The Best Album Brackets logo

The Best Album Brackets

Subscribe
Archives
November 5, 2025

#374 The 16 Best Albums of 1989

Best Album Brackets Logo #2.jpg

Hey folks!

Here are the 16 best albums of 1989 as decided by you, the voters. If anyone asks you what the 16 best albums of 1989 are, you direct them to this official and binding list. The albums are presented in seed order, from highest to lowest, from most expected to be here to least expected. Any album with a seed of #17 or lower was an underdog and had to fight one higher seed to be here, so kudos to those albums.

Without further ado, the 16 Best Albums of 1989:

Seed #1 Pixies, DOOLITTLE

On a brown background is a monotone photo of a small monkey. The monkey has a halo and is surrounded by three numbers: 5,6 and 7. The picture of the monkey has a green outline of a box around it, and within that box are green lines that make a bunch of connected shapes: squares, rectangles, circles, triangles, stars, trapezoids. etc.

Seed #2 Beastie Boys, PAUL'S BOUTIQUE

A photograph of a street corner in New York. There is a store called Paul's Boutique on the corner, as indicated by the sign that hangs over the sidewalk to the left. Above the store is a tall brick edifice, presumably apartments. On the sidewalk are clothes hanging from awning as a display, as well as a table with all sorts of objects on it, but difficult to identify any one object. There are two additional signs on the building, just below the brick edifice: "Lee's Sportswear" and "Ben's Shoes."

Seed #3 De La Soul, 3 FEET HIGH AND RISING

Black and white photos of three young Black men, arranged in a circle as if you are on the ground and they are looking down at you from above. The background is very bright yellow. There are hand drawn flower shapes in blue and orange arranged around them.

Seed #4 The Cure, DISINTEGRATION

We see the face of The Cure singer Robert Smith, with pale white skin, black hair, black eyeshadow, and red lips. (He's one of the most Gothiest men alive.) Around him are images of flowers. The photo has a sense of distortion, because I believe it's actually a projection onto a wall or another surface.

Seed #5 Nine Inch Nails, PRETTY HATE MACHINE

A digitized photgraph of some kind of machinery. It kinda looks like "Predator Vision" but the colors are blue and pink. It could be the wheelwell of a motorcycle? Maybe an engine? A close up of an indoor fan? No idea.

Seed #6 Nirvana, BLEACH

A black and white negative (creep) image of Nirvana playing (three guitarists and one drummer) all of them banging their heads and making their hair whip around.

Seed #7 The Stone Roses, THE STONE ROSES

This is a painting in a Jackson Pollock style, of splatters of white and black paint on a dark green background. On the left are three thick strips of paint, one red, one white, one blue. There are three circular slices of an orange or lemon on the canvas as well. THE STONE ROSES in gold lettering is in the center, and one of those slices forms the O of Roses.

Seed #8 N.W.A, STRAIGHT OUTTA COMPTON

Six young Black men shot from the ground looking up, so they appear to be standing over you. They are arranged in a circle. One of them is pointing a gun at the camera. They all look a little disappointed, like you fucked up and now they have to kill you. Also, please note there is no period after "A" in N.W.A

Seed #9 Tom Petty, FULL MOON FEVER

A photo of Tom Petty, a skinny white guy with a long narrow face, playing a guitar. He has an odd look on his face; he may be biting his lip? The photo is tinted rainbow style, going from red at the top to yellow (which covers most of Petty's body), to blue at the bottom.

Seed #10 The B-52's, COSMIC THING

A photograph of the B-52's, tinted with a rainbow of colors, red to yellow to green to blue. They are arranged from left to right, in performance. First is Keith Strickland, a young white man with longish New Wavey hair, playing guitar and smiling. Second is Cindy Wilson, a young white woman wearing a bowler-shaped hat and a very long braid going down her shoulder to her waist. She wears a sparkly coat and is playing a bongo and singing. Third is Fred Schneider, a young white man with short hair, in a suit and tie, holding a microphone in a stand, and facing Cindy, singing to her. Last but not least is Kate Pierson, who has very big red hair that frames her face like a circle. She is wearing a shimmering dress and is singing into a microphone on a stand, and is facing (a presumed) audience.

