The Kitchen Times logo

The Kitchen Times

Archives
Subscribe
November 28, 2025

This Meal Would Have Killed a Pilgrim

Traditional Thanksgiving food bores me, and I’m not really sure why. It may just be because it’s heavy on simplicity and familiarity; nowadays, I only have taste buds for novel flavors.

That being said, I can’t veer too far from tradition on our favorite feast day. I spent a good amount of time cradling my cookbooks in the weeks leading up to this Thanksgiving nailing down menu options. My thought was to cook something from every continent while including all the standard fare - green beans, carrots, mac ‘n’ cheese, etc. The final menu hit the mark, though I did skip Australia (I fear I may need a new cookbook). Our feasting friends Maria and Kyle rounded out the menu with the two items every Thanksgiving must include - stuffing and turkey.

The author's final menu consisting of mango ceviche with a pumpkin seed powder, glazed carrots with benne seeds, smashed potatoes with roasted seaweed sour cream, makhani mac 'n' cheese, loubieh (green beans in a tomato reduction), pumpkin seed rolls, Maria's favorite dressin', smoked turkey, and Arkansas possum pie.
final Thanksgiving menu (and prep plans)

For Africa, we had glazed carrots topped with benne seeds, chives, and cilantro. These were the most beautiful carrots I’ve ever worked with, and the tangy orange and carrot juice glaze was quite worthy of them. Benne seeds were brought to the Carolinas by enslaved Africans in the 18th century and are essentially OG sesame seeds with a more distinctive nutty taste.

Pumpkin seed rolls represented Europe due to their rye flour vibes. A nut butter of sesame and pumpkin seeds was incorporated into the dough to create the deepest nutty flavor possible, and the rest of the toasted seeds crowned them.

Baked rolls topped with generous sprinklings of toasted sesame and pumpkin seeds.
pumpkin seed rolls

A solid Asian contingent (you tell me how I’m supposed to only choose one!) comprised of smashed potatoes on roasted seaweed sour cream (Korea), makhani mac ‘n’ cheese (India), and loubieh (green beans in a tomato reduction - Lebanon) provided many of the necessary elements of a proper Thanksgiving feast but with the sought-after noteworthy flavors. We enjoyed the smashed potatoes as an appetizer and were blown away by the funky seaweed sour cream. The loubieh kept the green beans perfectly crisp (overcooked green beans have no place in my kitchen) in a bright, velvety tomato sauce, and the makhani mac ‘n’ cheese was a magical pairing of cheesy goodness and Indian spices.

Smashed potatoes on top of a roasted seaweed sour cream and topped with diagonally-sliced scallions.
smashed potatoes on a bed of roasted seaweed sour cream

South America was properly represented by a green mango ceviche with pumpkin seed powder. The acidity of this salad along with the toasted pumpkin powder was totally worth trekking over to White Center to collect the green mangoes.

Of course, North America was quite involved, too, thanks to the essential dressing and smoked turkey that Maria and Kyle supplied. Kyle’s smoked turkey has perhaps ruined all other turkey for me - it was juicy, tender, and perfectly smoky. It was so good, it featured in my dreams last night.

Much of the final spread: carrots covered by foil, stuffing, makhani mac 'n' cheese, mango ceviche, and loubieh.
most of our Thanksgiving spread

For dessert, I hesitated to deviate from my beloved bourbon pumpkin pie, but I just wasn’t feeling it this year. I turned to Arkansas possum pie instead, a treat I made for my birthday a few weeks ago that was worth an appearance here. More of a pudding than a pie, Arkansas possum pie consists of a crumbly pecan “crust” with layers of sweetened cream cheese, chocolate pudding, and whipped cream with more pecans and shaved chocolate tossed on top. The chocolate pudding is divine; quality cocoa powder, like the Guittard cocoa rouge that you can pry outta my cold, dead hands, is worth the price.

How was your Thanksgiving? Did you do anything different this year, and was it worth it? I think our meal will be remembered for years to come!

Read more:

  • Nov 19, 2025

    There's a Whole World in my Pantry

    I am not a world traveler. I am a creature of habit, and I am happily married to my routines. Home is the only place I want to be most days. That being said,...

    Read article →
  • Nov 26, 2025

    Recipe Snobbery is Worth It

    Seeing as I’ll be musing on the year’s best good eatin’ in this newsletter soon, now may be a good time to better explain my rating system that scales from S...

    Read article →
Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to The Kitchen Times:

Add a comment:

Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.