Meeting the Moment

Meeting the Moment

Archives
Liminal
Unbreaking
Log in
Subscribe
November 20, 2026

Year 2, Week 47

Nov 14-20 – practical actions

Hello friends,
The best hour I spent today featured Claudia Polsky and Erwin Chemerinsky telling the inside story of their landmark class action lawsuit on behalf of University of California researchers whose grants were terminated last year. I’ve got the latest update on that case in the bullets below, but just want to open with a celebration of the people throwing everything they’ve got into principled fights. In this case alone, an unusual team of more than 15 pro bono lawyers1 has already logged more than 6,000 hours. And they’re not just winning in court, either, they’re helping other teams build on what they’re doing. I’ve been using this newsletter to argue against capitulation from the beginning and, to quote Polsky, make the point that “resistance is the right thing to do, not just morally, but practically.”

This was Year 2, Week 47. Let’s get into it.

What’s happening in science & higher ed

  • Good news first: Federal Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV issued a final ruling killing the proposed four-year cap on international student visas. The administration’s proposal, “is arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, and otherwise not in accordance with law,” but its appeal from the preliminary injunction is still pending.

  • More good news this week, The Supreme Court, with no public dissent or comment, refused to review the decision of a lower court to reinstate hundreds of cancelled grants to University of California researchers.2 The case in question, Thakur v. Trump, is a particularly important case because (among other things) it argues that grant terminations based on keyword searches are viewpoint discrimination and therefore violate scientists’ First Amendment rights.3 Although this is not the final word,4 it has significance for other related cases, including another recent class action lawsuit (Salles vs NIH) brought against the NIH.

  • Eva Yi Xie, a Princeton graduate student, was intercepted and detained by ICE yesterday while she was traveling home after SFN.5 Her advisors have publicly sought help. The Dean of the Graduate School announced that Princeton has arranged legal representation for her and Senator Andy Kim’s office confirms that they’re working on her case, while SFN offers thoughts and prayers. A judge has already ordered ICE not to transfer her away from where she’s currently held in Virginia6 and to respond to her legal team’s petition for habeas corpus. I hope she is released immediately - along with everyone else, regardless of how powerful their professional networks are. Dr. Ann Lawani remains on my mind, for example. She remains in custody along with tens of thousands of other people who have been hidden from ICE locator databases. National Nurses United7 accuses ICE of deliberately concealing Lawani’s location to deprive her of representation. These conditions are front of mind for me when I read coverage of collapsing international student enrollment.8 I’m currently incubating a PI-led project to help mentors navigate the financial, legal, academic, and practical needs of their international trainees. If you can contribute to a resource guide, or know of folks we should be in conversation with, please reach out.

  • The NYT reports that the IRS has opened criminal investigations into four left-wing groups for “domestic terrorism” and referred at least four for financial audit. Details are currently scarce: we do not know the targets, but last year’s Bondi memo to federal prosecutors emphasized “extreme” views on immigration, race, or gender and those with objections to “traditional American views on family, religion, and morality”. The administration’s plans to weaponize tax enforcement infrastructure against political opponents has been a major and ongoing concern. I find myself wondering, for example, how the Ford Foundation’s (exciting!) new strategic direction will play out in this threat landscape.

  • Russell Vought’s Deputy Director Eric Ueland has been nominated to a pivotal role leading the GAO.9 His incredibly rushed hearing on Thursday is at profound odds with what you’d expect for an appointment that would last 15 years. He looked likely headed to a confirmation vote but Senator Thom Tillis (R-NC) has placed a hold on his nomination, which substantially slows the process and may kill the nomination in this lame duck session.

  • On the climate front, every mention of fossil fuels was removed from the overarching agreement10 for COP31 this week. The negotiations also seem to have failed to make progress on the financing of billions of dollars promised to low- and middle-income countries11 adapting to our changing climate.

  • The Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown, Iowa has postponed its plan to deliberately explode several tons of unstable munitions. The detonation might break windows, so local people are facing evacuations and the closure of schools in advance of what is planned to be a 25 mile-long plume of toxic lead dust affecting homes, farmland, and waterways including the Mississippi river. The EPA and DOJ are locked in a legal fight with the Iowa Environmental Council and the Sierra Club and no one knows whether the blasts will now happen on Monday or not.

  • And tragically, the beloved Cincinnati zoo hippo Fiona has died.12

And what’s next

Things I’m reading, looking forward to, or keeping tabs on:

  • Anthropic made its historic IPO yesterday. After today’s declines in the markets, I’ll be watching the (increasingly dire) headlines13 and trying to figure out if this is the typical instability of our “new normal” or the beginning of something much worse. I find myself wondering about the exposures of university investment portfolios, for example, and would welcome reading suggestions.

  • I’ll be looking for follow-up from this week’s meeting of the US Preventive Services Task Force, which has been hollowed out by HHS Secretary Kennedy.

  • Finally, I tend to think about four non-exclusive categories14 of anti-authoritarian work: disruption and disobedience, defending institutions, protecting people, and creating alternatives. I opened this issue with a focus on those fighting for researchers and the integrity of scientific funding. I want to end it with a celebration of people building new infrastructure and working to defend civic institutions. One upcoming opportunity, for example, is the upcoming Digital Day of Action (PDF) on December 9th planned by Partnership for Public Service.

I am finding it hard not to worry about cascading failures, and spent the first half of the week flinching at each new banking disruption and digital system outage. I initially coped with it by taking the kind of sensible measures that make sense for any kind of emergency preparations (like having some cash on hand). But at the root of it, I realized that some of my anxiety has to do with what it means to be the person who is the perpetual bearer of so much bad news. I imagine that if you read this newsletter week in and week out, you’re probably in the same boat.

That’s why celebrating the wins and sharing the stories of perseverance matter so much. I can’t stand glib soundbites: I prefer much more complicated versions of the notion of joy as resistance. But I do hope you can let yourself dance if you want to, rest if you need to, and keep at it if you can.

Liz


As ever, thanks for reading & thinking with me!

This work is supported in part by Solving For Science. Meeting the Moment will always be free, but if you want to contribute, you can ⤵️*

set up a subscription

If this email was forwarded to you, hi! 👋 I write briefings on the week’s news for those of us who care about science and higher education. If you like what you see ⤵️

you can get this delivered weekly

  1. Polsky originated and organized the suit, but had not litigated a class action lawsuit before. She recruited Chemerinsky, who then brought in Farella Braun + Martel. ↩

  2. You might hear or see this described as “denied cert” which refers to Writs of Certiorari, which are orders that compel lower courts to send case records for the Supreme Court justices to review. ↩

  3. This is in contrast to other successful legal strategies, many of which to date have hinged on Trump administration violations of the Administrative Procedures Act. I’m out at the limits of my own understanding, but I’m worried about whether the APA will be defanged early next year. ↩

  4. The lower court ruled that plaintiffs are likely to succeed, but has note yet made a final ruling ↩

  5. Society for Neuroscience - https://www.sfn.org ↩

  6. Chantilly, VA to be specific. I am not up to speed on the latest, but in fall 2025 the field office there was described as a “makeshift detention facility” where detainees, “are deprived of access to food and water, do not have adequate sleeping quarters and are sleeping on the floor with makeshift blankets, are denied medical care, and are subjected to unsanitary and degrading conditions,” ↩

  7. This country’s largest union of registered nurses - https://www.nationalnursesunited.org ↩

  8. See also the new American Association of Medical Colleges report on federal disruptions of biomedical research training programs (PDF). ↩

  9. Government Accountability Office - https://www.gao.gov ↩

  10. The official term is “cover decision” and I have probably explained it badly. I can’t vouch for it, but I thought this perspective by Ghazali Ohorella was interesting. ↩

  11. See this World Bank argument for why this is a better term than “developing countries.” ↩

  12. If you’re in the mood, I learned quite a lot about why we can’t do surgery on hippos from this thread and responses to it. Sometimes social media is amazing. ↩

  13. e.g. The Financial Times just published, “US tech stocks plunge into bear market in worst week since Covid-19 crisis” ↩

  14. Credit to Daniel Hunter. ↩

Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to Meeting the Moment:
Continue the conversation:
Older → Year 2, Week 46
Share this email:
Share on LinkedIn Share on Bluesky
Bluesky
LinkedIn
LIMINAL
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.