A Wrong Diagnosis of the Kidney Shortage
(Beginning of a news story:) In January 2026, Tim Andrews, who had received a genetically edited pig kidney in January 2025, became the recipient of a donated human kidney. His case represents the longest dialysis-free survival following porcine (pig) kidney xenotransplantation in a living human and the first transition to human kidney transplantation. In a paper published Sept. 3 in The Lancet, Harvard Medical School physician-scientists at Massachusetts General Hospital and colleagues detail Andrews’ experience and how xenotransplantation is moving closer to achieving its promise of bridging the gap between end-stage kidney failure and human kidney transplantation, allowing a patient to forgo dialysis in the meantime.
The authors report that Andrews, who was 66 at the time of xenotransplantation, successfully lived with the genetically edited kidney for 271 days — during which he did not need dialysis — before receiving a human kidney from a donor.
“The organ shortage is the greatest crisis we have right now in transplantation,” said lead author Leonardo Riella, the HMS Harold and Ellen Danser Associate Professor of Surgery at Mass General and medical director for kidney transplantation at Mass General Brigham. “We know that the best treatment option for patients with end-stage kidney disease who have developed renal failure is transplantation, but we simply don’t have enough human organs to transplant in a timely manner.” (end of news story)
Our response to the last paragraph in the news story: The shortage of transplant kidneys is not a fact of nature; it is the result of a policy mistake – a blunder made when writing the National Organ Transplant Act in 1984. Late in the drafting of that law, the authors – in an over-reaction to an entrepreneur’s statement that he intended to bring poor foreigners into this country and pay them to give up a kidney – added this sentence:
"It shall be unlawful for any person to knowingly acquire, receive, or otherwise transfer any human organ for valuable consideration for use in human transplantation if the transfer affects interstate commerce."
Although that sentence may seem reasonable to non-economists, it was actually a terrible economic blunder because it inadvertently imposed a price ceiling of zero on the market for transplant kidneys. And like all binding price ceilings, this one caused a shortage.
The economic explanation of why a prohibition on paying kidney donors causes a kidney shortage is an elementary application of the Laws of Supply and Demand that is discussed in almost every introductory microeconomics textbook (e.g., see Gregory Mankiw, Principles of Microeconomics, Chapter 6).
Frank
Add a comment: