Psychic Paper

Psychic Paper

Archives
Log in
Subscribe
November 13, 2026

Target Acquired

Hello! This is my talk from the recent Target Book day, organised by James Goss. Apologies to any subscribers who were there for the repetition of, as they say, “content” although at least here you’ll get a chance to experience it without my stupid face or “talking too fast” voice. Which is an improvement, even if doesn’t necessarily make it objectively good. There’s going to be a Target Book Day North in Manchester. Y’know, like No 10 North. It’ll be in the New Year, and I’m vanishingly unlikely to be able to make. (But never say never.) So I thought I’d make PP subscribers aware of that while running this here. It’s about how continuity does (or doesn’t) work in the Target Book range, and the vexed question of the order to store them in.


“A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds,” said Terrance Dicks. Although he was quoting the American transcendentalist Ralph Waldo Emerson at the time. It was intended as his all purpose explanation of how and why, in the end, Doctor Who didn’t and couldn’t ever quite add up. Terrance’s, not Ralph Waldo Emerson’s.

That “not adding up” is as true of the Target Books series we’re all here to celebrate as it is of the television series from which it derives, and Terrance, of course, did a huge amount to shape both. And curiously, given his sentiment in this regard, Terrance was not averse to doing a kind of ex post facto script edit to television stories he was novelising but hadn’t worked on the TV versions of. 

You know the sort of thing. 

Chopping out repetition from The Space Pirates, clarifying the timeline of the Urbankan’s visits to Earth in Four to Doomsday - writing an ending for Doctor Who And The Android Invasion. But he would also quietly tidy up bits of continuity when one story he was turning into prose contradicted another he’d previously done. Here’s just one example: 

In The Invasion of Time on television and object which is described in The Deadly Assassin as “the Key” or “Great Key of Rassilon” has become the Rod of Rassilon, and Borusa tells the Doctor that the Great Key is “a myth, missing for generations”. Rather than having been in his hand ten stories before. Terrance, novelising Invasion after having done Assassin obviously noticed this inconsistency, and fixes it with a few lines of dialogue - 

“I have the Rod of Rassilon, and the Sash. I do not have the Key itself” the Doctor said.

“The Key was stolen by the Master, when he escaped from Gallifrey...”

“The Great Key of Rassilon, lying unguarded in a museum?'“The Doctor shook his head. “That was a facsimile, a lesser key. Good enough for the Master's purposes - but not the Great Key itself.”

The old man was silent.

It’s just a handful of words, but they bring Doctor Who And The Invasion of Time into agreement with Doctor Who And The Deadly Assassin, although their television originals remain unreconciled. 

There are countless examples of this scattered across Terrance’s Target canon, enough for a whole extra talk this length. But I want to go somewhere else with this. Because yes, I did use the c word there. 

“Canon”. 

When fans use “canon” in relation to Doctor Who, it’s usually as a near synonym for “continuity”, a sense we probably stole from Sherlock Holmes fans who probably stole it from people who were studying the Bible. Terrance’s changes to TV stories tidy up, essentially, plot points between his own books whoever wrote the TV original, but not necessarily to books he didn’t write - or the TV series. 

There’s a Terrance Dicks Target “canon”,which is incomplete but broadly consistent. In the novelisation of The Five Doctors, there are a few lines linking the Castellan’s supposed vendetta against the Doctor to the events of Arc of Infinity, which Terrance had novelised earlier in the year. 

What he does not do, however, is amend the special’s strange omission of a moment where the Brigadier recognises Turlough, despite him having taught him at Brendon School for a number of months leading up to Mawdryn Undead. In the rehearsal script he doesn’t recognise Tegan either, but this was fixed by the actors during the Acton Hilton phase.

But all this means we can guess, possibly wrongly, that at no point during the writing of The Five Doctors  did Eric Saward furnish him with the scripts for Mawdryn Undead. Which is odd. They were script editors in the same department and he could have popped them in the internal post. It also means that Terrance hadn’t read the Target of Mawdryn Undead, but as it wasn’t published until after The Five Doctors that’s hardly his fault. 

