Archive (Page 2) • Plunder's Pitch Mix Picks • Buttondown

Quick Plunder Update: More changes

September 9, 2025

Quick update for 9/9 … Couple more changes for today (that kinda day) … Bobby Witt is battling a back issue so he’s probably outRed Sox starter has been...

Quick Plunder Update: No Turner

$ · September 9, 2025

Quick update for 9/9 … Morning! I missed the Trea Turner hit the IL with a bad hammy yesterday … so he’s obviously off the list. Apologies! Have a GREEN day!

I Know You Are, But What Am I?

September 9, 2025

We going deep in the pocket for this Buxton reference, but IYKYK and I’ll give you a shiny pirate dubloon if you figure it out. LFG!

Messin' With Pasquatch

September 8, 2025

Case of the Mondays? Not here!

September 7, 2025

First NFL Sunday means a tumbleweed might roll thru a baseball field today and nobody will notice, but we gots ourselves some plays to attack!

Happ-y Gilmore 2

September 6, 2025

Another windy day at Wrigley? Let’s roll it back!

September 5, 2025

Bunch of solid plays to take us into the weekend!

Jo Ho Ho and a Bottle of Rum

September 4, 2025

Short slate today so I’m putting all the plays outside of the paywall. Let’s GOOOOO!!!

Juan More Chance

September 3, 2025

Lots of really solid options to explore today.

Stanton Ovation

September 2, 2025

Let’s GOOOOOOO!!!!

September 1, 2025

It ain’t Halloween, but we’d like some treats in our goodie bag. Bumpy weekend so we are keeping the list tight

Devers Ever After

August 31, 2025

Sunday Funday anyone?

Quick Plunder Update: Typo

August 30, 2025

Quick update for 8/30 … Morning! Gotta correct my typo … Rice is facing Shane Smith and not Jake Irvin. All numbers are correct. Thanks!

August 30, 2025

Word to YOUR mutha! Much higher confidence on today’s picks vs. yesterday when everything terrified me.

Rub For Your Lives!

August 29, 2025

Lord have mercy on all of us … my top two picks are guys that love to never com thru when I play them.

The Master Bader

August 28, 2025

Short slate today (that’s what she said).

Big Philly Style?

August 27, 2025

Another showdown at Citi Field? Let’s GO!!!

August 26, 2025

Adele … meet Adell. And now that we’ve gotten the introductions out of the way, let’s have a Dinger Tuesday!

I'm Still Stanton

August 25, 2025

Sunday didn’t quite deliver as much as I had wanted. Had some bright spots, but would’ve loved an all out smasheroo.

August 24, 2025

Really liking the list today … lots of strong plays that check all the boxes. LFG!!!!

One Man's Trash is a Another Man's ... Well ... Trash

August 23, 2025

If you can identify the movie below I will give you one billion bonus Plunder points and my love and admiration forever.

Tommy Want Wingy

August 22, 2025

When Tommy Pham is my top play of the day I’m immediately thinking that the day is going to be crazy.

August 21, 2025

Hey … anybody wanna start the weekend early and have ourselves a DAY?? OK … let’s do it!!!

OK ... Who Killed the Puppy?

August 20, 2025

Have you seen the way Michael Harris has been swinging the baseball this week? The guy is like a man possessed!

August 19, 2025

Here’s to a nice sexy list of cashes today … lots of spots to exploit.

Harris My Mind?

August 18, 2025

Hey look … my email works again! Now you get all the flashy bells and whistles again.

Plunder Email: Stripped Down Version #2

August 17, 2025

Morning! Emails still being tempermental today but I can at least share the full data with you for the plays.

Plunder Email: Stripped Down Version

August 16, 2025

Morning! I am having some technical issues with the service that runs these emails and haven’t been able to put together the normal layout. So today we have...

Quick Plunder Update: Couple Pitching Changes

August 15, 2025

Quick update for 8/15 … Happy Friday! Urena is no longer starting for the Twins. I still think Carpenter and Greene are in play. Fedde is out for Atlanta and...

The Walrus and the Carpenter

August 15, 2025

Keeping this list tight and bright has served us well this month, so we are gonna keep that method rolling again today.

Quick Plunder Update: Some Adds/Drops

$ · August 14, 2025

Quick update for 8/14 … Afternoon! Pulling off Mauricio for today (if he even plays) … adding action on Michael Harris who’s on fire and Brandon Marsh (who...

Kyle and the Big Dumper

August 14, 2025

I mean I don’t know about you, but that totally sounds like the title of a children’s book.

Buehler ... Buehler ... Buehler?

August 13, 2025

Quick observation for today … the numbers look good, but the players are all kinda mid-level talent.

August 12, 2025

Big ol’ list of plays today for a full slate!

Return of the Max

August 11, 2025

Had a banger of a day yesterday and a solid weekend throughout. Let’s keep it going!!!

Kerry On My Wayward Son

August 10, 2025

Apologies for the delay today … let’s get right into the plays for Saturday, August 10th

Oh man … now I’m gonna go have to listen to “Meet Me Halfway” by Kenny Loggins and yell “Over the top Dad!!” in my front yard till the neighbors call the cops.

What Kurtz the Most

Happy Friday … let’s have ourselves a BANGER of a weekend!!!

Shea and His Langoliers

Anybody else remember this creepy made for TV movie based on a Steven King novel and starring the guy who played Balki on “Perfect Strangers?”

Free Willy (and Maybe Free Wilmer)

Let’s dive into the plays for Wednesday, August 6th

Vladi Da Di, We Like to Party

Solid crop of plays for Tuesday, August 5th.

We're Killing Independent George!

We have a really nice tight list of strong plays today. Let’s start the week off with a hammer!

Let's Cut Through the Crap, Vaughn

Any day I can cram a “Major League” reference into this email is a good one. Let’s have a DAY!!!!

Nuf Ced McGreevy

July was an up and down slog … let’s turn the page and start August out STRONG!!!!

Got Your Trade Deadline Flow Charts Handy?

Welcome to the post trade deadline frenzy! Now we just gotta figure out who the hell is on what team and who the hell is pitching.

Cal It a Light Day

Very small slate today with only three games, so I have some options for each for both hitter and pitcher props.

Springer Flinger

Fair warning … the next couple days are gonna be all over the place courtesy of the trade deadline.

The Kurtz of Oak Island

Man … that Nick Kurtz pun would’ve been even better if the A’s were still in Oakland. That said, what fool still watches that ridiculous TV show?

World Schwarbs Three

Happy Monday everybody! I hope you enjoyed “Free Everything Week.” Just a reminder you can lock in the final three months of the season for only $40, which is like a savings of 247,000,000% or something like that.

The Roman Empire

It’s the final Free Everything Day! Hopefully you’ve enjoyed the extra content and it has helped you make the big ol’ bucks.