October 3, 2024

[AINews] Canvas: OpenAI's answer to Claude Artifacts

This is AI News! an MVP of a service that goes thru all AI discords/Twitters/reddits and summarizes what people are talking about, so that you can keep up without the fatigue. Signing up here opts you in to the real thing when we launch it 🔜

---

Chat-with-Artifacts is all you need.

AI News for 10/2/2024-10/3/2024. We checked 7 subreddits, 433 Twitters and 31 Discords (225 channels, and 1721 messages) for you. Estimated reading time saved (at 200wpm): 212 minutes. You can now tag @smol_ai for AINews discussions!

Three months after Claude Artifacts (our coverage here), OpenAI released Canvas, an enhanced writing and coding tool based on GPT-4o (Mikhail Parakhin also notes that they shipped a similar feature in Bing Copilot). From the release announcement, Canvas includes:

• Inline Suggestions: Canvas provides inline suggestions and direct actions for refining writing and coding, such as adding polish, fixing bugs, or porting code.

• Seamless Editing: It supports seamless editing of larger documents and complex codebases, making project management easier.

• Collaborative Environment: The collaborative environment ensures continuous improvement and evolution of your work.

A quick scan of early commentary and feedback included:

• Vincente Silveira noted: "Looks great, we just tried it, compared w Cursor and Claude, and seems it brings more of the core editing and coding use cases into ChatGPT with a better UX for the average user."

• Machine Learning Street Talk tweeted early issues however: "OpenAI cloned the functionality inside @cursor_ai i.e. the apply model. Nice idea, poor execution - it doesn't work very well. Often updates the entire doc, not the selection"

• Karina Nguyen (who worked on Canvas) posted several examples of writing and coding using Canvas.

While the early emphasis seems to be on writing usecases, integrating well with ChatGPT's existing search, coding is of course an important comparator vs Claude Artifacts, and Karina has built in some custom tools for those tasks.

OpenAI will also be sponsoring Marijn Haverbeke, the creator and maintainer of the open source libraries ProseMirror and CodeMirror used in making Canvas.

The trickiest part of the implementation was the way in which OpenAI chose to integrate it into the existing ChatGPT experience, which involved training a detector for when the canvas feature should toggle on:

A key challenge was defining when to trigger a canvas. We taught the model to open a canvas for prompts like “Write a blog post about the history of coffee beans” while avoiding over-triggering for general Q&A tasks like “Help me cook a new recipe for dinner.” For writing tasks, we prioritized improving “correct triggers” (at the expense of “correct non-triggers”), reaching 83% compared to a baseline zero-shot GPT-4o with prompted instructions. They shared their evals too:

Similar improvements were done for triggering edit behavior and comment creation. This probably means the chatgpt-4o-latest model in API has been updated as well.

Unlike Artifacts, OpenAI Canvas does not support displaying Mermaid Diagrams or HTML previews. Presumably those features are in the works, but it is curious both that they weren't prioritized and that this was also not launched at Dev Day 2 days ago (the Latent Space recap here).

---

Sponsored by Daily: If you’re interested in conversational voice AI (and video, too), join the team at Daily and the Open Source Pipecat community for a hackathon in San Francisco on October 19th and 20th. $20,000 in prizes for the best voice AI agents, virtual avatar experiences, UIs for multi-modal AI, art projects, and whatever else we dream up together.

swyx: Voice AI is the hottest new AI engineering skill! I'll be here - Daily has been in the SF AI Hackathon scene for a very long time and this is the biggest prize set I've seen in a while to learn something I've wanted to get good on.

---

Table of Contents

---

AI Twitter Recap

all recaps done by Claude 3.5 Sonnet, best of 4 runs.

AI and Technology Advancements

• Large Language Models (LLMs) and AI Development: @karpathy shared an experiment where he curated a 10-episode podcast called "Histories of Mysteries" using AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude, and NotebookLM in just 2 hours, demonstrating the rapid content creation capabilities enabled by generative AI. @cwolferesearch discussed the potential of o1 (OpenAI's latest model) for automatic prompt engineering, highlighting its ability to leverage increased inference time compute for better reasoning.

• AI in Healthcare: @bindureddy argued for the rapid adoption of AI in healthcare, stating that AI is better than humans at retrieving information and makes fewer mistakes. They suggested that replacing human doctors with AI could benefit humanity.

• AI Model Developments: @OfirPress announced that o1 has set a new state-of-the-art on SciCode, outperforming Claude by a significant margin. @rohanpaul_ai shared information about Nvidia's NVLM-D 1.0 72B model, which performed on par with Llama 3.1 405B on Math and Coding tasks.

• AI Infrastructure: @soumithchintala provided a detailed explanation of how to train a model on 10,000 H100 GPUs, covering topics such as parallelization, communication optimization, and failure recovery strategies.

AI Ethics and Societal Impact

• AI Safety: @NPCollapse shared a resource on building a good future for humanity with AI, describing it as the best attempt to date on this topic.

• AI Regulation: @JvNixon commented on potential issues with Californian laws on AI, suggesting they might violate freedom of speech and thought.

AI Applications and Tools

• AI in Software Development: @AlphaSignalAI announced Pythagora, a VScode extension that uses 14 AI Agents to manage the entire development process, from planning to deployment.

• AI for Data Analysis: @basetenco introduced a new export metrics integration for model inference, allowing easy export to observability platforms like Grafana Cloud.

• AI in Content Creation: @c_valenzuelab shared an example of using AI for location scouting in the latent space, demonstrating the ability to visualize different times and seasons.

Industry Trends and Opinions

• AI Company Valuations: @RazRazcle commented on the rapid growth of OpenAI, noting they've gone from ~0 to 3.5Bn rev in 2 years.

• Software Development Practices: @svpino criticized the trend of overcomplicating software development, calling for a return to simpler, more direct approaches to building applications.

• AI Model Pricing: @_philschmid shared updates on LLM pricing, noting significant price drops from various providers including OpenAI, Google Deepmind, Cohere, Mistral, and Cloudflare.

