The Household of Letters

The Household of Letters

Archives
Log in
Subscribe
November 12, 2026

Opposition to Data Centers Must Find Its Root In Our Lives

If you don't want a data center in your back yard, stop using so much computing power.

In our current political culture, community-minded citizens like me find very few signs of hope, the surprising results of the recent election notwithstanding. One such sign, however, is the widespread resistance to the construction of data centers, a movement that appears to be led from the ground up, highly localized, and increasingly successful. In many respects, such a movement might be seen to conform to the principles of the late Wendell Berry: in its substance, resistance to data centers speaks of a concern for ecological and communal health, resistance to globalization, and distrust of big-money business and politicians; in its practice, this movement appears to be governed by the local concern that Berry would seem to endorse. It has fought its fight at the level of city councils and planning board meetings rather than at a national scale, and this accounts for much of what is good in it.

Sophisticates have and will criticize the anti-data-center movement as NIMBYist and myopic. If you don't like AI, they might claim, fine; but data centers are just a normal part of modern infrastructure, critical to the internet far beyond LLMs. We need data centers for all kinds of uses, from media to offsite business tools. Opposing the construction of a data center in your neighborhood will do little to stop the expansion of these computing tools.

These critics have a valid point, although it is not the point that they think it is. They are wrong in their counsel of despair that would advise citizens of rural and suburban communities to roll over and let the alliance of big business and big government build whatever they want, wherever they want to. But they are correct that, as a movement, opposition to data centers does not go far enough.

Despite his alliance with radical movements of several types, Berry consistently argued that acts of political activism must be morally consistent with the way one lives one's life. This is not just a sort of moral rigorism but a recognition that crises of waste and destruction are not purely imposed on us by business and government, but have their roots in our wasteful and destructive ways of life. Here is how he puts it in the pungently titled essay "In Distrust of Movements":

If it is unrealistic to expect exploitative and wasteful industries to be conservers, then obviously we must lead in part the public life of complainers, petitioners, protesters, advocates, and supporters of stricter regulations and saner policies. But that is not enough. If it is unreasonable to expect a bad economy to try to become a good one, then we must go to work to build a good economy. It is appropriate that this duty should fall to us, for good economic behavior is more possible for us than it is for the great corporations with their miseducated managers and their greedy and oblivious stockholders. Because it is possible for us, we must try in every way we can to make good economic sense in our own lives, in our households, and in our communities. We must do more for ourselves and our neighbors. We must learn to spend our money with our friends and not with our enemies. But to do this, it is necessary to renew local economies, and revive the domestic arts. In seeking to change our economic use of the world, we are seeking inescapably to change our lives.

The members of any valid movement must first act in their own lives to reduce the extent to which they contribute to the problems they deplore. One cannot meaningfully deplore environmental destruction while heedlessly contributing to it. I say "heedlessly" because I do not believe it is possible to avoid contributing to our environmental problems. So those who oppose them can only form, as Berry says in "Think Little," "a convocation of the guilty."

These principles, then, lead me to my charge to the anti-data-center movement. If you do not want a data center in your backyard, you should not only oppose its construction with your local government. You should also do something to reduce your own use of remote computing power, to reduce your own reliance on data centers.

You may say, "I already don't use LLMs," and that is well and good, and indeed the bare minimum for anyone involved in this movement. But the critics are correct to point out that LLMs are not the only source of demand for data center construction. Our general reliance on the internet and on computing power drives the construction of these facilities as well. Accordingly, each of us should ask how, in our own lives, we can reduce our use of the internet in general, not just LLMs.

Streaming media is the place to start. Video streaming makes heavy use of computing power, as anyone knows who's tried to use the internet on a slow connection when someone else in the house is streaming Netflix. Each of us can do our tiny bit to reduce the demand for data centers by reducing our use of streaming media. DVDs and CDs are still widely available, often very cheap, and pleasurable to use. Although watching movies and listening to music with physical media introduces a certain amount of hassle into one's life, it also provides an array of benefits: greater ownership and privacy, simpler decision making, and closer attention to whatever you're watching or listening to.

Indeed, I suspect that there are many ways to reduce one's use of data that would also prove not abstemious, but pleasurable. I might associate the word "convenience" with such data-intensive computing tools as Zoom or OneDrive, but I can't say that the idea of pleasure comes to mind. "Smart" devices and social media are data-consuming tools which I have foregone not just comfortably but with positive joy.

If you don't want a data center in your community, you should be thinking about how to make such reductions as well. The demand for data centers has its root in our profligate and screen-mediated lives. The solution must also find its root in a renewal of life lived in the real world.

Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to The Household of Letters:
Older → Walking at the Pace of Love: A Homily
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.