Best Evidence

Best Evidence

Archives
Log in
Subscribe
October 12, 2026

Kill. Bury. Print.: How the news gets broken

the true crime that's worth your time

Is Peacock's doc on the cover-ups and countersuits in McCurtain County, OK worth the spilled ink?

Publisher Bruce Willingham puts out the McCurtain County Gazette. (Number 19)

The crime
Good Lord, where to start. According to, among others, family-business local paper the McCurtain County Gazette, local law enforcement – and in particular former sheriff Kevin Clardy and deputy Alicia Manning – allegedly mishandled evidence; failed to investigate disappearances; took drugs; engaged in inappropriate intra-department relationships; violated local statute as to proper contact with county commissioners; abused prisoners in the county jail; and, once the Gazette reported these allegations, made racist comments, talked about hiring hit men to silence Gazette editorial, and defamed Gazette reporter Chris Willingham by tying him to a convicted pedophile.

Want to read the full issue?
Already a paid subscriber? Click here to log in.
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.