According to reports, producer David Fincher is just way too busy to commit to a third season of Mindhunter right now, which poses problems for people hoping to see what happens next with Bill Tench’s creepy son. (Actors who play killer kids grow up just as fast as those who play non-homicidal ones, after all.) Let’s lighten Fincher’s load by figuring out a period-appropriate crime for Tench and Holden Ford to investigate next.

For extra credit, pick one or two notorious convicts Tench, Ford, or Wendy Carr should go interview, and for extra extra credit, cast ‘em!