---

AI Reddit Recap

/r/LocalLlama Recap

Theme 1. Meta Releases Llama 3.2: A Leap in Open-Source Vision Models

• Model refresh on HuggingChat! (Llama 3.2, Qwen, Hermes 3 & more) (Score: 49, Comments: 15): HuggingChat has updated its model lineup, now offering free access to five new models including Qwen2.5-72B-Instruct, Llama-3.2-11B-Vision-Instruct (with vision capabilities), Mistral-Nemo-Instruct-2407, Hermes-3-Llama-3.1-8B, and Phi-3.5-mini-instruct. Additionally, two models with tool calling enabled are available: Meta-Llama-3.1-70B-Instruct and c4ai-command-r-plus-08-2024.
  • Jamba Mini, a 12B active/52B total MoE model, was suggested for its fantastic performance at 256K context and low hallucination rate. It's challenging to run locally but could be hosted by HuggingChat, though it may require vllm support or custom coding.
  • Users expressed interest in trying Jamba Mini, with the HuggingChat team acknowledging its potential but noting the lack of TGI support as a significant issue. They promised to consider the suggestion.
  • A request was made for LongWriter-glm4-9b by thudm, capable of "generating 10,000+ words at once." This model was suggested as suitable for companies with better hardware, like HuggingChat.

• Meta Llama 3.2: A brief analysis of vision capabilities (Score: 244, Comments: 47): Meta has released two multi-modal language models, Llama 3.2, in sizes of 11B and 90B parameters. The author tested the model's vision capabilities across various tasks including image understanding, medical report analysis, and chart analysis, finding it to be a strong performer for everyday use cases and a potential replacement for GPT-4o in certain applications, though GPT-4o still outperforms in more complex tasks. For a detailed analysis, the author refers readers to their in-depth article on Llama 3.2's vision capabilities.
  • Users discussed alternative models like Qwen 2 VL 72B and Molmo, with some suggesting these perform better than Llama 3.2. The author plans to compare the 90B model to Qwen 2 VL 72B.
  • The model's text extraction capabilities were found to be reliable for standard texts but not precise for invoices or tables. Users also expressed interest in its ability to generate coordinates for objects and handle tasks with overlayed grids.
  • The author used Gradio and Together AI cloud services to run the 70B model, citing limited local hardware resources. Some users shared experiences with implementing other models like Qwen 2 VL 72B using Gradio and Transformers.

Theme 2. Advancements in Language-Specific and Task-Specific Models

• google/gemma-2-2b-jpn-it Japanese specific models (Score: 45, Comments: 15): Google has released gemma-2-2b-jpn-it, a Japanese-specific model in the Gemma series, which is now available on Hugging Face. This new model was announced at the Gemma Developer Day in Tokyo, indicating Google's efforts to expand language-specific AI models for the Japanese market.
  • The pre-training of the Japanese-specific Gemma model was conducted in Japanese, as explained in the task-specific tuning documentation. There was no mention of plans for a 9B version or release date for Gemma 3.
  • Sundar Pichai, Google CEO, made a surprise appearance at the Gemma Developer Day, suggesting strong support for the project. A Hugging Face representative also spoke, hinting at potential future GGUF versions of the model.
  • Google introduced several Gemma-related tools, including a Responsible Generative AI Toolkit, Gemma Scope for model analysis, and on-device generation capabilities using MediaPipe. A $150,000 Kaggle contest for global communication with Gemma was also announced.

• Llama-3.1-Nemotron-70B-Reward (Score: 45, Comments: 6): The post title "Llama-3.1-Nemotron-70B-Reward" appears to reference a specific AI language model, but no additional content or context is provided in the post body. Without further information, it's not possible to provide a meaningful summary of the post's content or discussion points.
  • Llama-3.1-Nemotron-70B-Reward performs similarly to Skywork-Reward-Gemma-2-27B on human-annotated tasks, but lags behind on GPT-4 annotated tasks. This suggests Skywork-Reward-Gemma-2-27B better models GPT-4 preferences, likely due to its training on GPT-4 annotated data.
  • The discussion clarifies that Reward-Gemma (not Gemini) aligns better with GPT-4 generated "ground truth" but not human "ground truth". This is attributed to Reward-Gemma's training data including GPT-4 generated text.
  • The model is described as a "new best in class judge for RHLF" (Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback), noted for its accuracy in predicting human preferences.

• New leaderboard: which models are the best at role play? (Score: 40, Comments: 7): A new leaderboard called StickToYourRoleLeaderboard evaluates LLMs' ability to maintain character consistency in role-playing scenarios. The leaderboard, available on Hugging Face, assesses how well models adhere to provided roles and character values throughout discussions, with a detailed explanation thread by the authors available on X (formerly Twitter).
  • Users noted that Mistral performs best among tested models (Llama 3.1-8b, Llama 3.2-3b, Qwen 2.5, Mythomax), emphasizing the importance of base prompts and model parameters.
  • The leaderboard's omission of Mistral Nemo was highlighted, with suggestions to include more popular fine-tuned models in the benchmarking process.

Theme 3. AMD Strix Halo: A Potential Game-Changer for Local LLM Inference

• AMD Strix Halo rumored to have APU with 7600 XT performance & 96 GB of shared VRAM (Score: 68, Comments: 39): AMD's rumored Strix Halo APU is reported to offer performance comparable to the Radeon 7600 XT and support up to 96 GB of shared VRAM. This high-end laptop chip could potentially run large language models in memory without requiring a dedicated AI GPU, with Llama.cpp's Vulkan kernels supporting APUs at speeds similar to ROCm kernels on other AMD hardware, despite current lack of official ROCm support for APUs.
  • AMD's lack of 48GB VRAM GPUs with CUDA support is seen as a missed opportunity in the AI market. The W7900-PRO offers 48GB but at a high price point of $4K, potentially to avoid undercutting AMD's Instinct line.
  • The Strix Halo APU is rumored to use 256-bit LPDDR5X-8000 memory, providing 256GB/s theoretical bandwidth. Some speculate it could reach 500GB/s range, possibly including 3D cache benefits for gaming workloads.
  • Current AMD APUs face limitations with VRAM allocation, allowing only up to 8GB as dedicated VRAM. However, a new feature called Variable Graphics Memory allows conversion of up to 75% of system RAM to "dedicated" graphics memory for AMD Ryzen™ AI 300 series processors.

• Qwen 2.5 Coder 7b for auto-completion (Score: 37, Comments: 17): Qwen 2.5 Coder 7b model demonstrates superior auto-completion capabilities compared to other local models, particularly in handling large contexts of multi-thousand tokens. The user reports a significant reduction in hallucinations and improved code style continuity, making it comparable to Copilot in performance. For implementation with the ContinueDev plugin for IntelliJ, a custom template override is required: "<|fim_prefix|>{ prefix}<|fim_suffix|>{ suffix}<|fim_middle|>", and it's crucial to use the instruct model variant for proper functionality with control tokens and FIM support.
  • Qwen2.5-7b-coder-q8_0.gguf shows promising results for C++ auto-completion in Neovim, with Q8 quantization only ~5% slower than Q4 for short completions. User ggerganov is using 256 prefix and 128 suffix lines for context.
  • Comparisons between Qwen2.5 7b-coder and 14b-instruct models suggest the larger model may offer better context understanding and code explanation, despite not being specifically trained for coding. The 7b-coder version is fine-tuned for auto-completion with special tokens.
  • Confusion arose regarding the use of base vs. instruct models for fill-in-the-middle tasks, with the original poster reporting issues using the base model. Qwen's documentation suggests using the base model for FIM tasks, contradicting user experiences.

