
Thank you all for the kind words and well-wishes before my MRI! Good news: it’s not a stress fracture. The PT was flummoxed at first (because all symptoms did indeed seem like those of a bone stress injury), but we’re working through a treatment plan now for proximal hamstring tendinopathy and my pain has already lessened as a result. Supremely grateful! ↩
-
I always love how you phrase things, Nic. What stood out to me most this time around is your phrase:
"Choosing not to earn."
It reminds me of what you said about decoupling identity from your job. Something I've been working on is calling my job as "the way I earn money." Instead of making it have some greater meaning about me as a person.
It also helps me think creatively about earning money. I can sell a houseplant I grew and that counts just as much as what I do in my coaching business.
You're rad and can't wait to read more.
-
I appreciate all of this and will take forward pieces to consider for my own life, especially related to ads. Investing time into what I want has always been important to me even when I felt weird or guilty about it.
Last year, I got the first high-paying job of my life. I grew up with the labels of “smart” and “potential,” and I had felt like I wasn’t living up to it before this job. But now that I got here? Having this amount of money definitely reduces stress, but I’ve also spent a lot of time pulling the final dregs of my identity from having a high-paying job. Plenty of people who make less than I do have jobs that are actually important. People need stocked grocery shelves waaaaay more than I what I do. The system is so fucked up.
My other sense of relief is “my life is enough, my paycheck is more than enough.” I don’t want more and more and more. Capitalism is so fucked up, and I know I have more work to do. But I can also tell it hasn’t taken me over entirely.
-
"I don’t need capitalism’s approval." Thanks for that!
-
Absolutely loved these reflections, especially: "I still need a job, because I still need to earn money. But in decoupling my job from my identity I am now able to ask more generative questions, such as: Given that I need to earn, what is the most pleasurable, most relationally connective, and most values-aligned way to do that?"
"They don’t tend to ask follow-up questions because I have broken the conventional script. And so I don’t get to tell them about learning to grow potatoes this summer. I don’t tell them about my afternoon naps." I had this experience when I was not working and it was so stressful. When I do this again in the future, I think I will care less about what others think.
-
I always love when you write about money. This was excellent, thank you for sharing!
-
Thank you for writing this. I've been toying with the idea of taking a year off of traditional employment to pursue illustration again and have been feeling allllll kinds of ways about it. My job makes me angry every single day—affecting my ability to be a good wife, mother, person, artist, etc... and yet I stay for all the reasons you mentioned and more. It's not an easy choice for sure. I have the savings to do it, for at least a little while... just have to do the brain gymnastics to make it feel "ok."
-
Thank you so much for sharing Nic. I always appreciate the emotions, thoughts, questions and reflections your wonderful writing prompts within me.
-
You hit on so many good things here, Nic. I completely stopped wearing makeup over the last couple of years (dry eye makes mascara not fun) and even though I was a minimalist anyway, I don't miss it at all. I have friends who spend a ton of money on all of these serums and lotions and do the glazed doughnut face thing and it doesn't do anything. If using products makes you feel good, awesome; I love that for you, genuinely. But it's totally unnecessary. Genetics will determine how you age, and smoking, and weight gain or loss. That's about it. I have completely decoupled from diet culture and anti-aging culture and it feels so awesome to be free and at home in my own skin.
Re: navigating Medicare. I have so been there. Unpaid labor and untold patience with bureaucracy. Feed it what it needs, hope for the best, repeat, repeat, repeat.
Re: being able to work - I have two young adults with autism/auDHD who are either unemployed or under-employed, and trying to get any sort of benefits for people who have high IQs and "look normal" in our current disability system is a fucking nightmare. Social Security disability staff and even the judges at appeal hearings can be so cruel - our attorney said some judges are dead set against giving people benefits. So that's great. We got lucky for her appeal and got a "kind" judge and my kid was still humiliated and wrecked after her hearing, convinced she's not going to win. You have to appeal two, three times to get any disability benefits at all. I'm working on a book about it, because it's so fucked and it needs fixing and words are how I make sense of things.
I appreciate your words here and am grateful you're still writing. It's always good to see you in my inbox.
-
Nic: Your workshop "How Much Money is Enough" and all your writing on this topic have been hugely impactful for me and my own unraveling from capitalism and the more, more, more mindset. Getting clear on what is enough for me is still in process but feeling like I am moving towards deeper understanding of that has changed me! I am truly grateful! And I know this is not only NOT the point but contrary to another point you are making earlier in this essay, but the idea that this choice makes you less interesting is laughable to me! More interesting! More leaning in! SO many questions! (I do get the point you are making and I am typing this with some bratty energy.) That said, when I took a sabbatical for 6-months (aka left my job and stopped earning for a time) I experienced much the same. I'll never forget the person who said I was waiting my "highest earning potential years." I longed for others on this path to talk with and connect with. So again, full circle back to my first point of how your writing on this topic has been such a lighthouse for me! Thanks for opening up and inviting others along with you.
-
I love your money essays so much and I'm always inspired by them. First of all, fuck capitalism and the messed up systems that we live in, where some people don't have access to the most basic needs such as housing, food, and health care, while some people are freaking billionaires who don't pay their fair share of taxes.
