I Think You're Sauceome logo

I Think You're Sauceome

Archives
Portfolio
Shop Books + Prints
Shop Shirts + Totes
March 16, 2026

Recipe: Orgeat Lemonade

A delicious mocktail recipe from 1892!

hand lettered title that reads "I Think You're Sauceome" with a cartoon drawing of a peapod

I am counting down to the release of my newest book! Let’s Make Cocktails! comes out in just three short weeks! I’ve got another (spirit-free) “cutting room floor” cocktail for you today: the Orgeat Lemonade.

This spirit-free cocktail appears
in the first edition of Jerry Thomas’s 1892 Bar-Tenders guide – the first cocktail book ever published in the united states – in a section titled “Temperance drinks”.

it’s a lesser known mocktail, but the combination of creamy almond and citrus is uniquely delicious!

Sweet, crisp, and delicately tart, this spirit free cocktail is a refreshing treat!

the original recipe suggests topping the drink off with still water, but soda water cuts through the sweetness of the orgeat especially well.

Thomas also called for ornamenting the drink with “berries in season”, which is an excellent idea...

...But a sprig of fresh herbs, as we use here, is also a delightful complement to the flavors.
ingredients:

1 ounce lemon juice

3/4 ounce orgeat syrup

4-5 ounces soda water

Try adding a dash of orange bitters for some more subtly complex flavors!

Fill a collins glass with medium ice cubes or a collins spear.

in a shaker, combine lemon juice and orgeat syrup.

Shake vigorously
for 12-15 seconds, or until well-chilled.

Strain into the collins glass.

Top with the soda water.

Garnish with a sprig of fresh basil leaves and a lemon twist.

One interesting fact that came up while I was researching the book: “mocktail” is a much older word than I expected! It first appeared on a menu in 1916, over 100 years ago. This particular mocktail recipe is at least as old as 1892, when Jerry Thomas’s Guide was published – and it’s possibly much older. People have wanted creative and tasty non-alcoholic drinks for as long as they’ve wanted creative and tasty alcoholic drinks. The Orgeat Lemonade is a really delicious one that definitely holds up. If you’ve got some orgeat in your pantry, it’s absolutely worth a try.

Upcoming things:

BOOK EVENTS ABOUND!

I’ll be at C2E2 on Saturday, March 28, to speak on a panel with Kim-Joy, Jarrett Melendez, and Lucy Knisley! There’s a good chance we’ll have at least a few copies of Let’s Make Cocktails! for sale at C2E2, even though it’s about a week before the book comes out.

The first events for the launch of Let’s Make Cocktails! will be:

• Tuesday, April 7, 6-8 pm: Book Release Day at Billy Sunday

• Saturday, April 11, 6-8 pm: Cocktail Party at Challengers Comics

I’d love to see you and sign your books at any/all of these events!

What I’m Into Lately:

In my ongoing experiment where I’ve been asking friends to recommend their favorite books, this week I read The Bullet Swallower, by Elizabeth Gonzales James, which was recommended by brother Dave. It’s a magical realist western, and it’s wildly entertaining. But it’s also a meditation on some interesting ideas about evil, intergenerational trauma, and how later generations suffer from the unresolved sins of their ancestors.

What Toki’s Into Lately:

Any box that enters the house becomes Toki’s domain for at least a few days, and this box was no exception.

a fluffy orange and white cat sitting defiantly in an open cardboard box
All your box are belong to us!

Preorder Let’s Make Cocktails! My Portfolio Shop Shirts and Stuff Shop Books and Prints
A row of cartoon food drawings

Read more:

  • March 9, 2026

    Recipe: Toronto Cocktail

    "This cocktail is much appreciated by the Canadians of Toronto."

    Read article →
  • February 16, 2026

    Recipe: Kir and Kir Royal

    A classic French cocktail named for a badass priest and resistance fighter

    Read article →
Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to I Think You're Sauceome:

Add a comment:

Share this email:
Share on Facebook Share on Reddit Share via email Share on Mastodon Share on Bluesky
sarahbecan.com
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.