Theme 4. Open-Source Tools for AI Development and Evaluation

• How Moshi Works: A Simple Guide to the to Open Source Real Time Voice LLMs (Score: 52, Comments: 7): Moshi, an open-source alternative to OpenAI's Voice mode, is developed by Kyutai for real-time voice in language models. The author shares a link to their post detailing Moshi's architecture, suggesting it's worth understanding despite not being at the same level as OpenAI's offering.

• 🧬 OSS Synthetic Data Generator - Build datasets using natural language (Score: 38, Comments: 3): The post introduces an open-source synthetic data generator that allows users to create datasets using natural language prompts. This tool, which can be found on GitHub, enables the generation of diverse datasets including images, text, and structured data for various machine learning tasks such as classification, object detection, and segmentation. The generator utilizes large language models and image generation models to produce high-quality synthetic data based on user-defined specifications.
  • Hugging Face employee introduces the Distilabel Synthetic Data Generator, an open-source tool for creating high-quality datasets using natural language prompts. The tool can be run locally by cloning the Space or installing the distilabel library.
  • Users express enthusiasm for the tool, praising it for driving the "AI as commodity" paradigm. The creator welcomes feedback and mentions plans to add more tasks and functions in the future.
  • The tool simplifies dataset creation for training and fine-tuning language models, allowing users to define application characteristics, generate system prompts, and produce customizable datasets that can be pushed directly to the Hugging Face Hub.

• “Proverbs 27:17: As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another” “Training Language Models to Win Debates with Self-Play Improves Judge Accuracy” (Score: 35, Comments: 4): The paper introduces DebateGPT, a language model trained through self-play to engage in debates, which led to improved accuracy in judging debate outcomes. By pitting the model against itself in debates on various topics, researchers found that the resulting judge model achieved 83% accuracy in determining debate winners, surpassing both human judges and previous AI models. This approach demonstrates the potential of self-play in enhancing language models' argumentative and analytical capabilities.
  • Self-play and replicating human tendencies in language models, such as Chain of Thought (CoT) and debate-style interactions, are proving highly effective for improving task performance. These "simple" process changes often lead to substantial performance improvements.
  • The paper link https://www.arxiv.org/abs/2409.16636 was provided in the post body, but some users had difficulty accessing it due to app limitations in displaying text on image posts.
  • Discussion highlighted the importance of proper paper citation and linking practices in academic discussions on social media platforms.

Other AI Subreddit Recap

r/machinelearning, r/openai, r/stablediffusion, r/ArtificialInteligence, /r/LLMDevs, /r/Singularity

Here is a summary of the key themes and developments from the provided Reddit posts:

AI Model Advancements and Capabilities

• OpenAI's o1 model is demonstrating impressive reasoning and problem-solving abilities:
  • It can replicate complex PhD-level coding projects in hours that previously took months.
  • It's showing promising results in mathematical proofs, outperforming previous models.
  • OpenAI researcher Hunter Lightman says o1 is already acting like a software engineer and authoring pull requests.

• Google is working on reasoning AI similar to OpenAI's o1, using techniques like chain-of-thought prompting. They've already showcased models like AlphaProof for math reasoning.

• Salesforce released xLAM-1b, a 1 billion parameter model achieving 70% accuracy in function calling, surpassing GPT-3.5 despite its smaller size.

AI Research and Development

• A Google Deepmind paper demonstrates how data curation via joint example selection can accelerate multimodal learning.

• Microsoft's MInference technique enables inference of up to millions of tokens for long-context tasks while maintaining accuracy.

• Research on scaling synthetic data creation using 1 billion web-curated personas shows promise for generating diverse training data.

AI Industry and Funding

• OpenAI is seeking exclusive funding arrangements to accelerate AGI development.

• NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang states that a trillion dollars is being invested in data centers to enable the next wave of AI for business productivity.

AI Ethics and Societal Impact

• There are ongoing discussions about the potential job displacement due to AGI and the need for new economic paradigms.

• Sam Altman suggests being polite to AI assistants like ChatGPT, hinting at potential future developments in AI consciousness or rights.

AI in Image Generation

• New versions of image generation models like PonyRealism v2.2 and RealFlux are being released, showing incremental improvements in realism and capabilities.

---

AI Discord Recap

A summary of Summaries of Summaries

Claude 3.5 Sonnet

1. LLM Advancements and Benchmarking

• DeepSeek-V2 Challenges GPT-4: DeepSeek-V2, a new 236B parameter model, has shown impressive performance on benchmarks like AlignBench and MT-Bench, reportedly surpassing GPT-4 in some areas.
  • The DeepSeek-V2 announcement sparked discussions about its capabilities and potential impact on the AI landscape, with community members eager to explore its full potential.
• Llama 3's Leaderboard Leap: Meta's Llama 3 has quickly risen to the top of leaderboards like ChatbotArena, outperforming models such as GPT-4-Turbo and Claude 3 Opus in over 50,000 matchups.
  • This rapid ascent has ignited discussions about the evolving landscape of large language models and the potential for open-source alternatives to challenge proprietary leaders in the field.

2. Optimizing LLM Inference and Training

• ZeRO++ Slashes Communication Overhead: ZeRO++ promises a 4x reduction in communication overhead for large model training on GPUs, potentially revolutionizing the efficiency of distributed training.
  • This advancement could significantly impact the scalability of LLM training, allowing researchers to train larger models more quickly and cost-effectively.
• vAttention's Dynamic KV Caching: The vAttention system introduces dynamic management of KV-cache memory for efficient LLM inference without relying on PagedAttention.
  • This innovation addresses memory constraints in LLM deployment, potentially enabling more efficient serving of large models on limited hardware resources.
• Consistency LLMs Speed Up Decoding: Techniques like Consistency LLMs explore parallel token decoding to reduce inference latency, promising faster response times for LLM applications.
  • This approach challenges traditional autoregressive decoding methods, opening new avenues for optimizing LLM performance in real-time applications.

3. Open-Source AI Frameworks and Community Efforts

• Axolotl's Dataset Format Expansion: Axolotl has expanded its support for diverse dataset formats, enhancing its capabilities for instruction tuning and pre-training LLMs.
  • This update facilitates easier integration of various data sources, enabling researchers and developers to fine-tune models more effectively with custom datasets.
• LlamaIndex Teams Up with Andrew Ng: LlamaIndex announces a new course on building agentic RAG systems in collaboration with Andrew Ng's DeepLearning.ai, bridging academic insights with practical applications.
  • This partnership aims to democratize advanced AI techniques, making complex concepts like agentic RAG more accessible to a broader audience of developers and researchers.
• Mojo's Python Integration Teased: Modular's new deep dive with Chris Lattner teases Mojo's potential for seamless Python integration and AI-specific extensions like _bfloat16_.
  • The discussion highlights Mojo's ambition to combine Python's accessibility with systems programming capabilities, potentially reshaping AI development workflows.

4. Multimodal AI and Generative Modeling Innovations

• Idefics2 and CodeGemma Push Boundaries: Idefics2 8B Chatty focuses on elevated chat interactions, while CodeGemma 1.1 7B refines coding abilities, showcasing advancements in specialized AI models.
  • These models demonstrate the ongoing trend of tailoring AI capabilities to specific domains, enhancing performance in targeted applications like conversational AI and code generation.
• Phi-3 Brings AI to the Browser: The Phi-3 model introduces powerful AI chatbot capabilities to browsers via WebGPU, potentially revolutionizing client-side AI applications.
  • This development marks a significant step towards more accessible and privacy-preserving AI experiences, enabling sophisticated AI interactions directly within web browsers.
• IC-Light Illuminates Open-Source Image Relighting: The open-source IC-Light project focuses on advancing image relighting techniques, making sophisticated visual effects more accessible to the community.
  • This tool empowers creators and researchers to explore advanced image manipulation techniques, potentially leading to new applications in computer graphics and visual AI.

GPT4O (gpt-4o-2024-05-13)

1. Model Performance Optimization

• Dynamic Memory Compression Boosts Throughput: Dynamic Memory Compression (DMC) boosts throughput by up to 370% on H100 GPUs, enhancing transformer efficiency.
  • @p_nawrot shared insights on the DMC paper, sparking discussions about its impact on large-scale model training.
• ZeRO++ Reduces GPU Communication Overhead: ZeRO++ promises a 4x reduction in communication overhead for large model training on GPUs.
  • @deep_speed highlighted the benefits of ZeRO++, noting its potential to optimize resource utilization.
• Flash Attention's Memory Usage Debated: The community discussed whether Flash Attention exhibits linear memory growth despite quadratic computational complexity.
  • @ggerganov pointed out that Flash Attention could streamline memory usage in large models.

2. Fundraising and New Product Launches

• OpenAI Secures $6.6 Billion Funding: OpenAI successfully raised $6.6 billion to bolster their AI research projects.
  • @openai announced the funding round, with discussions on its impact on future AI advancements.
• FLUX1.1 Pro Impresses with Speed: FLUX1.1 Pro launched, providing six times faster generation and improved image quality.
  • @blackforestlabs shared the FLUX1.1 Pro release, sparking excitement and anticipation in the AI community.
• GPT-4o Realtime API Launch: The GPT-4o Realtime API was released for low-latency audio interactions.
  • @azure detailed the API launch, focusing on applications like customer support.

3. AI Tooling and Community Innovations

• Crawl4AI Enhances Data Collection: Crawl4AI, an open-source web crawler, offers customizable data collection tools.
  • @unclecode introduced Crawl4AI, discussing its integration with language models for improved data extraction.
• Mojo's Error Handling Strategies: Conversations focused on Mojo's error handling, suggesting Zig-style error unions.
  • @msaelices proposed improvements to Mojo's error handling, emphasizing pattern matching and composability.
• MongoDB Atlas Powers Hybrid Search: A blog post on creating and configuring hybrid search indexes with MongoDB Atlas for enhanced search relevance.
  • @llama_index detailed the implementation, merging semantic and full-text search to address common inefficiencies.

4. AI Alignment and Research Discussions

• AI Reading Group Launches: The AI Reading Group from Women in AI & Robotics launches with a focus on research discussions.
  • @aashka_trivedi will present the INDUS paper, highlighting collaboration between IBM and NASA.
• OpenAI's Moderation Policies Debated: Members recounted their experiences with OpenAI's moderation policy, flagging requests to prompt AGI.
  • @eleuther noted that these policies seem overly cautious, suggesting many flagged messages don't align with stated usage policies.
• Softmax Function's Limitations Explored: A paper highlighted the limitations of the softmax function in achieving robust computations as input sizes increase.
  • @nous_research shared the paper, proposing adaptive temperature as a workaround for these limitations.

5. Open-Source Contributions and Collaborations

• Axolotl Adds Dataset Format Docs: Axolotl supports diverse dataset formats for instruction tuning and pre-training LLMs.
  • @axolotl_ai announced the documentation update, enhancing usability for the community.
• OpenDevin Release Announced: The release of OpenDevin, an open-source autonomous AI engineer, garners interest on GitHub.
  • @cognition_ai shared the release, emphasizing its potential for developer collaboration and innovation.

GPT4O-Aug (gpt-4o-2024-08-06)

1. AI Model Performance and Optimization

• FLUX1.1 Pro Surpasses Expectations: FLUX1.1 Pro launched, boasting six times faster generation and improved image quality, achieving the highest Elo score in the Artificial Analysis image arena.
  • The AI community buzzed with excitement, eager to explore the model's potential in optimizing AI workflows and applications.
• Quantization Techniques for Large Models: Discussions around quantization algorithms for large neural networks (50B+ parameters) highlighted techniques like int8 and HQQ for maintaining less than 1% loss in target metrics.
  • Members noted that int4 + hqq quantization is also effective, requiring minimal calibration, sparking interest in optimizing model efficiency.
• GPU Cooling Solutions for AI Setups: A user considered water cooling single slot blocks for their setup of 8 GPUs, noting a maximum power draw of 4000W across two 1600W and one 1500W power supplies.
  • Discussions emphasized the importance of electrical safety and innovative uses of GPU setups, such as heating solutions during colder months.

2. AI Community Practices and Concerns

• OpenAI Bubble Concerns: Members expressed concerns that the OpenAI bubble is expanding precariously, drawing parallels to WeWork and questioning the long-term sustainability of AI hype.
  • The release of o1 temporarily alleviated fears, but discussions highlighted uncertainties about OpenAI's future trajectory and impact on the industry.
• Community Frustration Over Customer Support: Users voiced dissatisfaction with customer support for subscription issues, including file downloads and delayed responses, impacting user retention.
  • One user considered cancelling their subscription, underscoring the significant impact of inadequate support on community satisfaction.
• Addressing AI Model Moderation Issues: Concerns arose over Claude 2.1 flagging SFW prompts, with one instance marking a character description as 'sexual', sparking debate over moderation practices.
  • Community discussions highlighted the need for clearer moderation guidelines to prevent interference with user interactions.

