If you're searching "is Stock Paper Scissors a scam," you probably saw the TikTok clips, got curious about the Discord, and then remembered how many trading groups turn out to be fronts for fake screenshots and empty promises. Fair instinct. I went through the Stock Paper Scissors listing on Whop, the plans, the FAQs and the member reviews, and the short answer is no, it is not a scam. The strongest evidence is the review record: 61 ratings, a 4.54 average, and 49 of those ratings are a clean five stars.

Here is why the question comes up at all. The futures and options trading space is full of the same tricks: fake profit screenshots, "guaranteed" returns, anonymous owners, and admins who vanish after you pay. Stock Paper Scissors (SPS Trading, as some people call it) doesn't fit that pattern, and the rest of this article shows why. If you want to check the reviews yourself while you read, see the Stock Paper Scissors page and its ratings before you decide anything.

The scam test: 6 patterns I checked

Here are the scam patterns I'd screen for in a trading community, and how Stock Paper Scissors does on each.

1. Anonymous owner. The community is run by William Jordan, who has a public Whop profile and a public TikTok at @willoptions. The Discord grew out of that TikTok presence. There's a face and a name behind it.
2. Fake or thin social proof. The listing carries 61 ratings with a 4.54 average. The distribution is 49 five-star, 4 four-star, 2 three-star, 4 two-star and 2 one-star. That spread of opinions, including a few lower ratings, is what a real member base looks like, not a wall of copy-paste praise.
3. Guaranteed returns. The FAQ is plain: SPS provides educational content only, no financial advice, and it isn't liable for any trades. A group that tells you up front it sells education, not promises, is the opposite of the "guaranteed profits" pitch.
4. Hidden or confusing pricing. Two clear options: $100 / month, or a $497 one-time lifetime plan. No upsell maze, no vague "contact us for pricing."
5. Vague deliverables. The listing spells out what you get: live trading Monday through Friday, daily alerts, and 100+ hours of ICT-based education. You know what you're paying for.
6. A group that's been around. The company has been on Whop since May 2023, with 386 members, and reviews dated as recently as May 2026. Scam groups tend to burn out fast. This one is still collecting feedback.

Tally: six patterns, six cleared.

CHECK IF THE DISCOUNT IS STILL LIVE

Programs on Whop often run pop-up sales and price drops, and they come and go without much warning. Don't pay full price until you've seen what's live right now.

CLICK TO SEE IF A DISCOUNT IS ACTIVE

What members actually say

Numbers are one thing. Here is what actual members wrote.

A five-star reviewer of the SPS Lotion Model+ product said: "W community honestly, Will always willing to explain his stuff to the members and breakdown his trades. Fire indicator as well. He always answered my DMs. Most larps out there trading live and mfs don't even show executions. Transparency with wins and losses." That last line matters. Showing losses next to wins is exactly what fake gurus avoid.

Another five-star reviewer wrote: "learnt a lot from the live execution on how i should go about entering trades and psychology, theres also a charting session every day to go over the trades that people taken, and discuss the good and bad about it. overall a great mentorship, i was able to pass my first eval here…" A daily charting session where members' trades get reviewed, good and bad, is real teaching, not a highlight reel.

A third five-star member, writing in February 2026, said: "I've been thinking about writing this review for a long time. Last year, I was searching for a new trading community, and joining SPS was honestly the best decision I could have made. Beyond the results, the community itself is priceless…" And a short one from April 2026: "Goated discord community."

Read the distribution the way a skeptic should: roughly 80% of ratings (49 of 61) are five stars, and the lower ratings are a small minority. As with any education product, a few members will land lower when their expectations or learning pace differ, which is normal for trading education in general. The overall picture is lopsidedly positive.

Who is behind Stock Paper Scissors

William Jordan runs it under the Whop username @stockpaperscissorsllc, and you can view his public profile yourself. His TikTok is @willoptions, where the whole thing started. According to the listing description, the TikTok journey led to forming the SPS Discord, a community where seasoned traders share insights and help each other grow. In plain terms, a creator with a public following built a community from it, and he's reachable: one reviewer says he answered their DMs.

What your money actually buys

SPS teaches ICT concepts (a Smart Money Concepts style of trading) with a futures focus. Here is how the two plans compare at the time I checked:

The math is simple: five months of the monthly plan equals the lifetime price, so anyone planning to stay a while has an obvious option. The lifetime listing describes itself as "hands down the cheapest place to learn ICT futures," which is the creator's own claim, but the pricing at least backs up the argument that it's aggressively priced for what's included.

One term to know going in: the listing states that all resources are provided at purchase and that there are no refunds. That's a common setup for digital education on Whop, and it's the reason to do your homework first, which you're doing right now. Also notable is the honesty about scope: SPS says it provides education, not financial advice.

EXTRA BONUS THROUGH OUR LINK

Joining through our link usually comes with a special extra on top of the regular membership. Click through to see what's included right now.

GET THE BONUS, NOT JUST THE MEMBERSHIP

How to start smart

1. Read the FAQ first. It covers the purpose of SPS and the no-financial-advice stance. Know what you're buying before you buy it.
2. Know the no-refund rule. Everything is delivered at purchase, so decide with your eyes open.
3. Pick the plan that fits your timeline. If you want to test the waters, the $100 monthly plan is the lower-commitment way in. If you already know you'll stick with ICT futures, the $497 lifetime plan pays for itself after about five months.
4. Show up for the live sessions. Reviewers consistently point to the live execution and the daily charting session as the most valuable parts.
5. Ask questions. Members say William explains his trades and answers DMs. Use that.
6. Treat it as education. Practice and learn the concepts before putting real size behind anything.

Spots in communities like this are often capped and prices tend to move up over time, so it's worth checking what's available right now.

The verdict: is Stock Paper Scissors a scam?

No. Stock Paper Scissors is not a scam, and the evidence is concrete. It has a named creator with a public profile and TikTok, 61 ratings averaging 4.54 with 49 of them five-star, and transparent pricing at $100 a month or $497 once. Members describe a community where trades, wins and losses are explained openly, and the company states clearly that it sells education, not guaranteed outcomes.

If your original worry was "is this another fake guru group," the listing answers it. The patterns that define scams in this niche (anonymous owners, guaranteed returns, hidden costs, stale reviews) simply aren't here. What's left is a fairly priced ICT futures education community with live sessions, daily alerts and a member base that keeps leaving positive reviews well into 2026.

You don't have to take my word for it. Go read the reviews and the plan details on the official page and judge for yourself.

Trading involves real risk. Nothing here is financial or professional advice; do your own due diligence.