Dustin, 1/8/25

I think I speak for insufferable pedants everywhere when I say that I immediately clocked this as not being an actual line from Confucius -- it's way too touchy-feely -- and felt great satisfaction when exactly 5 seconds of research proved me right. It's widely attributed to the Scottish historian and philosopher Thomas Carlyle, as part of the longer quote "He who has health, has hope; and he who has hope, has everything," but nobody seems to have a specific citation for it, so that's probably not true either. I leave the details to the elite team of Brainyquote investigators in the comments, but I do think that if there were even a thin thread connecting this to Confucius, you'd find that attribution everywhere online, because the older and more exotic the source of an anodyne statement like this, the more people love it.

Anyway, it made me wonder: What would Dustin's dad think of Confucius? I feel like his opinion would be mixed: obviously he'd be into the filial piety and respect for hierarchy, but Confucius rejected the strict codes of Legalism and emphasized that an enlightened ruler leads by means of moral example, which a lawyer would be dubious about. I also considered trying to figure out what Dustin's dad would think about Thomas Carlyle, but it turns out that his Wikipedia article is really long, and why would I waste my precious time on it when I could be making jokes about Dawn Weston walking into a door in Mary Worth?