Mystery AI Hype Theater 3000: The Newsletter logo

Mystery AI Hype Theater 3000: The Newsletter

Archives
Subscribe
December 25, 2025

Fresh AI Hell, Wrapped

Mystery AI Hype Theater 3000 podcast logo against a black patterned background with an audio amplitude wave on it and text above 2025 and below Wrapped
2025 Mystery AI Hype Theater, Wrapped

By Alex Hanna, Decca Muldowney, and Emily M. Bender

We’re looking back on 2025 by sharing the episodes, published this year, that recorded the most listens. If you missed any, check them out! If you’re up to date on all of these, there are also 58 others produced to date (starting in 2022) for your listening pleasure 😄 (For those who prefer watching, you can find all of the the episodes on our PeerTube) Thanks to all of our listeners for taking this journey of ridicule as praxis with us, and especially to our livestream participants whose witty contributions you can hear in most episodes!

And now, we’re happy to present to you our most listened-to episodes of the year!

Top Ten Episodes of the Year

Graphic with a screen cap of the video from episode 57, showing photos of Molnar, Hanna and Bender along the right edge and the artifact we are reacting to to the left: an article from 404 Media with the headline "Leaked: Palantir's Plan to Help ICE Deport People". Above is text reading #10 and below is the episode title (same as in the image caption). All of this is against a dark grey patterned background with abstract purple shapes reminiscent of sea creatures.
#10: Ep. 57 - The “AI”-Enabled Immigration Panopticon (with Petra Molnar)

10. Ep. 57 - The “AI”-Enabled Immigration Panopticon (with Petra Molnar)
Recorded 2025-05-05 [Livestream, Podcast, Transcript]

Petra Molnar, a lawyer and anthropologist specializing in migration and human rights, joined us to discuss the ways in which “AI” technology is being developed for “border security” by US immigration enforcement in increasingly terrifying and dystopian ways, including the potential deployment of Department of Homeland Security robot dogs. Petra points out that the decisions made by ICE agents and other immigration officials are already opaque as it is, but the added layer of technology “adds this kind of veneer that people who are powerful like to hide behind.”

Graphic with a screen cap of the video from episode 59, showing photos of Logan, Hanna and Bender along the right edge and the artifact we are reacting to to the left: an article from The Conversation with the headline "AI isn't replacing student writing - but it is reshaping it". Above is text reading #9 and below is the episode title (same as in the image caption). All of this is against a purple patterned background with a ribbon of black lines through it.
#9: Ep. 59 - Et Tu, American Federation of Teachers? (with Charles Logan)

9. Ep. 59 - Et Tu, American Federation of Teachers? (with Charles Logan)
Recorded 2025-07-14 [Livestream, Podcast, Transcript]

Charles Logan, a former English teacher with a PhD from Learning Sciences at Northwestern University, joined us to discuss the false promise of ed tech, especially the drive to push “AI” into the classroom. We talked about ed tech marketing hype from OpenAI, a writing instructor who is missing the plot with using LLMs in her teaching, and the awful deal that the American Federation of Teachers made with Microsoft, Anthropic, and OpenAI for a “national academy for AI instruction.”

Graphic with a screen cap of the video from episode 54, showing photos of Hanna Bender, and Mitchell along the right edge and the artifact we are reacting to to the left: an article from CNBC with the headline "Scale AI announces multimillion-dollar denfense deal, a major step in U.S. military auotmation" below a banner that says "AI EFFECT". Above is text reading #8 and below is the episode title (same as in the image caption). All of this is against a dark grey patterned background with abstract purple shapes reminiscent of sea creatures.
#8: Ep. 54 - “AI” Agents, A Single Point of Failure (with Margaret Mitchell)

8. Ep. 54 - “AI” Agents, A Single Point of Failure (with Margaret Mitchell)
Recorded 2025-03-31 [Livestream, Podcast, Transcript]

We welcomed Margaret Mitchell from Hugging Face to the podcast to discuss agentic “AI.” What are “agents” and why won’t everyone stop talking about them? Is this the future of making travel plans and restaurant reservations? In a classic case of “nobody actually wants this,” we talk about the risks of giving “AI” agents access to all your information and why companies are ignoring requests from users, like those with low vision or cognitive decline, who could actually benefit from assistive technologies. 

Graphic with a screen cap of the video from episode 65, showing photos of Muldowney, Hanna and Bender along the right edge and the artifact we are reacting to to the left: an article from the USC Annenberg Center for Health Journalism with the headline "An early AI pioneer shares how the 'vibe coding' revolution could reshape data journalism". Above is text reading #7 and below is the episode title (same as in the image caption). All of this is against a purple patterned background with a ribbon of black lines through it.
#7: Ep. 65 - Crunching the Numbers (with Decca Muldowney)

7. Ep. 65 - Crunching the Numbers (with Decca Muldowney)
Recorded 2025-10-20 [Livestream, Podcast, Transcript]

We had our very own Decca Muldowney on to talk about what happens when people claiming to do data journalism foist off part of the work to synthetic text extruding machines. Looking into our artifacts, we found that the people who want this to be a good idea aren’t so much journalists but bosses of journalists. We hope that readers of journalism will keep holding higher standards. Speaking of crunching the numbers—this episode was posted on October 30 and with that short runway still made the top 10 for the year!

Graphic with a screen cap of the video from episode 61, showing photos of Brennan, Myers West, Bender and Hanna along the right edge and the artifact we are reacting to to the left: an document from whitehouse.gov with the title "Winning the Race: America's AI Action Plan". Above is text reading 6# and below is the episode title (same as in the image caption). All of this is against a dark grey patterned background with abstract purple shapes reminiscent of sea creatures.
#6: Ep. 61 - Winning the Race to Hell (with Sarah Myers West and Kate Brennan)

6. Ep. 61 - Winning the Race to Hell (with Sarah Myers West and Kate Brennan)
Recorded 2025-08-04 [Livestream, Podcast, Transcript]

In this episode we took on Trump’s AI Action Plan, with the expert assistance of Sarah Myers West and Kate Brennan, Co-Executive Director and Associate Director of the AI Now Institute, respectively. The AI Action Plan is full of hype, Sinophobia, and gifts for Silicon Valley and not grounded in either a realistic understanding of the technology in question nor care for the needs of people. Fortunately, the AI Now Institute spearheaded a People’s AI Action Plan, with much better ideas.

Graphic with a screen cap of the video from episode 62, showing photos of Harrison Dupré, Hanna and Bender along the right edge and the artifact we are reacting to to the left: an article from Forbes with the headline "How AI is Expanding The Mental Health Market". Above is text reading #5 and below is the episode title (same as in the image caption). All of this is against a purple patterned background with a ribbon of black lines through it.
#5Ep. 62 - The Robo-Therapist Will See You Now (with Maggie Harrison Dupré)

5. Ep. 62 - The Robo-Therapist Will See You Now (with Maggie Harrison Dupré)
Recorded 2025-08-18 [Livestream, Podcast, Transcript]

2025 was marked by what felt like a steady drumbeat of news about people being led to self-harm and psychosis through chatbot interactions, and every “AI” critic we know receiving emails from people distressed by their interactions in various ways. Against that background, it is stunningly atrocious to hear about people and companies putting forth chatbots as therapy replacements. We were fortunate to get to talk this all through with Futurism journalist Maggie Harrison Dupré, who has done first-rate reporting on the mental health consequences of chatbots.

Graphic with a screen cap of the video from episode 58, showing photos of Hanna and Bender along the right edge and the artifact we are reacting to to the left: Sam Altman and Jony Ive's video collaboration announcement as posted on x.com by Altman with the text "thrilled to be partnering with jony, imo the greatest designer in the world. excited to try to create a new generation of AI-powered computers." Also visible is a still from the video where Ive and Altman are sitting and talking in a coffee shop. Above is text reading #4 and below is the episode title (same as in the image caption). All of this is against a dark grey patterned background with abstract purple shapes reminiscent of sea creatures.
#4: Ep. 58 - “Like Magic Intelligence in the Cloud”

4. Ep. 58 - “Like Magic Intelligence in the Cloud”
Recorded 2025-05-26 [Livestream, Podcast, Transcript]

In this episode we give Sam Altman and Jony Ive’s collaboration announcement video the full Mystery AI Hype Theater 3000 treatment. OpenAI’s Altman and Ive, the iPhone guy, wander romantically around San Francisco’s North Beach discussing how great they both are, all the while ignoring the fact that their industry is destroying the city they claim to love. As Alex points out in the episode, while Altman and Ive talk about attracting “talent” to the city to work on “AI,” the tech industry has drastically pushed up rents, displacing working-class San Franciscans from traditionally Black and Brown neighborhoods.

Graphic with a screen cap of the video from episode 60, showing photos of Cox, Hanna and Bender along the right edge and the artifact we are reacting to to the left: a blog post with the headline "My AI Skpetic Friends Are All Nuts". The blog post is illustrated with a bright, cartoony image of a yellow path through a green lawn or grassland diverging in two, with the left branch heading towards a sunrise behind snow-capped mountains and the right branch towards a rainbow under pink, lilac and white clouds. Above is text reading #3 and below is the episode title (same as in the image caption). All of this is against a purple patterned background with a ribbon of black lines through it.
#Ep. 60 - Vibe Coding: Four Security Nightmares in a Trenchcoat (with Susanna Cox)

3. Ep. 60 - Vibe Coding: Four Security Nightmares in a Trenchcoat (with Susanna Cox)
Recorded 2025-07-21 [Livestream, Podcast, Transcript]

Security engineer Susanna Cox joined us to discuss the absolute nightmare that is “vibe coding”, that is, letting synthetic text extruding machines generate code for you. We took on credulous screeds against AI critics, and also a guy who had a very bad day indeed using Replit to create a minimum viable product, with disastrous results. Adding in “AI agents” and allowing them to cross communicate opens up Pandora’s box of security vulnerabilities. “You should never let this touch your code base.”

