Art of the Day: The Calling of Saint Matthew by Caravaggio (1599–1600)
The Calling of Saint Matthew
Caravaggio · 1599–1600 · Oil on canvas, 322 × 340 cm · Contarelli Chapel, San Luigi dei Francesi, Rome
Image: Wikimedia Commons, public domain · Full-size image
The piece
A gloomy room, a table and a cluster of men counting money. Into this ordinary scene step two figures from the right: Christ, half-hidden in shadow, and Saint Peter. Christ stretches out an arm and points. A shaft of light cuts across the wall above him and falls on the faces at the table. The subject comes from the Gospel of Matthew (9:9). Jesus sees a tax collector called Levi at his booth and says “Follow me”, and Levi gets up and becomes the apostle Matthew.
The painting is one of a pair Caravaggio painted for the side walls of a chapel in the French national church in Rome. The money for the chapel came from the will of a French cardinal, Matthieu Cointerel (Contarelli in Italian), who had asked for scenes from the life of his namesake saint. Caravaggio signed the contract in July 1599, apparently helped by his patron, Cardinal Francesco Maria del Monte. He was paid in full in July 1600, and the Calling and the Martyrdom of Saint Matthew were in place by then. It was his first public commission, and until then he had painted mostly small pictures for collectors. Some years later he added a third canvas, The Inspiration of Saint Matthew, above the altar.
What made it remarkable was its directness. Instead of a stately religious scene, Caravaggio set a sacred moment among Roman street life, with real-looking people. He lit it with hard, raking light against deep darkness, the dramatic effect later called tenebrism. The scene was easy to read, unlike much of the busy Mannerist painting of the day. It drew crowds, made his name almost overnight, and helped spread a style that was imitated across Europe by the “Caravaggisti”.
What to look for
The hand. Christ’s limp, outstretched hand closely echoes Adam’s hand in Michelangelo’s Creation of Adam in the Sistine Chapel. Scholars often read this as a deliberate reference to Christ as the “new Adam”, who here gives new life rather than receiving it.
Then and now. The men at the table wear the feathered caps, slashed sleeves and swords of fashionable young Romans of around 1600. Christ and Peter are barefoot and wear timeless robes. Two worlds meet across the table.
Which one is Matthew? Most people take him to be the bearded man in the middle, pointing at himself as if to say “Me?” Some art historians argue that he is really the young man slumped at the far left, still counting coins, with the bearded man pointing to him. The question is still debated.
The artist
Michelangelo Merisi, known as Caravaggio after his family’s home town near Milan, was born in 1571. He was orphaned young and trained in Milan before arriving in Rome, poor and unknown, in the early 1590s. Cardinal del Monte took him into his household, and the Contarelli canvases turned him from a painter for connoisseurs into the most talked-about artist in Rome. Major church commissions followed. So did a long police record of brawls, and in 1606 he killed a man, Ranuccio Tomassoni, in a fight. He fled Rome and spent his last years on the move between Naples, Malta and Sicily, painting all the while. He died in 1610 at Porto Ercole, on the coast of Tuscany, while on his way back towards Rome in hope of a papal pardon. He was 38. His naturalism and use of light shaped the Baroque, and his influence can be seen in Rembrandt, Velázquez and many others.
One curious fact
X-ray examinations are widely reported to show that Saint Peter was not part of Caravaggio’s first idea. At first Christ seems to have stood alone, and Peter was squeezed in later, partly blocking him from view. Long after, Pope Francis said that he often visited the painting as a young man in Rome, and that he saw himself in Matthew: a sinner on whom the Lord had turned his gaze.
See it
The painting still hangs where Caravaggio meant it to, in a side chapel of San Luigi dei Francesi near Piazza Navona, and visiting is free. San Luigi dei Francesi: the Caravaggio paintings