Seed #11 Fugazi, 13 SONGS

A red background. At the top in black reads "FUGAZI" and along the bottom in the same font "13 SONGS."

Seed #12 New Order, TECHNIQUE

A color photo of a statue, some kind of cherubic figure, holding some kind of plants, leaves, I think. The lighting on it colors it from dark red to green to blue. The upper part of the background is dark pink, and that turns into dark purple by the bottom.

Seed #13 Janet Jackson, JANET JACKSON'S RHYTHM NATION 1814

A black and white photo of Janet Jackson, a beautiful young Black woman, from the shoulders up. She wears a black cap, and a jacket with a military-style collar. The hat and the collar both have a metal plate that read 1814. She wears an a hoop earring with a key attached. She stares off to the right.

Seed #15 Madonna, LIKE A PRAYER

A close up of Madonna's exposed belly and crotch of her jeans. The top buttons of the jeans are unbuttoned. Madonna's hands are on top of her jeans, her thumbs tucked inside. Two long pieces of jewelry hang (presumably) from her neck, strings with various gems and baubles and rings on them. They probably have Catholic significance but I do not know what. If you want to see Madonna's face, cf. Ciccone Youth, THE WHITEY ALBUM.

Seed #16 Galaxie 500, ON FIRE

A photograph of the band, taken from a low angle on the ground looking up at them. They're dressed in T-shirts. There's a guy with a round face and longish light-colored hair, a woman in a dark shirt with short dark hair and large spiral earrings, and another guy with short moussed hair in a white t shirt. The whole thing is orange-tinted. A great deal of the picture is the sky above the three, and the sky is orange.

Seed #19 Neneh Cherry, RAW LIKE SUSHI

A color photograph of a young Black woman with her hair pulled back, her arms crossed, and wearing loads of bracelets and a very large medallion. She has a very.. angry? disappointed? smug? look on her face. It's very intense, regardless. The background is blank white.

Conspicuously missing:

#14 The Jesus and Mary Chain, AUTOMATIC (lost to #19 Neneh Cherry, RAW LIKE SUSHI, 139-127-4)

Bonus Beats!

Just for funsies, here are the 1989 Top Albums ranked by total votes after 3 rounds:

1. Beastie Boys, PAUL'S BOUTIQUE [seed #2] 471 total votes
1. The Cure, DISINTEGRATION [seed #4] 471 total votes
3. De La Soul, 3 FEET HIGH AND RISING [seed #3] 417 total votes
4. Fugazi, 13 SONGS [seed #11] 410 total votes
5. Nirvana, BLEACH [seed #6] 397 total votes
6. New Order, TECHNIQUE [seed #12] 385 total votes
7. Pixies, DOOLITTLE [seed #1] 376 total votes
8. Galaxie 500, ON FIRE [seed #16] 373 total votes
8. Neneh Cherry, RAW LIKE SUSHI [seed #19] 373 total votes
10. Nine Inch Nails, PRETTY HATE MACHINE [seed #5] 364 total votes
11. The Stone Roses, THE STONE ROSES [seed #7] 357 total votes
12. N.W.A, STRAIGHT OUTTA COMPTON [seed #8] 341 total votes
13. The B-52's, COSMIC THING [seed #10] 333 total votes
14. Madonna, LIKE A PRAYER [seed #15] 315 total votes
15. Tom Petty, FULL MOON FEVER [seed #9] 311 total votes
16. Janet Jackson, JANET JACKSON'S RHYTHM NATION 1814 [seed #13] 310 total votes

Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to The Best Album Brackets:
Start the conversation:
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.