Save S13 Green Belt, The Sapphire McCarthy Campaign

Save S13 Green Belt, The Sapphire McCarthy Campaign

Archives
Subscribe
9 November 2026

What the Council Leader wrote to the Minister, and our 2027 calendar

Last week we wrote about S13's share of Sheffield's Green Belt loss.

This week: what the Council Leader has said and written about the Plan, Marie Tidball MP's call for a pause, our affordable housing question for Wednesday, and our 2027 calendar.


Calls for change in Sheffield and Westminster

At Full Council last Wednesday, Councillor Fran Belbin, Leader of Sheffield City Council, told campaigners in the public gallery that negotiating a more acceptable outcome for the Plan was "a political challenge, rather than a technical one" (The Star, 5 November).

On 21 September, she wrote to Housing and Planning Minister Matthew Pennycook MP, seeking a meeting about the Plan. The Sheffield Green Belt Alliance has obtained her letter, and we've published it in full.

Among residents' concerns, she listed the loss of 92 hectares of well-used green space in Woodhouse ward, S13. She also wrote:

"We accept there is a need to include green belt in the Plan, but have misgivings over the extent of green belt development."

We don't know whether the Minister has replied.

In the House of Commons on 2 November, Marie Tidball, Labour MP for Penistone and Stocksbridge, called for a pause to the Plan, a fairer distribution of Green Belt sites across Sheffield and greater use of brownfield land. She also cited new evidence that proposed sites in her constituency, including Town End Farm, had been assessed as containing "our best agricultural land".

Matthew Pennycook declined to meet her and other Sheffield MPs, citing his role in the planning system, and said it was for the independent Inspectors to consider consultation responses and set out the next steps (Hansard, 2 November).

Councillor Belbin has put her misgivings in writing. The Council can still propose dropping Green Belt allocations, including SES29 and SES30, before the Inspectors report.

Poster showing a portly man in a hat labelled Sheffield, his trousers held up by a green belt, with the words: What will happen if he loses his Green Belt? To prevent it sign the petition before Oct 15th.
Sheffield's 1952 Green Belt campaign poster. Courtesy of the Totley History Group; a copy is held in the CPRE archive (ref. CPRE/A421)

Wednesday: a question on affordable housing

On Wednesday 11 November at 2pm, we will ask the Council's Strategy and Resources Policy Committee about affordable housing.

Bramley Common (SES30) alone is expected to provide 413 affordable homes - more than twice the 180 or so that all housing allocations in the south-west, including its two Green Belt sites, would provide by 2039.

Yet the Council's assessments put affordable housing need per household in the south-west at nearly three times that in the south-east. We have set out the figures in our article "Affordable housing in the wrong place".

Our question:

If affordable housing is part of the case for building on Green Belt, why does the Plan allocate so little affordable housing in the South West, where the Council's evidence shows much higher need per household?

The Council's evidence puts the greatest need in one part of the city, and the homes in another. Is that a good plan for Sheffield?


Our 2027 calendar

Our 2027 calendar is now on sale: twelve months of S13's Green Belt, from snow in January to sunflowers in August, with the 1937 Recommendations for a Green-Belt for Sheffield map on the back.

The cover and a selection of month pages from the Save S13 Green Belt 2027 calendar.

Calendars cost £10, with all profits going to the campaign fund. Buy from our shop, with free delivery in S13, or at Handsworth Post Office.

Thank you to everyone who helped, and to local printers Word for Word.


What you can do

Write to your councillors. Find them here and ask:

  1. The Council Leader has told the Housing Minister she has misgivings over the extent of Green Belt development. Will you ask the Council to drop the S13 Green Belt allocations before the Inspectors report?
  2. If the Plan comes to Full Council unchanged, will you vote to adopt it?

Forward this email to a neighbour.

Our next email will report Wednesday's answer and what the campaign and Alliance submitted to October's consultation.

Thank you for sticking with us.

-The Save S13 Green Belt Campaign


Save S13 Green Belt Rainbow Logo
saves13greenbelt.org.uk
Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to Save S13 Green Belt, The Sapphire McCarthy Campaign:
← Newer "A much more even distribution": the Council Leader on the Plan Older → 5% of Sheffield's Green Belt, 35% of the loss
saves13greenbelt.org.uk
Facebook
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.