Also, when I had may fancy corporate job with my fancy title, I felt like everyone (other than me) was oh so impressed and oh so interested. Now that I've walked away from my fancy job and tell people that I've retired, the only thing I get is "Why? You're way too young to retire! What do you do all day? Don't you get bored?"...um, nope, haven't been bored for a minute yet, but please tell me why I'm too young to stop being super stressed at a job that sucked the life out of me. I am very thankful that my fancy job allowed the financial privilege of being able to "retire early" but also all that stress probably took a few years off my life so there's the tradeoff I suppose.
Lastly, why do the physical therapy exercises feel like the hardest and also the most boring thing on earth? I'm doing PT for my messed up shoulder and I tell you, just getting out the stupid foam roller to do my 20 minute homework every day feels so impossible. Once I start, it's fine but I feel so much resistance to just starting the damn thing.
-
I just noticed that there isn't a "like" button anymore and I love that.
I just wrote a question and then deleted it. You are telling us what you want us to know so I will respect that and not ask for more!
-
Loved reading this, and it really resonates with me! I intensely hear that "Fuck all of that" 🥳🥳 Value coming from within is a beautiful lesson to learn. Tying self worth to your job is such a long con, so gross.
Excited for your continued reevaluation of value. Onwards and upwards! 💓
-
Absolutely not the point of your essay, but wow, I feel you on the physical therapy. Why can't I take a pill instead of having to do something that is both boring and painful, multiple times a week? And worst of all, that actually works, so I just... have to keep doing it! Also, I'd love to meet someone someday who says they're currently not working, and ask them about their potatoes and charitable work dogs and and hobbies. That's so much more interesting than hearing about someone's wage work.
-
When I first started reading, I thought 'why is she talking as if gap year is almost over'. And then I kept reading and I thought '11 months?!?! It hasn't been 11 months' And THEN I thought 'oh my god, it is the middle of November, it HAS been 11 months!' What a funny thing time is and our perspective of it!!! Thanks for continuing to share your writing and insights with us <3 Btw, I've noticed I enjoy reading your newsletter opened up in my browser vs as an email. It just feels more restful and enjoyable to engage with it in that way. It's nice the buttondown platform is simplistic, away from the buzz of my inbox.
I had the exact same thought process, Melissa! Time is weird and wild.
-
Always love your writing on money, Nic. I find it so helpful. I feel my own spending has gotten a bit out of control again, specifically for my kiddo. I buy most things used but I still notice the ways I tend toward getting sucked into her having the coolest swanky wooden Montessori toys and all that jazz. When really, the reality is that her spending time with me and her dad is obviously the most important thing to her.
So I really appreciated the question you posed of “am I willing to work more hours to replenish this money if I do spend it in this way?”. I think I really need to carry that one with me. I know most of the decisions I make would be the same, but some would not, and that is helpful. It's so obvious... but it's not something I consciously think about in those terms every time I make a purchase. Because the money will just... come from... somewhere... oh yes, right. MY LABOR.
-
Nic, I’m so glad it’s not a bone fracture! Hope the healing continues to go well, even when it’s boring. Today’s newsletter… oof. Thank you. I found out a few days ago that I (and almost 200 other people in my company) are at risk of redundancy, and in my immediate team it will come down to a selection process to see who stays. Just before Christmas too. As with so much of capitalism: fuck all of that. Since then, I’ve been trying with others to find counter-proposals and solutions to save jobs where we can. It feels well worth the time and energy, even if the company are unlikely to agree to any of them. One option I've thought of, which the union thinks might work, would be for me and another colleague to do a job share. The prospect of halving my (currently full-time) income is scary, but far less terrifying than the idea of losing it all. And I hate the thought of one of my colleagues losing their jobs. I’ve known all of them for years and the job market for our industry is pretty dire right now. I’ve been working out my finances - the very definition of how much money is enough. The job share would cover my bills, but not leave any money for savings, and I only have a small savings pot to begin with (there’s about two months of essential spending money in it). I’d need to get another part time job, probably a local, minimum wage one, to make things less risky. I have my partner to factor in too and what he thinks: we keep our finances pretty separate, but this might impact on our future dream of having a little house with a garden. On the other hand, I’d been planning on dropping down to four days a week in the new year anyway, for some more rest and that elusive work-life balance. But I just keep coming back to: if one of my colleagues is selected for redundancy, doing a job share could save their job, mean they keep half their income and help their peace of mind. It’s what I would love for someone to offer me, if I’m the one who’s selected. That feels huge. That feels like a good impact to have on the world. (And I’m generalising, of course: for some people choosing redundancy over a job share, due to the redundancy payout, might be the better option.) My gut tells me choosing to job share is a good decision, but my brain (possibly capitalism/my mother’s voice, if I’m really honest) is telling me to cling on to my money if I can and other people are not my responsibility, so not to stick my neck out. So… what do I do? I think I want reassurance that although this is not necessarily a ‘sensible’ decision, it is a valid one!
Add a comment: