Archive • Plunder's Pitch Mix Picks • Buttondown

Quick Plunder Update: I Made a Typo

$ · April 28, 2025

Quick update for 4/28 … I made a typo in my premium email. The first player after the paywall line should read FREDDIE FREEMAN vs. Edward Cabrera. All the...

Suck it Garfield, You're Gonna LOVE This Monday

Ahhh Garfield … I thought he was hilarious when I was a kid. Then I turned 9 and realized he was just a prick cat that didn’t even deserve the life he had.

Quick Plunder Update: Yankee Game(s)

Quick update for 4/27 … Doubleheader today now in the Bronx. Winds are blowing HARD out to right field so just about anybody could go yard. Rice was...

Put On Your Sunday Best

Commentary will be kinda short, but just trust me that all these plays are awesome and stuff.

In a Van Down By the River

I always figure betting on baseball is gonna either send me to a penthouse apartment filled with sexy hoochie mommas, or living out of a van down by the river like motivational speaker Matt Foley. No van yet so … so far so good!

Giving you the HOOAH!

I gotta write like 175 on these emails this season, so we’re always gonna be looking for goofy headlines and ways to kick it off. Today is Al Pacino’s birthday.

The Parade of Weirdoes

Oddball day of picks today. Short slate of games and a few of them have very solid pitchers going, so just a smattering of picks today. It’s also a getaway day so lineups could be funky as well.

The Six Million Dollar Day

OK … I’m not sure where the hell I’m even going with this, other than the fact that we need to just go out and win $6 million today. You in? I AM!!!

DIY Dinger Tuesday

Big ol’ list today with the freebies getting 4 picks and another 11(!) for the premium subscribers.

Patriots Day in Plunderville

It’s the holiday that isn’t actually a holiday except in Boston and Maine, but if you’re a Massachusetts native like me you know it’s all about 11am baseball and lunatics running 26 miles outside the stadium.

So Far, So Good

Happy Easter! Figured today is as good a day as any to look at where we are so far.

Painting the Chalk

A fairly chalky day here for the Pitch Mix Plays, but we just go by what the numbers tell us.

Friday Night Lights

Clear eyes, full hearts … Can’t lose!

Quick Plunder Update: One More

$ · April 17, 2025

Quick update for 4/17 … Apologies for the multiple emails, but I wanted to pass along that I’m adding Bryce Harper to my plays tooday as well. Same logic as...

Put Yo' Hands In the Air

It’s “National High Five Day” … whatever the heck that means. We in Plunderville have decided we’re gonna be handing out many high fives while all of our players go yard today.

We Got That Fire!

What a week … and it’s only Wednesday! Pitch Mix Plays have been absolutely crushing it the past few days and I’m so thrilled to see this paying off (and paying off for YOU in particular).

The Wood is Good

Today features a lot of “pretty good” plays in the B+/B range but not a ton that on the “OH MY GOD!!!” standout level.

It's Raining Dongs

The internet says today is “National Reach as High as You Can Day,” so we’re gonna go ahead and take that as a sign for a home run parade of our Pitch Mix Picks.

No Sunday Scaries Here!

Who’s ready for another Sunday of trying to figure out who’s actually gonna play and who ain’t? We are!

Saturday Shenanigans

Excited about my top picks for Saturday, including Bryce Harper and Vlad Guerrero!

Who the F is Pitching?

Lot's of up in the air pitchers, but we dig for some solid options!

Merry Friday Eve!

Today’s picks include top plays for Bregman, Devers, and a couple of bonuses for free subscribers!

Quick Plunder Update: Tatis Gots a Boo Boo

Quick update for Wednesday (4/9) …Tatis left last night’s game with shoulder discomfort, so he’s out for today. I do think Jackson Merrill is worth...

Pirate Road Trip!

Morning all! Your boy Plunder has to hit the road for a few days for work, but there’s two pieces of good news attached to that …

Tuesdays Aren't Just For Tacos

I asked Google what pirates used to eat back in the day and it said hardtack, salted meats, and dried beans. Mmmm … sounds awful!

Monday Picks and Analysis So Far

As we get ready to kick off a new week I figured it would be a good time to look at the season so far.

Drunk Sunday Plundering

Sunday's Pitch Mix Picks (at the right time this time)

All Rise For Your Saturday!

All rise for Judge’s first appearance in the Pitch Mix Picks!

Drunk Sunday Plundering

Am I ACTUALLY drunk while writing this? Maybe! Or maybe I’m “just drunk enough to nail all these plays!”

Quick Plunder Update: Weather Issues

Happy Friday all! Wanted to pass along a quick CAUTION update from today’s picks … the weather looks kinda lousy for both Kerry Carpenter and Bobby Witt....

It's Friday, We're In Love!

Let's do Friday money things!

PREMIUM RESEND: Time to Go to Gambling School

$ · April 3, 2025

Quick reminder: This email goes out every morning by 8a (eastern). If you don’t have it by then, something is going on with the service. If anything looks...

Time to Go to Gambling School

Now that we have about a week under our belts, I’ve been running though questions, thoughts and observations from you wonderful scallywags.

Let's Get Over the Hump (Day)

It’s not ALL the data we want, but today is the first day we get to at least look at a slate of pitchers who have a start under their belt.

No Foolin' Around Here

No pranks here—just solid data and picks to amp up your April betting game!

The Storm!! AHHHHH!!!! THE STOOOORRRRM!!!

Packed with daily picks, banking tips, and a dash of humor, I'm ready to roll for today's games!

The Calm Before the STORM!

Get ready for a storm of picks targeting subpar pitchers tomorrow!

Opening Weekend in Plunderville

April's a learning curve in baseball; Ohtani's a must-pick as we navigate this tricky month!

What'cha Gonna Do When Day 2 Rumbles on YOU?

$ · March 28, 2025

Day two ya bitches!

Quick Opening Day Update: What I'm Playin'

$ · March 27, 2025

Afternoon all! I won’t be able to do this every day, but since it’s day one I wanted to give you a quick peek behind the curtain of the kinds of plays I’m...

It's Opening Day in Plunderville!

Opening Day brings two free plays, premium picks, and a 15% discount that ends tonight!

Who's Ready for Some TOKYO GREEN? 💰

Dive into the excitement of the Tokyo Series with betting insights and early-season triumphs!

Tokyo Series: A Plunderiffic Day 2!

Day 2 brings exciting MLB insights, picks, and transparency as we gear up for the season!

Let's Plunder the Tokyo Series!

Get ready for thrilling Tokyo Series action and my top MLB picks for winning big this season!

We're Gonna Have a SMASHING Good Time!

Had a wild week with my car but scored big on MLB picks—ended up +8.48u! 🏴‍☠️⚾️

What Will Plunder's Pitch Mix Picks Actually Look Like?

Get ready for the season with my data-driven picks to boost your betting game!

Welcome to Plunder's Pitch Mix Plays!

$ · March 8, 2025

Ahoy mateys! Who’s ready for baseball season, a healthy amount of pirate-related puns and a nice healthy GREEN bankroll? Let’s do this!!! Time to Plunder...