3. AI Tools and Features Launch

• OpenAI's New Canvas Feature: OpenAI introduced the canvas feature for writing and coding projects, allowing Plus & Team users to work beyond simple chat interactions by selecting “GPT-4o with canvas”.
  • The feature aims to improve user experience in project management and collaboration, with discussions on its potential for enhancing complex task workflows.
• GPT-4o Realtime API for Audio: The GPT-4o Realtime API was released for low-latency audio interactions, targeting applications like customer support and requiring client integration for end-user audio.
  • This development sparked interest in enhancing conversational capabilities with real-time audio features for diverse applications.
• LangChain's LangGraph Innovates Query Generation: A LinkedIn post highlighted LangGraph's role in managing complex query generation and output structuring within the LangChain ecosystem.
  • Focus was placed on error correction and user-friendly results, with appreciation for Harrison Chase and the LangChain team's contributions.

4. AI Research and Collaboration

• AI Reading Group Promotes Collaboration: The AI Reading Group from Women in AI & Robotics launches, featuring IBM and NASA research on October 17, 2024, with limited sign-ups for audience Q&A.
  • The group aims to foster direct dialogue between researchers and the community, spotlighting interdisciplinary AI discussions and innovations.
• Exploring Liability in AI Research: Discussion centered on whether individuals who share AI models for research could be held liable for misuse, with a call for clear legal guidelines.
  • Members emphasized the importance of clarity in legal waters to establish responsible AI research practices and protect original researchers.
• Knowledge Graph Embedding Innovations: A paper introduced a novel approach to knowledge graph embedding (KGE), integrating uncertainty through group theory for efficient and expressive models.
  • This approach allows entities and relations to be embedded as permutations in a symmetric group, suggesting potential for improved KGE frameworks.

5. AI Ethics and Data Privacy

• Concerns Over Data Privacy in AI: A member raised alarms about data privacy, alleging AI firms, including OpenAI, focus on stealing data from mid-sized companies, sparking debate.
  • Discussions emphasized the importance of transparency and opt-out options for data sharing, reflecting broader concerns in the AI community.
• AI's Impact on Future Movies: An article explored AI's impact on filmmaking, suggesting technology will reshape storytelling and production processes, accessible here.
  • The conversation pointed out emerging trends that could redefine audience engagement in cinema, with AI playing a pivotal role in transforming the industry.
• Legal Status of Web Scraping: Concerns were raised over ongoing litigation regarding web scraping, with artists and writers frustrated about its legal status and implications.
  • The conversation highlighted legal complexities and the need for clear guidelines to balance data access and intellectual property rights.

O1-mini

Theme 1. AI Models on the Fast Track: Speed and Savings

• FLUX1.1 Pro Zooms Ahead: FLUX1.1 Pro launches with six times faster generation and superior image quality, clinching the highest Elo score in the Artificial Analysis image arena.
• GPT-4o Slashes Prices: Starting today, GPT-4o's input costs drop by 50% and output by 33%, aligning with the updated model GPT-4o-2024-08-06 available since August.
• NVIDIA's NVLM 1.0 Unveiled: NVLM 1.0 introduces open-sourced weights for vision-language tasks, positioning NVIDIA as a key competitor against proprietary models.

Theme 2. Seamless Integration: Bringing AI to Your Projects

• gpt4free Joins Chatbots: A member successfully integrated gpt4free into their chatbot, enhancing flexibility despite slower performance and frequent provider switches.
• Cloud Solutions for AMD GPU Challenges: Facing fine-tuning issues on Windows without CUDA, members recommend cloud platforms like Lambda Labs or Collab, ensuring effective training on AMD hardware.
• Shadeform's GPU Marketplace Streams: Shadeform offers a centralized billing and management system for reserving on-demand GPUs, simplifying multi-cloud deployment for developers.

Theme 3. Tackling Tech Troubles: Overcoming AI Training Hurdles

• Quantization Conundrums Solved: Developers explore quantization algorithms like int8 and HQQ to maintain <1% loss in large models (50B+ parameters), leveraging Hugging Face's guide for implementation.
• Mojo's Import Mysteries: Mojo faces challenges with Python's dynamic imports, prompting discussions on security risks and potential delegations to CPython.
• Flash Attention's Memory Mix-Up: The Flash Attention feature shows inconsistent memory behavior, with some users experiencing linear growth despite its quadratic computational complexity, as seen in llama.cpp Pull Request #5021.

Theme 4. Building Bridges: Engaging the AI Community

• AI Reading Groups Ignite Collaboration: Launching in multiple Discords, groups from Women in AI & Robotics feature presentations like INDUS by Aashka Trivedi from IBM and NASA, fostering direct dialogue and interdisciplinary discussions.
• Unsloth Webinars Share Insights: The Unsloth Webinar highlights shifts to lower precision bits for training speed and the integration of high-quality datasets, sparking deeper technical conversations.
• Festive AI House Parties: Events like the October House Party encourage members to showcase their Open Interpreter creations, blending fun with knowledge sharing and community bonding.

Theme 5. Powering Progress: Optimizing AI Tools and Infrastructure

• Torchtune 0.3.1 Boosts Fine-Tuning: The latest Torchtune 0.3.1 update includes all Llama 3.2 Vision models, introduces MPS beta support for Macbooks, and offers a new knowledge distillation recipe for models like Llama3.2 and Qwen2.
• LlamaIndex Enhances Hybrid Search: Integrating MongoDB Atlas with LlamaIndex allows for seamless hybrid search, combining semantic and full-text search to improve result relevance.
• Aider Expands with Real-time APIs: The launch of the GPT-4o Realtime API in Aider enables low-latency audio interactions for applications like customer support, enhancing conversational capabilities.

---

Links Mentioned: - FLUX1.1 Pro on Replicate - Artificial Analysis Image Arena - GPT-4o GitHub Release - Lambda Labs - Shadeform AI Marketplace - Hugging Face Quantization Guide - llama.cpp Pull Request #5021 - INDUS Paper - Unsloth Documentation - Aider Configuration Options - Torchtune Documentation - Torchtune GitHub Release - LlamaIndex with MongoDB Atlas

O1-preview

Theme 1. OpenAI's New Features and Strategic Moves

• OpenAI Launches Canvas, Revolutionizing Collaboration: OpenAI introduced the Canvas feature, allowing users to interact with ChatGPT beyond simple chats for writing and coding projects. Plus & Team users can try it now by selecting “GPT-4o with canvas” in the model picker.
• GPT-4o Prices Slashed Amid Model Update: OpenAI reduced the price of GPT-4o by 50% for input and 33% for output, aligning with the updated GPT-4o-2024-08-06 model available since August. This move makes advanced AI capabilities more accessible to users.
• Sam Altman Tightens Grip as OpenAI Eyes $157B Valuation: Reports reveal Sam Altman amplifying his influence at OpenAI during its rise toward a staggering $157 billion valuation. This concentration of leadership raises questions about the organization's future trajectory.

