Tangible Tuesday #21 A Touchy Subject
Your body, or at least mine, is a bag of salty water, which makes your skin an input. How capacitive touch replaced buttons, why Volkswagen apologized for it, and how SawStop and 3D-printed "Prinjection" put it to better use.
> Tangible Tuesday is a free newsletter for the upcoming book Designing the Tangible Interface. Past issues in the Archives > > Please share this email to someone who would enjoy it!
Tuesday Tune: Fall In to Me (feat. Ben Hadwen) by Emanative
Buttons and switches are easy to see, but engineers are very clever inventing new ways to make a button that solves specific problems.
- Photoresistors are very cheap; a “button” could be activated when a finger covers it, assuming there is always some ambient light.
- Hall sensors and reed switches are activated by magnets, which is handy when the switch needs to be sealed. An underwater button can be made from soft rubber embedded with a small magnet. (More in Why the Hall Sensor Took Over the World.)
The most common invisible button, though, uses you as part of the circuit.
Capacitive Touch
Touchscreens used to have a very poor reputation as they required hard strikes on the glass, or had a mushy feel. They have mostly been replaced with the newer capacitive touch surfaces.
Capacitive touch runs on a simple fact: bodies made of salty water — yours included — conduct electricity. A touchscreen holds a faint electric field across a grid of electrodes, and a finger close enough to that field draws off a measurable sliver of charge. The controller scans the grid and reads exactly where that charge went missing. Capacitive unlocked the modern touchscreen because it could detect multiple touches, enabling pinch-to-zoom for maps. The tradeoff was needing skin contact; gloves need special metal fibers in the fingertips.
As devices get smarter, the cheapness and durability of capacitive touch make it widely used as a replacement for physical buttons. This trend has much potential, but also has been the cause of significant user frustration. In 2023, the CEO of Volkswagen apologized to its customers for the design of its vehicle controls. Much focus has been on the touchscreen, but the use of black plastic capacitive “buttons” was widely disliked. These buttons had no movement to let the person know they had been clicked, and the common behavior of lightly touching a button to locate it before clicking was lost. (The full story is in The Rise and Fall of Car Touchscreens.)
Capacitive Touch continues to be an area of development. Disney Research developed Touché, a Swept Frequency Capacitive Sensing technique that can not only detect a touch event but also recognize complex configurations of the human hands and body.1
One striking application turns the same principle into a safety device: the SawStop table saw uses the spinning blade itself as a capacitive sensor.
Sparr Risher, via Flickr, CC BY-SA 2.0