Best Evidence logo

Best Evidence

Subscribe
Archives
September 26, 2023

How many of these CrimeCon award contenders have you watched, read, or listened to?

the true crime that's worth your time

CrimeCon announced its Clue Awards last week, in a ceremony that included Best Evidence side-eye recipients Nancy Grace, Paul Holes, and Kelly Siegler. But a roster of presenters that we’re not so sure about isn’t enough reason, on its own, to make me ignore its list of winners for this year — after all, understanding trends in true crime, even if I hate them, is part of this gig.

So I’ll hustle past the news that the “Crimefighter of the Year” award went to The Gabby Petito Foundation, with this from Variety: “Derrica and Natalie Wilson, who received the award in 2022 for co-founding the Black and Missing Foundation, presented the award to Petito’s parents and step-parents during the ceremony; in turn, the Petito Foundation co-founders announced a $15,000 donation to BAMFI.” That could have gone worse, I guess.

Now, onto the award winners! They’re listed in full on the CrimeCon site, but I’m going to paste them below so I can link to each to save you a “which one was this?” Google or two.

Today’s questions are easy: which of these properties have you consumed? Which were worth your time? And do you agree with the rankings? We can’t wait to hear. — EB

Outstanding docuseries

Winner: Secrets of the Chippendales Murders

Nominees:

  • I Just Killed My Dad

  • Low Country: The Murdaugh Dynasty

  • Still Missing Morgan

  • Dateline NBC: Trial of Alex Murdaugh

Outstanding Episodic Series

Winner: 911 Crisis Center

Nominees:

  • ABC News Studios: Death in the Dorms (How is this not under docuseries?? — EB)

  • Accident, Suicide or Murder

  • Cold Justice

  • Finally Caught

Book of the Year

Winner: Trailed: One Woman’s Quest to Solve the Shenandoah Murders

Nominees:

  • American Autopsy

  • The Murders of Moises Ville

  • The Science of Murder: The Forensics of Agatha Christie

  • Unmasked: My Life-Solving America’s Cold Cases

Outstanding Documentary Film

Winner: The Fire That Took Her

Nominees:

  • Murdaugh Family Murders

  • Serial Killer Capital: Baton Rouge

  • The Fatal Attraction Murder

  • The Last Strike

Podcast: Outstanding Episodic Series

Winner: Missing in America: Keeshae Jacobs

Nominees:

  • Crawlspace – True Crime & Mysteries

  • My Life of Crime with Erin Moriarty

  • Predators I Have Caught with Chris Hansen

  • Zone 7 with Sheryl McCollum

Podcast: Outstanding Docuseries

Winner: Freeway Phantom

Nominees:

  • Father Wants Us Dead

  • Finding Tamika

  • Project Unabom

  • The Girl in the Blue Mustang

Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to Best Evidence:
Start the conversation:
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.