People pleasing as self soothing
When you talk to someone who people pleases about their people pleasing pattern, they'll talk about how difficult it is for them to choose to do something they want to do over what other people want. Simultaneously, they find it difficult to know what they want, or to make a decision at all.
This is often a learned response or pattern. Growing up without space to have opinions or make decisions means you're not used to autonomy, growing up where not going along with what other people wanted resulted in being shouted down, being shamed for your decisions, or being told you're selfish for not doing things for others means that people pleasing is the default response to any situation.

It becomes safer to go along with others, not make a decision, and generally not 'cause a fuss'. (we can add socialisation here as well, because not making a fuss, being good/quiet is something aimed at girls more than boys, people of colour more than white people, etc)
There is often a feeling of it being 'easier' to just go along with what other people want. Less fuss, less arguing, less back and forth. This is especially true if you've ever been in a position of stating an opinion and then getting shouted down, or talked out of it, or someone going along but complaining loudly about it. Often it comes with a side of managing other people's emotions because they can't self-regulate.
This tends to cause resentment, as you're abandoning yourself over and over, pushing your own wants aside for the greater good of keeping safe.
The issue is that the pattern persists even when you're in a supportive environment, and that's because the people pleasing is self soothing now. You're anxious about people's judgement or perception of you, you think you're too much or asking too much, or you fear outcomes of making a decision. So you look to others and go with what they want and feel disappointed in yourself. Maybe you feel a little resentful of people for not realising what you're doing, or thanking you (the fact that they're not asking or expecting anything from you is beside the point)
The realisation that you're doing this for you, not for others, is a difficult one to come to. The whole thing about people pleasing is doing it for others! But the others don't really want you to tie yourself in knots to please them, or avoid any kind of discomfort. They might be able to handle it. You, however, will find it difficult, so the urge to be quiet and pleasing is an easy way out.
I'm aware that what I'm saying sounds harsh, and I don't want to downplay the very real anxieties that are under this pattern. It's learned, there's evidence there for it being the way to stay safe. The problem becomes safety when it's unnecessary. You might be projecting your fears and judgement onto other people, assuming they're thinking these things about you when they're not. So you keep them happy at all costs, to avoid the negative outcome you're imagining.
This is why thinking about internal safety is important, because so often we follow patterns that have historically kept us safe without checking in on whether it's still actually needed. Then comes the care for yourself, realising that you were keeping yourself safe, had built these patterns after evidence that to do otherwise would be unsafe. Now you can try new ways of being, and that's great.
It's a weird realisation, that you're people pleasing for yourself more than others. Something that causes so much anxiety, friction, and resentment isn't needed any more, and it's all you. This is why care is so important, it's so easy to be disappointed in yourself, and maybe that's okay, but taking it too far is unhelpful.
Add a comment: