Save S13 Green Belt, The Sapphire McCarthy Campaign

Save S13 Green Belt, The Sapphire McCarthy Campaign

Archives
Subscribe
15 November 2026

"A much more even distribution": the Council Leader on the Plan

Last week we promised two things: the Council's answer to our affordable housing question, and what we sent to the Inspectors in the Further Main Modifications consultation.

Both are below, along with how to order our 2027 calendar.


Wednesday: no answer

The Council says building on Green Belt will help deliver affordable homes. Bramley Common (SES30) alone is expected to provide 413, more than twice the 180 or so from every allocation in the south-west of the city by 2039.

On Wednesday 11 November, we asked the Council's Strategy and Resources Policy Committee why this is, when its evidence shows need per household in the south-west is nearly three times that in the south-east.

Councillor Fran Belbin, Leader of Sheffield City Council, did not answer in her written reply. It said she had answered many questions to help residents respond to consultations, that the last consultation the Council expects has now closed, and that the Council must wait for the Inspectors' report. She said:

"It is therefore not appropriate for me to continue to provide responses to technical questions around Plan content and the associated evidence base."

A question about community facilities for Handsworth received the same standard reply, followed by a reference to her 4 November answer (questions and responses, 11 November).

Compare that refusal to answer with what Councillor Belbin has said about openness:

  • At Full Council on 4 November: "I don't accept the premise that there has been a lack of transparency, leadership or accountability in relation to the Local Plan." She added that the Council "has never shied away from public scrutiny on this matter" (questions and responses, 4 November).
  • In Wednesday's reply itself: "I have always sought to be open and transparent in the answers I have given."

The reason she gave for not answering doesn't hold up. The consultation closed on 28 October. A week later, at Full Council, she answered questions about the Plan, including one on community facilities. And in Wednesday's meeting, after declining to answer our question, she answered Councillor Mike Levery's question about the Plan's housing numbers: she said the allowance for windfall sites was "around 7,000 homes", and "a reasonable number" (webcast).

We think the question went unanswered because the answer is uncomfortable for the Council, not because the consultation has closed. She did not dispute our figures and said she recognised the point, and that she had raised a similar one in her letter to the Housing Minister.

We said this was not a technical question, but one about a choice the Council made. She replied:

"I think everybody who was involved in that process would have far preferred to see a much more even distribution across the city, including in the South West."

Councillor Belbin said the options for where to put sites were "extremely limited", and that some were "simply not available to us" (webcast).

Which options in the south-west were not available, and why?

Councillors need to know before they vote: on 4 November, Councillor Belbin said elected members "will have the final say on adoption of the Plan".

Open fields at Bramley Common in S13, with hedgerows and trees on the skyline.
Bramley Common (SES30) on 13 November 2026. The Plan would put about 827 homes here, 413 of them affordable.

What we told the Inspectors

The consultation on the Further Main Modifications closed on 28 October. We have published what the campaign, the Sheffield Green Belt Alliance and others sent to the Inspectors. Four points from those responses:

The Council ruled out Ryecroft Farm, which it owns, as unavailable because of a long lease. The lease lets the Council end it for development if planning permission is in place. At Town End Farm, the Council told the Inspectors that a tenancy of that kind does not stop the land coming forward. We have asked for the lease and the Council's assessment to be published (our response).

Yorkshire Water's assessment, released on 13 October under an information request, rates the land at Bramley Common red, which it defines as "Object to allocation". The Council's published evidence shows the same land in red, but defines red as "Significant mitigation may be needed". It does not explain the difference (response).

The Plan would bring 1,697 homes to Handsworth Hall Farm (SES29) and Bramley Common (SES30), yet names no community centre, library or meeting place for them. The Council says "small-scale meeting rooms" could be fitted in "if a need is identified". We have found no assessment of that need, or of what Handsworth has now. We asked the Inspectors to require one and have the result written into the Plan (response).

The Alliance's planning consultants, James Bailey Planning, conclude that the Council's latest work finds greater potential harm to farmland but does not show why the allocations remain justified. They ask the Inspectors not to recommend adoption until this is addressed (report).

Read them all, with the responses from Clive Betts MP and Marie Tidball MP, on our Further Main Modifications page.


Our 2027 calendar: how to order

Twelve photographs of S13's Green Belt by local residents: snow on the fields in January, winter light through trees in February, sunflowers in August. On the back is the 1937 map Recommendations for a Green-Belt for Sheffield.

The cover and month pages of the Save S13 Green Belt 2027 calendar, with photographs of snowy fields, sunlit lanes and sunflowers.
The 2027 calendar. Select the image for a closer look.

It's an A4 wall calendar with a hanging hook and the bank holidays marked, designed and printed by local firm Word for Word. Calendars cost £10, and all profits go to the campaign fund.

Ordering takes a couple of minutes. Go to our shop, choose how you want to receive it at the checkout, and your confirmation arrives by email. For Christmas:

  • Free delivery in S13 - order by Friday 11 December
  • Pickup in S13 - order by Friday 11 December
  • By post - order by Wednesday 9 December; postage is added at the checkout

Prefer to buy in person? Nutt Case on Handsworth Road and Handsworth Post Office are both selling them.


What you can do

Buy a calendar, for yourself or as a gift.

Write to your councillors. Find them here and ask:

  1. The Council Leader has said it is not appropriate for her to answer more technical questions about the Plan's content and evidence. Before you vote on the Plan, will you ask why it allocates so little affordable housing in the south-west, where the Council's evidence shows much higher need per household?
  2. If the Plan comes to Full Council unchanged, will you vote to adopt it?

Forward this email to a neighbour.

Full Council next meets on Wednesday 2 December. We will write again before then.

-The Save S13 Green Belt Campaign


Save S13 Green Belt Rainbow Logo
saves13greenbelt.org.uk
Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to Save S13 Green Belt, The Sapphire McCarthy Campaign:
Older → What the Council Leader wrote to the Minister, and our 2027 calendar
saves13greenbelt.org.uk
Facebook
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.