Theme 2. Innovations in AI Models and Tools

• FLUX1.1 Pro Blazes Ahead with Sixfold Speed Boost: The newly released FLUX1.1 Pro delivers six times faster generation, improved image quality, and holds the highest Elo score in the Artificial Analysis image arena. This model sets a new performance standard in image generation.
• NVIDIA Unveils NVLM 1.0, Challenging Proprietary Models: NVIDIA introduced NVLM 1.0, an open-source model designed for vision-language tasks, rivaling leading proprietary models in accuracy. Developers can access the weights and code, paving the way for new innovations.
• StackBlitz Drops Bolt for AI-Powered Fullstack Development: Bolt by StackBlitz allows users to prompt, edit, run, and deploy fullstack applications with AI support. It offers a free, comprehensive development environment supporting npm, Vite, and Next.js.

Theme 3. Challenges and Concerns with AI Model Limitations

• Moderation Madness: SFW Prompts Flagged by AI: Users report Claude 2.1 and other models erroneously flagging safe-for-work prompts as inappropriate, disrupting interactions. A character description was incorrectly marked as 'sexual', sparking debates over overzealous moderation practices.
• Softmax's Soft Spot: Limitations in Sharp Decisions: A paper reveals the softmax function's inability to approximate sharp functions as inputs increase, challenging its effectiveness in AI reasoning tasks. Authors suggest adaptive temperature as a potential remedy, prompting further research.
• GPU Woes: Running Big Models on Modest Hardware: Users grapple with difficulties running large models like SDXL on older GPUs, exploring alternatives like ZLUDA for AMD users. The community discusses strategies to balance performance with hardware limitations.

Theme 4. Community Engagement and Learning in AI

• AI Reading Group Bridges Research and Community: The AI Reading Group from Women in AI & Robotics launches, featuring Aashka Trivedi from IBM presenting joint research with NASA on October 17, 2024. The session will delve into INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models for Scientific Applications.
• DSPy 2.5 Gets Thumbs Up, Calls for More Docs: Users praise DSPy 2.5 for improvements like TypedPredictors but urge for better documentation on customization and integrating Pydantic. Enhanced guides could unlock advanced features for users.
• Fiery Debates Over Data Practices and Privacy: Members express concerns about data privacy, alleging that some AI firms focus on stealing data from mid-sized companies. The community debates the ethics and legality of data usage in AI development.

Theme 5. Technical Discussions on AI Model Optimization

• Quantization Quest: Balancing Size and Accuracy: Developers explore quantization algorithms like int8, HQQ, and int4 + HQQ for large models (50B+ parameters), aiming for less than 1% loss in target metrics. Techniques like HQQ offer efficiency with minimal calibration needed.
• Mojo Battles Python Imports and Error Handling Woes: The Mojo programming language struggles with Python's dynamic imports, complicating integration and error management. Community members debate adopting Zig-style error unions and other strategies to improve Mojo's robustness.
• Flash Attention Sparks Memory Usage Mystery: Users question whether Flash Attention results in linear memory growth despite quadratic computational complexity. Mixed experiences prompt discussions to clarify its actual impact on memory and performance.

---

PART 1: High level Discord summaries

Unsloth AI (Daniel Han) Discord

• Morning greetings lead to casual chat: Members exchanged morning greetings, leading to a light-hearted discussion about time differences, humorously noting that, 'if ur not in EST or PST ur missing out.'
  • This relaxed atmosphere set the tone for further technical discussions.
• Debate over Jupyter Notebook vs VS Code: Members voiced their preferences on interfaces, with one expressing dissatisfaction with Jupyter Notebook, stating it felt outdated compared to VS Code.
  • Another member countered, asserting that they preferred VS Code for its notebook support and overall usability.
• Concerns about Qwen model reliability: Discussion raised concerns regarding the reliability of Qwen models, with users reporting unexpected results from familiar configurations.
  • The absence of models on the Unsloth page confused members, intensifying the discussion.
• Insights from the Unsloth Webinar: Key points highlighted in the Unsloth Webinar emphasized the shift to lower precision bits during training, aimed at improving speed.
  • Members discussed the integration of high-quality datasets and enhanced model architecture for deeper learning.
• Challenges with Fine-tuning on AMD GPUs: A member questioned how to run Unsloth on Windows without CUDA support, sparking discussions about AMD's limitations in ML.
  • Recommendations included using cloud solutions like Lambda Labs or Collab for effective training.

---

HuggingFace Discord

• Users Encounter Model Access Issues: Several users reported issues accessing models like Llama, facing timeouts and restrictions with Hugging Face platforms, impacting the usability of popular models.
  • One user confirmed running Llama-3.2-1B on older hardware like a GeForce 980Ti, showcasing that even limited resources can still be sufficient.
• gpt4free Successfully Integrated: A member successfully integrated gpt4free into their chatbot, although experiencing slower performance and the need for frequent provider changes.
  • This integration also included adding two OpenAI models, demonstrating adaptable development during their Release v1.3.0 on GitHub.
• FLUX1.1 Pro Impresses with Speed: FLUX1.1 Pro launched, providing six times faster generation and improved image quality, achieving the highest Elo score in the Artificial Analysis image arena.
  • This model's performance sparked excitement and anticipation for further advancements in the AI community.
• AI Reading Group Launch Announced: The AI Reading Group from Women in AI & Robotics launches, with its inaugural session featuring a presentation from IBM about joint research with NASA on October 17, 2024.
  • A member suggested streaming events on Discord and Eventbrite to broaden audience engagement, enhancing community involvement in AI research.
• Hugging Face Courses Recommended for Beginners: Members recommended Hugging Face courses and the Open Source AI Cookbook as essential resources for newcomers to NLP, emphasizing the importance of combining practical experience with foundational theory.
  • Resources like 'The Illustrated Transformer' and 3blueonebrown were cited as helpful for understanding complex concepts in NLP.

---

aider (Paul Gauthier) Discord

• Aider Telemetry Data Collection Concerns: Users discussed that Aider currently lacks telemetry data collection, limiting insights into usage metrics and trends.
  • Suggestions for future telemetry included monitoring model choices and tokens while ensuring privacy.
• Cursor vs Aider - Battle of Interfaces: Members compared Aider and Cursor, noting the smoother interface of Cursor, yet praising Aider's efficiency in terminal use.
  • Dissatisfaction arose over Cursor's inconsistencies in its Composer feature, contrasting with Aider's reliability.
• Claude Development Sparks Interest: Interest in Claude Development grew among users for its promising coding assistance capabilities.
  • Users eagerly awaited updates, eager to compare its potential improvements over current tools.
• Launch of GPT-4o Realtime API: The GPT-4o Realtime API was released for low-latency audio interactions aimed at applications like customer support.
  • Integration requires handling end-user audio, enhancing conversational capabilities.
• Crawl4AI Enhances Data Collection: Crawl4AI is now available as an open-source LLM-friendly web crawler, offering developers customizable data collection tools.
  • Its integration with language models could significantly improve operational data extraction processes.

---

OpenRouter (Alex Atallah) Discord

• DeepInfra Outage Duration Compromised: DeepInfra experienced an outage lasting about 15 minutes but is now recovering.
  • Users were informed shortly after about the status and ongoing recovery efforts.
• GPT-4o Slashes Prices by Half: The price for the GPT-4o model drops 50% for input and 33% for output starting today.
  • This adjustment aligns with the updated model GPT-4o-2024-08-06 that has been available since August.
• Moderation Confusion with Claude 2.1: Users raised concerns about Claude 2.1 flagging SFW prompts, which interferes with interactions.
  • One flag-worthy instance involved a character description incorrectly marked as 'sexual', sparking debate over moderation practices.
• NVIDIA Unveils NVLM 1.0 Model: NVIDIA has announced its competitive NVLM 1.0, which offers open-sourced weights and code designed for vision-language tasks.
  • This model is expected to enhance performance and accuracy, rivalling proprietary models in the space.
• Flash 8B Model Slowing Down Production: The Flash 8B model is now in production but registers 200 tokens per second, slower than previous versions.
  • Discussions indicate potential speed upgrades might be considered in the future to address hardware efficiency.

---

Modular (Mojo 🔥) Discord

• Mojo struggles with Python imports: Discussions revealed that Mojo cannot natively handle Python's dynamic import behavior, complicating integration and error management.
  • Members noted that delegating imports to CPython might introduce security risks similar to issues seen in the NPM ecosystem.
• Mojo functions encounter returned value issues: Members discovered that returning values from functions in Mojo sometimes requires a variable declaration (e.g., using var) to avoid runtime errors.
  • An example was shared showing that SIMD initialization fails unless modified to return a mutable object.
• Exploring error handling strategies: Conversations focused on potential improvements to Mojo's error handling, with suggestions leaning towards Zig-style error unions for inferred error types.
  • Some members advocated for a more functional programming approach to error management, emphasizing pattern matching and composability.
• Static data storage complexities: Users sought ways to statically store tables in Mojo without incurring excessive code bloat, especially from constructs like List.
  • The emphasis was on matching the performance and memory efficiency seen in C static declarations.
• SIMD initialization issues spark GitHub discussions: A request was made to create a GitHub issue regarding the unexpected behavior of the SIMD.__init__ constructor, which returned errors under certain conditions.
  • Members expressed willingness to help track down the root cause of SIMD related bugs.

---

OpenAI Discord

• Canvas Feature Launches for Writing & Coding: OpenAI announced an early version of the canvas feature, allowing users to work on writing and coding projects that extend beyond simple chat interactions. Starting today, Plus & Team users can try it by selecting “GPT-4o with canvas” in the model picker.
  • This enhancement aims to improve user experience in project management and collaboration, leveraging advanced AI capabilities for complex tasks.
• API Access tier confusion: Discussion emerged regarding API access being rolled out to specific usage tiers, with one user experiencing a 403 error despite previous access. The conversation highlighted the importance of approaching rate limit issues and handling errors effectively.
  • Members shared insights on mitigating rate limits found in the OpenAI Cookbook, emphasizing community support for navigating these API challenges.
• Impressions of the new Copilot App: Users expressed positive feedback on the performance of the new Copilot App, noting its smooth usability as a native app on Android. However, concerns arose about the inability to delete chats, highlighting comparison points with other chatbots.
  • Community discussions focused on user experience, comparing features and functionality, suggesting room for improvement.
• Voice Feature Now Available in Custom GPTs: A member celebrated the introduction of the voice feature in custom GPTs available in the GPT store today, appreciating OpenAI for resolving previous concerns. They noted that the voice mode is not the new advanced voice, which users hope will be included for all custom GPTs in the future.
  • This enhancement reflects an ongoing request for richer interactive features in GPTs, indicating the community's desire for continuous improvement.
• Ninetails Training Data Flaw in 4o-mini: A user identified that 4o-mini consistently misidentifies Ninetails as having 6 tails when asked about fire-type Pokémon, while 4o provides the correct answer. This pattern across multiple regenerations suggests a flaw in the training data rather than typical hallucinations.
  • The discrepancy was further investigated, revealing that smaller models like gpt-3.5-turbo and gpt-4o-mini display inaccurate responses, raising questions about their training datasets.

---

Stability.ai (Stable Diffusion) Discord

• Virtual Environments Are Key for Compatibility: Members recommended using virtual environments like venv or conda to avoid conflicts with Python versions when running tools like AUTOMATIC1111.
  • Virtual environments streamline package management, ensuring different setups don’t disrupt workflows.
• Choosing the Right AI Model and UI: New users were encouraged to use Comfy UI for its flexibility, alongside mentions of Automatic1111 and the faster Forge UI fork.
  • Comfy UI’s node-based design offers more versatility, while Automatic1111 is still popular for tutorials.
• Generating Images in Specific Poses: Users tackled challenges in generating images with specific poses and recommended the use of ControlNet for enhanced output control.
  • Training specific models like LoRA helps adjust generated images to meet user expectations.
• Navigating AI Model Limitations: Discussions highlighted issues with running SDXL on older GPUs, suggesting alternatives like ZLUDA for AMD users.
  • While lower resolutions can expedite processing, optimal results usually require higher resolutions suited for specific models.
• Experimenting with AI Model Training: A user shared their training experience that ended in complications, highlighting the consequences of improper image selection.
  • This serves as a reminder on the importance of adhering to community standards when training AI models.