(It is also possible that this is a result of how, even in the rehearsal script for The Five Doctors, the Brigadier is time scooped from BEFORE the events of Mawdryn Undead. What presents onscreen as a reunion is, in even the script given to the actors to learn, his retirement do. Although of course that itself may be a result of Terrance not knowing the Brigadier had met Davison’s Doctor, Tegan and Turlough.)

However, there’s another dimension to this, which I can probably best explain this way - 

Many people shelve their Target novelisations in the order in which the television stories on which they were based were transmitted. It’s probably the most common approach, in that it allows almost any Doctor Who fan to find a particular book without having to work out where it might be. But doing so demonstrates the foolishness of imposing consistency from the off. 

Your shelf will start with a 1981 novelisation of the first serial, followed by a 1965 novelisation of the second serial, followed by a 1987 novelisation of the third, and despite Terrance’s glorious cliffhangering of the final chapter of Doctor Who And An Unearthly Child the book leads into the first Dalek television serial, rather than the next book on the shelf. 

If you continue to read the books in that order you will crash into wild inconsistencies in “continuity” prompted by e.g the “alternative” openings for Doctor Who And The Daleks and Doctor Who And The Doomsday Weapon or the alternative closing to Doctor Who And The Space War which just doesn’t work when read before Doctor Who And The Planet of the Daleks AT ALL.

Because the “Target Doctor Who Library” is not a series that can be read in the order it “happened”, any more than it can be read in the order of the ex post facto numbering system imposed on the first seventy three books in the early 1980s. Which is odd, as those two orders are the two ways in which we as fans tend to shelve their Target collections. Numerical order is more attractive on a shelf. Transmission order makes things easier to find. But neither are a reading order. 

There are many Target Books that contain shifts from their television originals that affect a book’s relationship with the ones either side of it, particularly if you shelve them in order of the transmission of the television stories on which they’re based. Which personally I don’t. Some changes might tempt you to attempt to create a bespoke order for your shelves. 

For example, Doctor Who And The Curse of Peladon, as opposed to its TV original, seems to be set after The Three Doctors. The explanation of the Time Lords sending Doctor Who and Jo on a mission to Peladon is cut. Because the Target audience of 1975 has no need of an explanation for the TARDIS arriving on a planet to have an adventure, so it’s quietly disposed of. It was always a means, not an end, in telling that story. But it does mean it’s probably best to move the book up on the shelf to after the eccentrically titled Doctor Who And The Three Doctors.

(The fourth Doctor in that title is presumably Doctor Tyler, by the way.) 

Some Targets have inconsistencies that can’t be solved by moving a book. Unbelievable as that may seem. We all know that Doctor Who And The Tenth Planet is set in 2000, whereas the TV serial was set in 1986. Explicitly in this and Doctor Who And The Cybermen and later when remembered in Doctor Who And The Tomb of the Cybermen Ben and Polly are from “1970s London”. Davis keeping his contemporary companions contemporary by updating them by a decade. 

This is a version of what Hayles did in Doctor Who And The Curse of Peladon, but more far reaching, and goes as far as details such as Ben watching a little of the 1974 James Bond film The Man With The Golden Gun when locked in the Snowcap projection room. Davis’ three 1970s novelisations, And the Cybermen, And the Tenth Planet and And the Tomb of the Cybermen are a neat trilogy, a story with a prequel and a sequel, that are broadly consistent with each other, and work well as one volume; one in which the Cybermen definitively originate from Telos and migrated to Mondas, and where there’s a black helmeted Cyberleader in every story. 

If reprinted now, it would arguably be more in keeping with Davis’ view c 1977 to set its first third in 2050, make Ben and Polly from 2026 and have Ben fell a Cyberman by streaming a bit of No Time To Die at it.  I say Davis view c1977 because by his 1984 novelisation of The Highlanders, Davis has fallen into line with broader ideas of Doctor Who consistency, and makes Polly “an independent girl from the nineteen sixties” when describing her disdain for Kirstie’s meekness. 

It was a time of more rigorous brand control in Doctor Who. In the 1980s and 1990s, with even more of television Doctor Who missing than there is now, and much of that which did exist seemingly forever inaccessible to fandom, a key criteria for judging Target novels was how accurately they represented television originals that would never be seen. Demanding a foolish consistency that could never come. 

