Last Week's New Yorker Review: đ The Weekend Special (August 24)
The Weekend Special
Pieces are given up to three KATs (for fiction), Anunobys (for essays), or Brunsons (for random picks). As with restaurant stars, even one KAT, Anunoby, or Brunson indicates a generally positive review.
đ Fiction
âHidden Lifeâ by Madhuri Vijay. Three KATs. house, hobby, hot. I canât speak highly enough about this intricate, crackling bildungsroman, which speaks directly to and reconfigures the Henry James-style early modernist short story through a lens more acutely aware of social dynamics around class, gender, age, ability1 â without a hint of narrative predictability. This is a story to write academic papers about, far too full to ably critique in this spur-of-the-moment style; it somehow transcends the middlebrow effectiveness of almost all non-experimental contemporary literature and finds a way to make the short story form fresh. Itâs also an incredibly pleasurable read, in a way that Vijayâs previous story in the magazine wasnât for me; both stories are about painful discovery, but here the emphasis lands on the latter word. (The many modes of condescending and handling condescension also seems central; every speaking character is seen both condescending and also being condescended to.) Itâs also interesting reading this story so soon after Karan Mahajanâs essay on writing about India without living there (Google tells me Vijay lives in Hawaii and has done lots of study of Indian people abroad); Iâm not going to presume to speak on that subject, but it feels of-the-now even as this story is otherwise fairly timeless. I havenât touched on the Theosophy of it all! I havenât touched on the motherâs miscarriage, or the politics of blood and concealment! So many, many threads.
đ Weekend Essay
âWhen Middle Age Comes Into Focusâ by E. Tammy Kim. Two Anunobys. I had no clue Kim, who usually writes thoughtful if sometimes generic legal-issues coverage, could modulate her voice to write something so bubbly and sociable it could run in Teen Vogue for Adults, if such a magazine existed. The inevitability of myopia as we age makes it perhaps the only universal disease, and one without a cure. Thatâs enough of a hook for a piece this brief, and Kim makes just enough of it â she writes against the panic that some may feel when first confronting the condition, but doesnât trivialize. Small things do matter â thatâs why we need glasses in the first place. Kim makes sure the reader canât look past the topic.
đ Random Pick
âThe Beautiful Spoilsâ (Annals of Crime) by Janet Flanner. (February 22, 1947). One Brunson. Who knew that Flanner basically broke the story that, decades later, would be packaged as unknown history and turned into a dad book and later a dad movie? This is the first third of a piece that, in its next two thirds, addresses the Monument Men in greater detail; I was less familiar with and thus more interested in the machinations of the looting itself. Flanner is particularly interested in Göringâs schemes to nab the best of the art for himself, probably because it shows the petty hypocrisy of his character. Only two years past the liberation of the concentration camps, itâs pretty wild how much relish and even joy Flanner gets from attacking the Germans; she isnât interested in solemnity. Thereâs something revealing about this; history makes everything deadly look grave, but in the moment the human capacity to make light of horror, especially when you arenât directly affected, is pretty much infinite.
đ Something Extra
I touched on my feelings on Big Feelings and Birthright when I reviewed Nussbaumâs reviews of those shows, but Iâve caught some other, better theater since last we spoke (all of it closed or sold out): Camping at HERE was extremely well-executed on every level, though we may be approaching the last few years in which presenting your doomed yuri without even a hint of authorial knowingness can be taken seriously. Real Estate at the Brick is its opposite number, a totally deconstructed take on a continuously dissolving queer romance, and still moved and fascinated me â even though Isa Spector is now two-for-two in terms of projects where I think the first fifteen minutes are so fantastic they obviate the rest of the show.
Woyzeck, the new Adult Film production (starring its guru, Ryan Czerwonko) of the BĂŒchner play, has people flocking to a disused factory in outer Ridgewood to sweat together. At first I wasnât sure if the indie-sleaze-throwback vibe had the oomph to read as something other than an affectation, but the ballsiness of the stagecraft, which never stops throwing out new tricks, and the utter gameness of the cast do heat things up to a point where âimmersionâ starts sounding less like an annoying sales pitch and more like the next step in making human soup. Bring your own peas.
And for something completely different: I caught the Brandt/Roxander show of American Ballet Theaterâs Sylvia, a splash of pure joy and the best whole-evening ballet Iâve ever seen.
Sunday Song:
I dunno, I hate saying shit like âfor the #metoo eraâ because plenty of old short stories are awake to many, many aspects of social injustice, and also because I appreciate that this short story is not trying to âspeak toâ any distinctly contemporary phenomenon. But Vijay literalizes the generation gap (through the difference between Nidhiâs experience of the Auntâs house and her fatherâs) in ways that also speak to the generational differences in our understandings and readings of texts. â©
Add a comment: