SBN's Editing Tips

Archives
May 15, 2026

Discovery Writer or Plotter?

Woman Business Work - Free photo on Pixabay

You may have heard the term “pantser,” as in one who writes by the seat of her pants. Like many other writers, I prefer the term discovery writer, which, to me, sounds more purposeful.

You may identify as either a plotter or a discover writer. However, I seen this as a sliding scale.

A discovery writer doesn’t open a new Word doc with absolutely no idea what she wants to write and expect to create a 75,000-word novel. At least that’s highly unlikely.

And only the most detail-oriented plotters create outlines that include the entire skeleton of the manuscript down to the stapes (the smallest bone in the human body).

Several years ago, I had an idea for a speculative fiction story, but it wasn’t until it dawned on me to make the main character a young woman about to become her nation’s ruling princess that I became excited about how the story would unfold.

And because I love to surprise myself while I write, I completed approximately half the story until I found myself uncertain as to where to go next.

At this point, I wrote the last chapter.

Why would I do that?

Because then I knew I had to get my MC from where she was to that final scene.

To further help me plot my course, I’ve begun to create a list of things that have to happen in the as-yet unwritten chapters.

I may or may not write one or two sentences summarizing these chapters. But even if I do, there will still be lots of surprising discoveries along the way. Those discoveries keep me motivated to keep writing.

Therefore, when it comes to fiction, I would refer to myself as a discovery writer who, when necessary, creates a high-level outline to keep me moving forward.

When it comes to nonfiction, however, I need more structure. Far earlier in the process will I ask myself the following questions:

  1. Who is my target audience?

  2. Do I want to encourage, challenge, or instruct readers?

  3. What author voice will I use? Casual or academic? Down-to-earth or authoritative? Lighthearted or serious?

  4. Do I want to include anecdotes? If so, where will I find them?

  5. Where will I publish my work?

Although I can’t foresee ever creating an extensive outline, I would likely know far more about a nonfiction project than a work of fiction.

How about you? Are you a discovery writer or a plotter? What do you want to know before setting out to write your first draft? What details do you include in your outline when plotting your work?

Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to SBN's Editing Tips:

Add a comment:

You're not signed in. Posting this comment will subscribe you to this newsletter with the email address you enter below.
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.