I Think You're Sauceome logo

I Think You're Sauceome

Subscribe
Archives
July 28, 2025

Cobbler, Crumble, Buckle, Slump

hand lettered title that reads "I Think You're Sauceome" with a cartoon drawing of a peapod

Niles brought home a ridiculous amount of blueberries from the neighborhood farmer’s market. I was thinking about what to do with them, when I realized I didn’t really know the difference between all of these American fruit bake desserts. So I did a deep dive!

A Taxonomy of Summer Fruit Bakes. a crumble is baked with fruit and a streusel-like mixture of flour, butter and sugar, crumbled over the top. a crisp is very similar to a crumble, but often has oats or nuts added to the streusel to make the topping crispier. a pandowdy is baked with a pie-crust-like pastry topping. During baking, the crust is broken and pushed down into the fruit. a sonker is specific to north carolina! Fruit filling is juicier than a cobbler, and dough can range from biscuity, like cobbler, to a flaky pie crust. a cobbler is usually Made with a biscuit-like batter. Fruit can be on the bottom, with batter dropped into it, Or the batter can go in first and the fruit drizzled over the top. the biscuity clumps resemble cobblestones. a betty is made by baking Alternating layers of fruit filling and buttered bread or cake crumbs. grunts and slumps are made much like cobbler, but cooked in pans on the stove instead of baked in the oven. a buckle is made by folding Fruit into a cake-like batter and topping it with clumps of streusel-like topping. The streusel and fruit weigh down on the batter, causing the texture to buckle.
Every single one tastes marvelous with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

It was lots more complicated and confusing than I thought! I cross referenced several sources, including the Washington Post, the Joy of Cooking, and the Oxford Companion to Food. There’s a lot of conflicting information, which makes sense for what were originally very informal folk recipes. I found four different articles that said “sonker” originally came from a Scots-Gaelic word, but all four articles disagreed on what the original word meant!

An interesting note: what my family called “cobbler” when I was little was actually a buckle! I was in my late 20s before I encountered the biscuit-drop version of cobbler.

While I was puzzling over this this week, between the two of us, we ended up just eating all the blueberries. So I didn’t even make any of these! But now I’m in the mood for baking one, and berries are still extremely in season. Time to go raid the farmers market! The next newsletter might need to be a good berry crisp recipe. (^_^)

How’s the book going, Sarah:

I have 154/192 pages done!!! I only have 38 pages left to color!!! I’ll spend the next two weeks coloring (on a much more relaxed schedule), and then I’ll have a week or so to drop all the art into the final layout. I can’t believe how close I am to the finish line!

What I’m into lately:

I picked up the audiobook of William by Mason Coile recently and I’m really loving it. I’m only halfway in, but it’s deliciously tense and creepy and has me very much on the edge of my seat. It’s a great motivator to keep me working on the book if I can only listen to this audiobook while I’m working.

Also! my book club LOVED Bury Your Gays! It made for a really excellent discussion, too. It was such a great chat that I went back and re-read Camp Damascus, too. Bury Your Gays had some well-placed references to the events of Camp Damascus, which didn’t surprise me. But rereading Camp Damascus, there were also some references to the films and tv shows mentioned in Bury Your Gays, which was published later! Now I’m wondering if there’s a planned Extended Tingleverse in the works.

What Toki’s into lately:

Being a perfect and precious blameless little angel.

a precious orange and white fluffy cat sleeping like an angel and definitely not dreaming of eating all my expensive lotion
SO DECEPTIVE

LOL, just kidding. His latest obsession is trying to lick the hell out of my arms after I’ve put lotion on them. Apparently some cats really love Aquaphor? The lotion is for my arms! Not for cats to eat!

A row of cartoon food drawings
Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to I Think You're Sauceome:
Join the discussion:
sunnymcd@gmail.com
Jul. 28, 2025, evening

I need a print of this taxonomy! Love it!

Reply Report
My Portfolio Buy Books & Prints My Threadless Shop
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.