Silver Linings in a Tough Election for Taxpayer Groups
Across California, 2026 General Election voters broadly supported tax and bond measures. In the Bay Area, the Measure RTM transit sales tax passed with about 63% across the five counties it targeted (in Contra Costa, 57% voted yes). But, while the election was a tough one for CoCoTax and others skeptical of more taxes and spending, there were a couple of green shoots.
East County voters defeated Measure X, a school bond proposed by Liberty Union High School District. And in Clayton, voters turned aside Measure M, a 1% sales tax increase that would have been layered on top or RTM’s 0.5% hike, Many thanks to CoCoTax members and allies who wrote opposition ballot arguments and spoke to their neighbors about the disadvantages of these costly measures.
At the state level, voters defeated Proposition 40, an unusual billionaire wealth tax which could have damaged California’s venture capital ecosystem and devastated the state’s budget. Voters also ratified Proposition 42, which prohibits wealth taxes as well as taxes that are applied retroactively. It is worth noting that Prop 42 protections are limited: while they bind the legislature, the tax advocates at UC Berkeley and SEIU could still introduce a new retroactive wealth tax measure so long as it contains a repeal of Prop 42.
While we can take some solace in these wins, there is no escaping the fact that November 3 was a blowout for advocates of higher taxes. The size of Measure RTM’s victory was especially troubling given that we had made opposition to that multi-county measure our highest priority.
Speaking for myself (and not the CoCoTax board or executive committee), I take two things away from the election. First, it was something of an outlier: an unusually large number of voters turned out to send a signal at the national level and likely paid less attention to local measures.
Second, we should focus our resources on winnable local races. Aside from the two we won; others may have been within reach had we made more intense efforts. This is especially true of Richmond Measure Q, an indefensible city general obligation bond which was only about 3.5% above its two-thirds passing threshold (based on near-complete election results). Also worth more attention was Hercules Measure P, a 1% sales tax hike which could have been defeated by flipping about 400 votes. With everything at CoCoTax going to the Measure RTM effort, we simply lacked the resources to help local members in West County oppose these measures (aside from writing ballot arguments).
One last word on the topic of ballot arguments. CoCoTax is one of just a handful of local California taxpayer’s associations that performed our key function this cycle, which is to write, circulate, and submit competent arguments and rebuttals. In Southern California, a number of organizations turned it few if any arguments, allowing many costly measures to move forward unopposed.
Your Latest Reminder that We Were Right on Measure B
Back in June, we led the opposition to Measure B, a 0.625% sales tax marketed by the County as a necessary offset to devastating federal Medicaid cuts (in California, the national Medicaid program is known as Medi-Cal).
Supposedly, the federal cuts would kick 93,000 beneficiaries off the program forcing them into County emergency rooms where they would crowd out the rest of us. The main reason that beneficiaries would be kicked off Medi-Cal was that they would not be able to comply with new work requirements.
But now these “onerous” work requirements are in the process of vaporizing. Even before the election, we knew that beneficiaries could satisfy the work requirements with any combination of work, volunteering, studying, or training that add up to 80 hours per month. Many would be exempted due to medical frailty and other conditions.
New work requirement implementation details from state and federal agencies show a trend toward further dilution. In 2027, beneficiaries will be able to “self-attest” that they complied with the work requirement: county social workers do not need to verify that they put in the 80 required hours.
Further, the attestation need only apply to any one month of each beneficiary’s six-month eligibility period and the work requirement can be satisfied by the participant earning equivalent to 80 hours at the federal minimum wage (of $7.25 per hour compared to California’s $17.40 per hour minimum effective January 1).
The overall effect is as follows: to meet the work requirement, an affected Medi-Cal beneficiary would have to work just 34 hours for one month out of six. Does anyone seriously expect tens of thousands to lose coverage over these trivial requirements?
Finally, the incoming Congressional majority takes office on the promise that it will reverse the 2025 Medicaid cuts. Even though they’ll have to negotiate with the current Presidential administration, you can rest assured that the work requirements will be further watered down if not eliminated entirely.
In Contra Costa, we are fortunate that voters deprived County Supervisors of a new revenue stream that is proving redundant with what could reasonably be expected from the federal and state governments (the state legislature has been taking its own steps to offset the 2025 Medicaid legislation). Taxpayers in Santa Clara and Los Angeles Counties are not so fortunate as voters there approved similar Medi-Cal sales taxes.
Save the Dates for Early 2027
We start a new luncheon series at Denny’s in Concord on Friday, January 22 with a discussion of our local measure wins. Among our speakers will be Bryan Scott, who was instrumental in helping defeat the Measure X school bond, and Jim Killoran, who led the opposition to Clayton’s Measure M sales tax. What can we learn from these positive results to more effectively protect taxpayers in 2028?
On February 26, Eric Eisenhammer of Dauntless Communications, will join us to discuss the successful fight against Prop 40 and for Prop 42. Registration for these two events will be available next month.
Happy Thanksgiving to you and your loved ones, and please be on the lookout for our annual membership appeal early next month.