Graphic with a screen cap of the video from episode 56, showing photos of Hanna and Bender along the right edge and the artifact we are reacting to to the left: the AI 2027 webpage. The top of the web page is visible, with the headling AI 2027, author names Daniel Kokotajlo, Scott Alexander, Thomas Larsen, Eli Lifland, Romeo Dean, and the opening paragraphs of text. To the right in the web page is the dynamic infographic showing imagined progress towards "AGI", in its setting for April 2025. Above the screenacp is text reading #2 and below is the episode title (same as in the image caption). All of this is against a dark grey patterned background with abstract purple shapes reminiscent of sea creatures.
#2: Ep. 56 - AGI: “Imminent”, “Inevitable”, and Inane

2. Ep. 56 - AGI: “Imminent”, “Inevitable”, and Inane
Recorded 2025-04-21 [Livestream, Podcast, Transcript]

It may be 2025, but the human race will be ending in 2030. At least that’s what the rationalist authors of the awful AI 2027 report suggest in their several-thousand word dystopian science fiction.  We went through their website, picking apart the most egregious of their claims. Like did you know that the most important thing that “OpenBrain” could be working on are AI agents who do science? And that they are going to pretend to be under our control, all the while planning the demise of humans with biological agents. Despite how silly this all sounds, this document has had influence with some policymakers and mainstream opinion writers at large, legacy publications.

Graphic with a pair of images representing the bonus episode for our book launch. The first is text against a white background with some light grey diagonal lines, reading: Help!! Is artificial intelligence going to take over the world? Have big tech scientists created an artificial lifeform that can think on its own? Are we about to enter an age where computers are better than humans at everything? (Very large text:) NOPE. (Smaller:) LOL. They wish! The second image is against a dark red/reddish black background with something like clouds and also diagonal lines in lighter read. Text at the top: VIRTUAL BOOK LAUNCH. Text at the bottom: MAY 8 2PM PT - TWITCH. Centered: An image of the cover of our book, which as THE AI CON in large black and red letter-press font and then the subtitle "How To Fight Big Tech's Hype and Create the Future We Want" and author names Emily M. Bender & Alex Hanna in smaller (red) font. Both images have the DAIR logo at the top. Above is text reading #1 and below is the episode title (same as in the image caption). All of this is against a purple patterned background with a ribbon of black lines through it.
#1: BOOK LAUNCH: Why “AI” is a Con: Our Book Launch! (with Vauhini Vara)

1. BOOK LAUNCH: Why “AI” is a Con: Our Book Launch! (with Vauhini Vara)
Recorded 2025-05-08 [Livestream, Podcast, Transcript]

And last, but certainly not least, we were joined by journalist and author Vauhini Vara to talk about our new book, The AI Con! We talked about the process of writing the book, the way that the podcast made writing the book much easier, and took a bunch of fantastic questions from long-time listeners of the pod.

Fresh AI Hell, Wrapped

All year long, Emily tries to keep up with the flood of Fresh AI Hell by dropping links to news stories in our big ol’ list of links spreadsheet. This represents only the links we collectively come across and drop into our group chat (including some contributed by listeners) and is far from comprehensive. Among other things, the vast majority are written in English; Fresh AI Hell is alas international. As of this reporting, the spreadsheet has 2,154 rows, and 1,149, or about 53% of those, point to items published in 2025. It’s not just that Emily was more systematic this year (in fact, at one point she cried uncle and just left some links from the group chat unharvested)—the Fresh AI Hell seems to be flowing faster than ever. And we can barely keep up! We only discussed 190 (about 17%) of those items from 2025 on the show.

Graphic with the purple patterned background used in the previous images but with flames along the right and left. Text, in white, reads: Fresh AI Hell, Wrapped by the Tag. The top five tags and their counts are displayed. This info is given in the text in the paragraph below this image.
The top five tags from Fresh AI Hell: Accountability/Good Pushback, Education, Info Ecosystem, Policy/Law, It’s Alive!

In addition to recording the link, Emily also attempts to maintain a rough topical categorization, associating each item with one more tags. Some of the items she files under “Accountability/Good pushback” (with potentially other tags) and happily, this was the most common tag this year at 133. The next four are Education (95), Info ecosystem (85), Policy/Law (77), and It’s Alive! (72).

With all that said, we bid you adieu, and look forward to you joining us in 2026 to take on the AI industry. We hope you’ll take some time to yourself, and emerge fresher than the AI Hell we’ll be encountering.


Our book, The AI Con, is now available wherever fine books are sold!

The cover image of The AI Con, with text to the right, which reads in all uppercase, alternating with black and red: Available Now, thecon.ai.

Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to Mystery AI Hype Theater 3000: The Newsletter:
Share this email:
Share on Twitter Share on LinkedIn Share via email Share on Mastodon Share on Bluesky
https://dair-in...
https://twitch....
https://peertub...
https://www.buz...
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.