Lots to Gain logo

Lots to Gain

Subscribe
Archives
  Back to the email
Ethan McCutchen
Sep. 29, 2025, afternoon

It does lead to a lot of questions, but those questions are generally easier where mini-publics are institutionalized. In the Ostbelgien model, for example, a permanent assembly calls ad hoc ones, so it's clear that the convening itself is democratic. And I think much richer patterns could evolve.

I realized last week I had left out a significant point in this post about Congress's willingness to respect constraints imposed by state applications (and that it may be a long time before I got back this far into the weeds again). So I added this to the version in the archive:

And if Congress were to argue that states could not constrain conventions, they'd create quite a legal pickle for themselves. As we saw, their argument for not having called any conventions yet is that they were respecting the constraints the state applications imposed.

I mean...right?!

Fwiw, I have a couple of posts coming on next steps in this realm. It's taking me a while to get to something actionable, but we're getting there!

Reply Report Delete

Deleting this comment will remove it from the email, and will also delete any replies to it.

Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.