While my last email pointed out the failures of the first batch, I was feeling pretty good about my innate skill to make croissants. People liked them. They mostly looked like croissants. I assumed I knew what to improve in the second batch. But those technical improvements were not enough, I also needed MORE croissants. And, I needed to try a new butter because I felt like I was skipping out on the key ingredient. And then, when I realized I could get local flour, I just had to use it. If I had stepped back and counted the changes I was making, I'd like to think I would have stopped, but it wasn't until I had fully worked the dry flour into the wet ingredients and the ball was still very wet that I realized how far from the original recipe I had diverged. Pride comes before the fall, and the enthusiasm blinds us all.
Expert rating: 3 out of 10
Expert review: "They tasted like...bread? Not super buttery, not enough salt and not a lot of air. Grateful for fresh bakes anyways. :)"
The expert above is Caitlin, my wife. In reviewing this post, she suggested that a ranking system would make how the batch went clearer, and so I asked her to be the judge and throw in a short review as well. As you can see, there wasn't much room for praise. Below I'll cover more about what went wrong, but the main culprits are using a new flour, trying to scale the recipe too far and letting proof go on for too long. Next batch I'll be going back to the flour from batch 1, doubling the recipe rather than tripling it. This week also was plagued by a five hour proof as I needed to sleep. Lets hope that can be avoided in batch 3.