In Warren Buffett's office hangs a piece of paper worth less than the nail holding it up: a Western Union stock certificate. Dangling between an award signed by Obama and a diploma from the famed Dale Carnegie public-speaking class. Looking back, Buffett can laugh and say "That's when Charlie and I quit short selling." Charlie would sigh and explain it was his third and final time betting against stocks.
Western Union was a telegraph monopoly running out of reasons to exist. Competitors' long-distance rates were falling while Western Union's kept rising. The uniformed messenger, once an iconic mascot, was being phased out as machines took over. They needed a growth story, and they needed it fast. They settled on Telex, a direct-dial teleprinter service still years from commercial launch and already eating a significant share of the R&D budget. It had to work, or Western Union was in trouble.
Market cap of $118M, earnings of $19M, pension outlays of $10M, reserves of $2.4M. The retirement obligations were growing 15% annually, on track to become a $200-250M liability1 with no funding plan behind it. Western Union ran it pay-as-you-go, so the earnings looked real and weren't. 17 a share for a stock worth pennies.
Munger saw this as a prime short candidate. The company was overstaffed, surrendering pricing power, and watching its technology become obsolete. He'd learned from a previous investment that setups like this didn't end well. This was his chance to sit on the other side of the table.