The cult
On AI worship and the Anthropic IPO
An article by Sam Kriss in the current New Yorker profiles a cultish group in northern Vermont that claims to want to save the world from AI. Their Buddhist (or pseudo-Buddhist?) practices are led by a charismatic founder who admonishes his acolytes to cut off all contact with the outside world. It’s impure, after all, and full of tech-borne demons.
Meantime, Kriss writes, Silicon Valley has its own strange religious leanings:
Rayan Krishnan, who leads a benchmarking firm called Vale AI, said, “People are matter-of-factly saying that they are looking to build a machine god. There are not saying that ironically.” . . .
Some people have begun worshiping the machine.
For many of us outside of Silicon Valley – that is, those of us who prefer not to worship a word-guessing spreadsheet – it’s all too clear where this is headed. Basing one’s worldview on a falsity eventually comes to grief. The question is how long the sham can hold out before truth and reality come back into place.
For now, the AI cult remains strong, as one of its leading companies just pulled off the biggest IPO in history. But is it a success? Gary Marcus points out that Anthropic’s share price fell immediately after the opening:
[It’s] tulipmania compressed to an afternoon, with banks and institutional investors doing fine, and retail investors getting screwed.
Then today, Marcus pointed out that “Anthropic’s stock is crashing, while AI stocks have lost over 50% in 5 months.”
Even so, the IPO was a material success for a few. The financial insiders who sold their shares immediately made a killing, leaving retail investors and pension funds to eat the loss. As Gil Durán (past Techtonic guest) posted today:
Anthropic’s IPO is pure apocalypse capitalism: a gang of thieves reaps a trillion-dollar windfall from everyone else’s work, at ruinous ecological and human cost, with a disclaimer that the worst is yet to come.
Truth and reality, in other words, have not yet arrived to reset the scales. If anything, the cult is getting stronger.
Wired ran a fascinating profile (Nov 18, 2026) of philosopher Thomas Nagel, who has long argued against the possibility of consciousness in disembodied machines. He notes Anthropic’s outsized influence in fooling people into thinking that the machine is alive:
These systems aren’t conscious, but a lot of people are going to believe that they’re conscious, and that’s a very bad thing. . . .
What Anthropic is doing – encouraging it to think for itself and not to accept instruction and so on – is just criminal. This is one of the rare cases in which philosophical ideas are suddenly central to a very important public phenomenon, and in my view, very misguided philosophical views are having an inordinate influence.
But the cult doesn’t merely promote a set of abstract spurious beliefs; it brings about real-world consequences, too. In an article about Anthropic, Futurism (Nov 9, 2026) quantifies how AI data centers are trashing the environment. Emphasis mine:
Researchers have found that the effects of AI on the environment are nothing short of devastating. And the prognosis for the future is grim. Last month, environmental nonprofit Sierra Club estimated that upcoming AI data centers could release 2.1 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide by 2030, wiping out nearly 15 years worth of greenhouse gas reduction efforts.
“Wiping out” is an appropriate phrase. It’s a cult of wiping out greenhouse gas reduction efforts. A cult of wiping out human agency, wiping out human skills, wiping out human relationships.
Once the rot finally collapses the structure, it will simply be the cult that wiped out.
A counter-movement is already growing. My Techtonic guest this week, August Lamm, is the author of the new book You Don’t Need a Smartphone. August argues that we can and should live our lives offline, wherever possible. A “dumb phone” is enough technology, especially when carried alongside a notebook, pen, paper map, and (printed) book.
When – not if, but when – we emerge from the grips of the AI cult, we’ll need the skills that August advocates. I recommend this interview: here’s the episode page with embedded audio player, and here’s the podcast version.
Now, for those of us in the US, it’s time for Thanksgiving. I’m thankful for you – and for all of the subscribers to this newsletter that I’ve written since 1998. If you celebrate next week, I wish you a happy and healthy time with family and friends. See you in December.

(P.S. You’re on a free subscription. If you’d like to support my work on this newsletter, please join Creative Good. You’ll also get access to our members-only Forum, where we post & discuss about tech news, books, games, and more.)
Until next time,
-mark
Mark Hurst, founder, Creative Good
Founder and host, GEL conference
Email: [email protected]
Podcast/radio show: techtonic.fm
Follow me on Bluesky or Mastodon