Well Sourced by Kelly Jensen

Well Sourced by Kelly Jensen

Archives
Subscribe
November 14, 2026

The Rise of Theatrical Censorship

It's not just books being banned. Student theatrical performance cancellations are also on the rise.

We have documentation about the rise of book bans since early 2021. But one arena that hasn’t gotten quite the same level of coverage is another form of literature and the arts seeing censorship: student theatrical performance. It’s been especially noteworthy this year, and while there’s hope that the change of political season will help slow down all forms of literary censorship, the reality is that the growth will likely spur even more growth in the coming years. Those who’ve been aggrieved already will push harder.

Back in fall 2023, a friend pinged me to let me know there was a situation unfolding in our neck of the woods. A local high school had been told they could not put on their spring performance of The Prom. It wasn’t because of the LGBTQ+ themes. At least, that wasn’t the explicit reasoning. The explanation was that the district administration wanted to make sure the kids would be safe given the level of attention they’d receive, and they didn’t think they had the security resources to do that.

After pushback from the community–really, the public comment session starting at minute 30 here showcases an entire community showing up and asking what the district was thinking–the play was allowed to move forward for the spring.

That was 2023. There’ve been plays canceled between then and now, but nothing like what we’ve seen happen in the last few months. The number may not be large, but in context, three is a noteworthy trend. Like book bans, reporting on the cancellation of student plays suffers the same fate. There are too few local news reporters covering local beats and stories; too often, there’s no reporting on the issue at all. These three stories, however, made local news and both regional and national news, too.*

Watertown Unified School District (WI)

If Watertown, Wisconsin, sounds familiar, there’s good reason. Last fall, the school board voted to remove the song “Mother of a Revolution” from the spring band concert because of its ties to queer and trans history. Students protested the decision, which the board made with little hedging around their bigotry. They believed the song, about the Stonewall Uprising and honoring trans activist Marsha P. Johnson, violated the district’s controversial issues policy. Students protested, and it made headlines nationwide as other venues and outlets statewide offered to host the students for their full, uncensored performance.

Watertown’s leadership decided that wasn’t enough.

This fall, the interim superintendent elected to “not proceed”–note the inability to use the word “cancel” here–with the spring musical Flashdance. Rather than reading or researching the high school edition of the performance, that superintendent called the show “X-rated.” Though the play has the same name as the film–which is R-rated, not X-rated–it is not the same show. The director at the school also worked to ensure that every aspect of the performance would be age-appropriate.

There’s a really interesting discussion about this particular version of the show in a Facebook thread for the OnStage blog, a site for theater fans. In the comments, they noted that the district would be doing something wrong by performing the show with changes made to the script.

They then followed up that comment with this:

UPDATE (9/28/26) - Since publishing this piece, I learned something important that changes part of my original argument.

The changes Watertown High School planned to make to Flashdance WERE apparently approved by the show’s rights holder.

I initially questioned whether the school could legally make significant changes to the material just to make the show more appropriate for a high school audience. Normally, you cannot simply rewrite a licensed musical because there are parts you do not like.

But if the rights holder approved these changes, then that criticism does not apply here.

It also changes how I look at this situation.

Ryan Moldenhaur was not secretly rewriting Flashdance on his own. He had apparently gone through the proper channels, received permission to make changes, and was working toward a version he believed could be appropriate for their students.

The principal, Jason Widiker, had also approved the production.

The superintendent still canceled it.

A LOT of work and effort went into ensuring the show would be appropriate for students and attendees. This wasn’t done to continue bringing attention to the district, though the superintendent’s decision certainly did.

Students protested this decision.

The district has not yet announced what the new spring show will be, and I can’t find the information on their website either. There’s nothing in the most recent board meeting minutes from October, though at least one person in the public comments continued to address the situation. 

Copley-Fairlawn City School District (Ohio)

The Copley High School Thespian Society was excited when they learned their fall production this year would be She Kills Monsters, a play written by Qui Nguyen. The show is a coming-of-age story that wrestles with topics like grief, friendship, family, and queerness, and what made it particularly special for the group was its setting in Athens, Ohio–about three hours south of Copley. The central character in the story is queer, and for the president of the Copley Thespian Society, that was a huge deal, especially because the portrayal is positive.

Unfortunately for the students, the show was canceled by the school’s district leadership right as rehearsals began. 

Reporting on why the play was canceled, of course, differs depending on who is telling the story. Per this piece at WKYC, administrators had already approved the play early on, which is how the theater department secured rights, conducted auditions, and planned rehearsals. The cancellation came after a parent complained about the queer themes in the story. In that same piece, the district claims it did not complete its normal review process initially and that the cancellation was administrative. 

Students then had to scramble to get rights to another play for the fall (which was Alice in Wonderland). As this was happening, the group’s president ran a GoFundMe campaign because a local theater offered to let them use their space for the show, and the group needed to pay for rights to the original show. They raised nearly $10,000. 

After word about the cancellation got out, Carrie Coon called members of the Copley Thespian Society. Coon is an alumna of the school and an Emmy- and Tony-nominated actress.  She donated $1,000 to the student actors' fundraiser. 

The publicity the school and its leadership received after their decision to cancel the show was not good. The community showed up for these kids, and many pointed out that the same play had been produced at high schools nearby without this kind of response. Others noted that students were excited to perform something diverse and inclusive that really resonated with them. 

A couple of weeks ago, the superintendent developed a “compromise” regarding the performance. The school’s space could be used for She Kills Monsters, but the school itself could not produce it –in other words, a local theater company could lead students through the performance in the school’s space, but it couldn’t be the school’s production. The school’s production director is a contract employee, so she’s still able to produce and direct the show, but it has to be outside of her contractual obligations. 

Grand Prairie Independent School District (TX)

Texas school leaders have bowed to pressures from the state’s suite of new anti-DEI, anti-literature, anti-education laws over the last couple of years. The two biggest culprits for K-12 education censorship and the raiding of public school and classroom libraries have been Senate Bill 12 and Senate Bill 13.

In Grand Prairie, administrators claimed that due to Senate Bill 12, they had to shut down production of the December performance of Little Shop of Horrors after a week of rehearsals. No, it wasn’t because of the bloodthirsty, man-eating plant.

It was because a girl was performing the lead character in the school’s performance.

Reiterating: in a theatrical performance of a show about a bloodthirsty, man-eating plant, the problem was that the lead character was being played by a girl rather than a boy, per the script.

The girl cast as the lead, Ana Mota, was offered a different role in the performance so that it could continue. She–as she should–declined the offer. She’d have to take a secondary role and share it with another student. Not only would she be giving up the lead she’d earned, but she hadn’t auditioned for the other part.

The show was canceled in response and is being replaced by Frozen.

This story takes a particularly good twist, and it will be fascinating to watch play out in the coming months. Mota sued the school for discrimination in response. The lawsuit emphasizes that Senate Bill 12 doesn’t mean that she can’t play the FICTIONAL role of a play as someone of a different gender than the FICTIONAL character in its publication. The parents in this lawsuit were really savvy, too, noting that their parental rights were undermined by the district’s decision. They said it was okay for their daughter to have this role.

As Howard Sherman writes:

In the filing, by attorney Jonathan Winocour for Ana Mota “by and through her parents and next friends Nancy Jimenez-Mota and Rafael Mota,” the arguments rebut the suggestion that casting Ana in a male role somehow runs afoul of Texas law SB12. It states that there is no language in the law which “requires actors in school productions to match the biological sex of the fictional character they portray,” that Ana was simply playing a role and not “engaged in a personal gender transition,” that Seymour was to remain a male character and that cross-sex casting has a long tradition in the theatre, and that nothing in the production of the play constituted “policy, procedure, training, activity, or program that references gender identity or sexual orientation.”

Grand Prairie administrators would lose it if they learned about Shakespeare, but we know Shakespeare has also been targeted during this era of literary policing and literate-starved censors.

Given the regime change about to happen in Texas, it’ll be interesting to see what happens here. It isn’t a stretch of the imagination to think that bills like SB 12 and SB 13, which the state has wielded to whip districts into compliance with any host of discriminatory and harmful actions, will be weakened. This kind of lawsuit will cost the district time and money that should not be wasted on such legal cases–and yet, the state set them up for this very thing.

These are three examples that got some good coverage. But they aren’t the only examples of canceled and censored theater in the latter half of 2026. One person got a performance of Rocky Horror Picture Show canceled in an Idaho community theater (yes, it was about it being “obscene”). Tallahassee State College canceled all of its theater classes and plays abruptly at the start of the semester. Ocean County Vocational Technical School (NJ) canceled a Holocaust themed play based on a Todd Strasser novel.

Students who have cell phones or laptops have ready access to pornography in their pockets or bedrooms, not to mention ready access to any other topic they’re interested in, curious about, or have heard about from their peers at school. Even the best filters are imperfect, allowing any kinds of content to slip through them and into the eyes, ears, and minds of the tech user. That we’re seeing theatrical performances like these canceled over the possibility of queer people being normalized or girls–gasp–playing a fictional role that was originally written with a male in it is absurd.

It’s a manufactured panic with no winners and a hell of a lot of losers. What is the point of denying students the ability to act in a show which is opt-in and by which no other students are forced to partake?

Nothing but power wielding, hate mongering, and/or sheer cowardice.

In some cases, it’s all three.

Notes

*I knew about all three of these stories through my weekly censorship news roundups, as they’ve all popped up in those searches. I found far more information about them while writing this, and I was happy to see the robust writing on theater and the arts by Howard Sherman on his Substack, Downstage Center. There’s likewise some solid writing about theater and the arts–including some coverage of these stories, as cited above–in the OnStage Blog. It appears that, as with book censorship, coverage of theater censorship appears in smaller publications that reach a fervent readership but not the kind of widespread audience it deserves.

Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to Well Sourced by Kelly Jensen:
Older → A Not-So-Happy Halloween of Banned Horror Books
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.