Published after the end of the TV series, the novelisation of Mindwarp ends with the Valeyard promising “The third part of the prosecution….the future” as per the original scripts, and one of the many earlier plans for scripting The Trial of a Time Lord. But the earlier published Terror of the Vervoids still opens with the case for the defence. (Although maybe that’s a place to sneak in an intra Trial “Missing Adventure”. Or whatever it is they’re called nowadays.)

My favourite is that in the novelisation of Galaxy Four, William Hartnell seems not to be the first Doctor. When trying to avoid being grabbed by the Chumblies, he laments that he is an old man. “The Doctor [was] soon wishing he had found a younger body to inhabit. There was not a lot to be said for this one.” The phrasing “found a younger body to
inhabit” seems to me to say this is not his first. Who would talk about ‘finding’ their own body? We’re born in it, or into it, or Loomed with it. It’s dissonant, in a way it wouldn’t be if written about the Capaldi
Doctor—we’d assume he was reminiscing about once being Matt Smith or David Tennant. Which is a nice problem to have.

These days we can all blame / credit that to the innovation of the Timeless Children and the idea of pre-Hartnell Doctors with Sonic Screwdrivers and police boxes, probably. But there are other moments in later novelisations that can’t be squinted away. Even if you want to.

Which, again, personally, I don’t. 

Another Terence, Terence Dudley only wrote three Doctor Who TV stories, didn’t novelise all of them, and wrote those he did novelise in the wrong order; that’s fine, of course. But it means that in Black Orchid… well, I’ll tell you in full - 


Sir Robert frowned. He was deeply worried that such an exemplary cricketer appeared not to have an exemplary character to match. 

It denied a whole code of ethics, contradicted a whole way of life.

"Then you weren't sent here?”

The Time Lord hesitated. The question had to be answered truthfully and it wouldn't be the first time that the Grand Council on Gallifrey had seen fit to nudge the TARDIS towards moral intervention. He remembered the Master's attempt to topple King John of England. “It's possible I might have been.”

Yes, that’s the Doctor remembering the events of The King’s Demons. 


Now, that’s presumably because Dudley had novelised that first, and didn’t know or care in which order the scripts on which they were written were based and no one else “corrected” it. There really is no way to make that “fit”, but that only matters if you want them to fit. Although I do like the idea of the Doctor’s trip to Cranleigh Hall being at the instigation of the Time Lords. Presumably they’re very keen for him to invent Bazball a hundred years early. (Yes, there’s a very small diagram for that joke.)

We shouldn’t, I think, see these as mistakes, but as decisions made for good reasons and working to different criteria than that foolish consistency Terrance - that’s Terrance Dicks not Terence Dudley - mentioned up top. They are part of the story, or the meta narrative, of the “Target Doctor Who Library” itself, as well as the stories within it. Because, yes, there’s a bit of the fan brain that tries to work these things out. It’s probably the same bit that tries to work out whodunnit when we read detective novels or reconcile dates when we go through production folders. 

Well, I say “we”, that’s more of a confession than an accusation. 

It all springs from a desire to make sense, to reconcile when there is really no need. I think we should enjoy them. Embrace a foolish inconsistency instead. As another American transcendentalist whom Terrance Dicks would occasionally quote, Walt Whitman, said in another context entirely  - “Do I contradict myself? Very well. I contradict myself, I am large. I contain multitudes.” 

Or, if you prefer - “It’s bigger on the inside.”

Dimensionally transcendentalist.

“Stay on Target”


Read more:

  • May 2, 2023

    "I'm On Target With Doctor Who."

    It would be remiss for a Doctor Who Substack to not mark the fiftieth anniversary of the beloved Target Books Doctor Who novelisation range. The golden...

    Read article →
  • July 14, 2023

    “New Adventures in Sci-Fi.”

    Doctor Who was dead, to begin with. 1992 isn’t considered a landmark year in the history of Doctor Who. The TV series had ended in 1989. The 2005 revival was...

    Read article →
Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to Psychic Paper:
← Newer Revolution #9 Older → The Tenth Planet
Share this email:
Share on Bluesky
Bluesky
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.