ARTchivist's Notebook: A Survey for Book Lovers
Why criticism is important, especially now, and a call for help with a survey on book reviews.

If you’ve been an ARTchivist’s Notebook subscriber for any length of time, you know that I’m a critic — of art, archives, museums, movies, AI, what-have-you. You also probably know that I’ve been studying critics for several years, in a series of reports for Critical Minded, a grantmaking and learning initiative focused on supporting critics and writers.
Why do critics need to be studied? As the growing forces of fascism in the US increasingly demand fealty to a narrow, homogeneous, repressive vision of what it means to be a human in this world, we need to support and value folks who are willing to speak up, to point out when something is demeaning, hurtful, destructive, exclusionary, and to venture how it could be otherwise. We can learn a lot from critics, who are adept at reporting on such squishy things as feelings, values, and tastes, and listening to that inner compass that tells us when something just feels wrong. We need more of that right now, especially on the verge of a consequential election. Critical Minded is studying critics to better support them and ensure their voices continue to be heard now and into the future.
The next report I’m working on focuses on book critics, and we want to hear, not only from folks who review books, but also those who consume reviews or criticism. We want to understand both the experiences and challenges faced by book reviewers, and the impact their work has on others. Of course, as a critic, I think criticism is important (for the reasons given above and so many others); I also want to know if and how it matters to you.
If you read, watch, or listen to book reviews, on any platform (BookTok, Bookstagram, GoodReads, Amazon, etc., or any good ol’ fashioned media), I hope you’ll consider taking our survey. All responses are anonymous and it takes less than 10 minutes. (You would also really be helping me out!😀)
Please take the survey here. Thank you!
News & Opportunities
Cultivating Support for Arts & Culture Journalism
I’m helping to organize this online convening, Nov. 17, 3:00 - 4:15pm ET presenting the report, Support for Arts and Culture Journalism. Based on a survey of 141 independent US publications that cover arts and culture, the report explores the impact of recent funding shifts and free-speech pressures. This presentation will be followed by a panel discussion with publishers sharing their experiences and insights on how to keep arts and culture journalism vibrant, relevant, and sustainable. RSVP by Nov. 13.
Museums Moving Forward Data Study Staff Survey
It seems it is the season of surveys! Museums Moving Forward is doing their own data gathering for a report on workplace equity in museums. If you work on staff at a US art museum, please take their survey.