Elaine Perlman Responds to Caleb
Excellent article by Caleb. There is already a bipartisan bill before Congress that would put the central idea he describes to a real-world test: the End Kidney Deaths Act (EKDA, H.R. 2687). It would provide a refundable $10,000-a-year tax credit for five years to Americans who donate a kidney to a stranger, as part of a 10-year pilot program.
Reason readers may remember that Ilya Somin wrote about EKDA here in April 2025, calling it a major improvement over the status quo even while arguing that a fully legal organ market would go further. And Caleb himself made the fiscal case for increasing living kidney donation in National Review last year, pointing to the enormous cost of keeping patients on dialysis.
EKDA offers Congress a practical next step: test whether substantial, government-administered compensation can increase nondirected kidney donation while retaining the safeguards of the existing transplant system. Rather than continuing to debate compensation only in theory, we can collect real-world evidence about whether it saves lives, shortens the kidney shortage, and reduces taxpayer spending.
Reason has now helped make the case for compensating kidney donors multiple times. The End Kidney Deaths Act gives Congress an opportunity to find out how well that idea works in practice.
-
Great step going forward. Thank you for sharing
-
As a kidney translant recipient, blood cancer survivor and HUGE advocate for this sensible legislation I have one question for opponents of legislation that will save thousands of lives and billions of dollars. Here's the question. Our nation gives tax credits for electric vehicles and solar panels in order to help our nation environmentally. Why in the world would anyone oppose giving someone a task credit for sharing their spare kidney and saving another's life? What value to we put on human life? Drive for Five salutes Elaine and everyone working their butts off to educate folks. Donating an organ is not easy for a living donor but there are plenty of people available. We could virtually wipe out the kidney transplant need with this legislation. Come on folks, this is a no brainer and will help us fight back against our nation's growing kidney crisis.
-
Sorry for the typos. I didn't edit before sending. My bad.
-
Golly, the more I look into this, the more sense the EKDA makes; not just lives, but lots of tax-payer money!
-
Go for it.
Reply: