Plunder's Pitch Mix Picks

Subscribe
Archives
May 9, 2025

OK May, You Can Cut It Out Now

Lots of really solid plays on tap for today, so let’s have ourselves a DAY!!!!

Quick reminder: This email goes out every morning by 8a (eastern). If you don’t have it by then, something is going on with the service. If anything looks weird on your end, please email me directly at plundertheunder@gmail.com

Good lord May has been less than ideal so far. We’ll get a little breakthru every now and then, but consistent sustained days of green have been eluding us. But we shall stay the course and steer this dang pirate ship to the treasure. Lots of really solid plays on tap for today, so let’s have ourselves a DAY!!!!

NOTE: Several unconfirmed starters as a write this, so make sure to check the probables before making any wagers.

Let’s jump into the plays for Friday, May 9th. Reminder SIGN UP FOR PREMIUM (if ya ain’t already) to get the full list.

✅ TOP PICKS ✅

  • Kyle Schwarber (PHI) vs. Gavin Williams [GRADE: A]

H/AB

AVG

wOBA

ISO

ExitVelo

HardHit%

8-22

.364

.431

.455

99.8

78.95%

Schwarbs is also batting .400 this week so that’s an added bonus, and Williams is worse against lefties for an even more added bonuserer type thingie.

TARGET MARKETS: H+R+R/TB (1u), HR (0.3u-0.5u for boosts and such)

Quick note on the Target Markets section: These are the markets I’m going to be line/promo shopping for when the markets open up. Sometimes I will avoid them if they’re too juicy or the odds are just garbage (-130 and worse). Unit recommendation is a general guideline, but could change based on value. Also … feel free to visit GAMBLING SCHOOL 101 for a breakdown of all markets, bankroll, risk management and more

  • Aaron Judge (NYY) vs. Oswaldo Bido [GRADE: A]

H/AB

AVG

wOBA

ISO

ExitVelo

HardHit%

34-76

.447

.485

.316

96.1

57.38

I’m not exactly re-inventing the wheel here for a guy who can hit pretty much anybody and gets to face a bad pitcher in an offense-heavy ballpark.

TARGET MARKETS: TB (1u), HR (0.3u-0.5u), hit parlays, H+R+R parlays

💰 THE RECAP 💰

These are all of our picks from Wednesday, May 7 …

✅ Shohei Ohtani: 1-2, triple, 2 runs

✅ Freddie Freeman: 3-4, 4 RBI, run

✅ Juan Soto: 2-4, 2 HR, 3 RBI, 2 runs

❌ Pete Alonso: 0-5

✅ Byron Buxton: 2-4, HR, 3 RBI, run

❌ Aaron Judge: 0-4

✅ Vlad Guerrero: 2-4, run

❌ Kerry Carpenter: 1-5

❌ Gunnar Henderson: 1-4

❌ Wyatt Langford: 0-4

Decent day!


OK friends … this is the part of the email where we move on to the PREMIUM plays. So here comes THE DREADED PAYWALL!!!!! AHHHHH!!!!!! NOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!

Want to read the full issue?
Plunderville
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.