---

Nous Research AI Discord

• FLUX1.1 Pro Outpaces Competition: FLUX1.1 Pro was announced with six times faster generation and improved image quality compared to its predecessors, indicating a significant upgrade.
  • Users can leverage this performance for more efficient workflows, as emphasized in the release announcement.
• Grok Usage Verification Required: Discussion emerged about the need for verification and payment to access Grok, leading to mixed opinions among members.
  • It was clarified that some users can access the service without verification, though they still need to pay for it.
• Softmax Function's Limitations Explored: A paper highlighted limitations of the softmax function in achieving robust computations as input sizes increase, pointing to a theoretical proof of its shortcomings.
  • The authors propose adaptive temperature as a potential workaround for these limitations.
• Searching for Uncensored Story-Creating LLMs: A user inquired about the best LLM for creating stories that is both uncensored and can be run as an API.
  • They also sought sites that build stories using LLMs automatically without just providing standard help.
• Controlling Model Thought Process Revealed: Concerns were raised about the controls in place to prevent models from revealing their chain of thought, questioning their impact on self-explanation capabilities.
  • This points to ongoing discussions about balancing transparency with security in AI interactions.

---

Perplexity AI Discord

• Audio Reading Feature Gets Mixed Reviews: Users discussed the potential for an audio reading feature, finding it helpful for consuming long responses but facing issues with pronunciation.
  • One member indicated they frequently use this feature while multitasking, showcasing its perceived value.
• Frustrations with Subscription Customer Support: Several users voiced frustration due to subscription issues like downloading files and delayed responses from support regarding security concerns.
  • One individual even contemplated cancelling their subscription, highlighting a significant impact on user retention.
• Inconsistency in Model Output Quality: Community discussions revealed concerns about the inconsistent quality of models, especially under the Collection or Pro package.
  • Members noted extreme performance instability, raising doubts about the product's reliability.
• AI's Impact on Future Movies Explored: An article details AI's impact on filmmaking, suggesting technology will reshape storytelling and production processes, accessible here.
  • The conversation pointed out emerging trends that could redefine audience engagement in cinema.
• OpenAI Secures Significant Funding: Reports reveal that OpenAI successfully raised $6.6 billion, which is expected to bolster their AI research projects; details found here.
  • This funding is anticipated to significantly advance their technology and platform capabilities.

---

Cohere Discord

• OpenAI Bubble on the Brink: Members expressed concerns that the OpenAI bubble is expanding precariously, particularly after the release of o1, which temporarily soothed fears.
  • This feels like WeWork all over again, as discussions highlighted uncertainties about OpenAI's long-term fate.
• Cohere's Low-Profile Strategy: Admiration for Cohere's strategy surfaced, with comments suggesting that it operates across the board while maintaining a grounded presence in the AI sphere.
  • This cautious approach might offer Cohere a competitive edge in a landscape filled with visibility-seeking players.
• Shifting AGI Concepts: A belief emerged that the concept of AGI is set to evolve dramatically over the next two decades, igniting vigorous discussion among members.
  • Such a shift could redefine both expectations and scope within the AI ecosystem, causing surprise among community members.
• Concerns Over Data Privacy: A member raised alarms about data privacy, alleging that some AI firms, including OpenAI, are focused on stealing data from mid-sized companies.
  • The community debated this claim's validity, pointing out that companies have options to opt-out of data sharing practices.
• Reranking API hitting rate limit: Frustrations brewed over the reranking API, as a user reported hitting a rate limit while only making minimal API calls with 50 records.
  • This issue raises questions about the constraints of the free tier, potentially hindering effective testing.

---

Interconnects (Nathan Lambert) Discord

• OpenAI Launches Canvas for Enhanced Collaboration: OpenAI's new Canvas interface allows users to engage more intuitively with ChatGPT for writing and coding projects, enhancing collaboration overall.
  • Despite its benefits, limitations like lack of rendered frontend code and difficulty tracking code evolution have been highlighted by early users.
• Sam Altman's Growing Authority at OpenAI: An article reveals how Sam Altman has amplified his influence at OpenAI, coinciding with its soaring $157 billion valuation.
  • This moment raises critical questions about the repercussions of concentrated leadership on the organization’s future trajectory.
• c.ai Faces Potential PR Crisis: Warnings surfaced about an impending PR disaster for c.ai, with members expressing their concerns about the company's reputation.
  • The community shared a sense of disappointment in the ongoing situation, with sentiments echoing feelings of sadness and resignation.
• Exploring Shadeform's GPU Marketplace: Members discussed Shadeform, which offers a marketplace for reserving on-demand GPUs, enhancing multi-cloud deployment capabilities.
  • Centralized billing and management features seem to streamline workload deployment, highlighting Shadeform’s efficiency.
• O1 Preview's Thought Process Revelation: A Reddit post revealed that O1 Preview accidentally disclosed its complete thought process, attracting significant attention in the chat.
  • One member humorously suggested this could inspire a compelling blog post, illustrating the unexpected transparency within the tech community.

---

Latent Space Discord

• OpenAI launches ChatGPT Canvas: OpenAI introduced ChatGPT Canvas, a new interface for collaborative projects within ChatGPT that allows users to edit code and receive in-line feedback.
  • Features include direct editing capabilities, task shortcuts, and improved research functionalities.
• StackBlitz debuts Bolt platform: StackBlitz launched Bolt, a platform for prompting, editing, running, and deploying fullstack applications with AI support.
  • This development environment fully supports npm, Vite, and Next.js, providing a free toolset for app creation.
• Gartner recognizes AI engineering: Gartner has acknowledged Writer as an Emerging Leader for Generative AI Technologies, underscoring the significance of AI in enterprise solutions.
  • This recognition highlights advancements in areas like Generative AI Engineering and AI Knowledge Management Apps.
• Google's Gemini AI competes with OpenAI: Google is developing a reasoning AI model known as Gemini AI, setting itself in competition against OpenAI's capabilities.
  • This initiative builds on Google's legacy of advanced AI systems like AlphaGo, aiming for enhanced human-like reasoning abilities.
• Discussion on Reflection 70B Model: Sahil Chaudhary discussed challenges with the Reflection 70B model, particularly around benchmark reproducibility and output quality.
  • Community members raised concerns regarding evaluation inconsistencies and the model's overall impact on AI.

---

LM Studio Discord

• Confusion Over LM Studio Setup: Debates on connecting LM Studio with Langflow revealed users' frustrations regarding the clarity over the OpenAI component's base URL.
  • There were concerns about the grammaticality of message queries, indicating a need for improved documentation.
• Improved Outputs with LM Studio Update: Updating LM Studio from version 0.2.31 to 0.3.3 led to notable enhancements in model output despite unchanged settings.
  • This sparked inquiries about the role of key-value caching in affecting output quality.
• Limitations in Managing Context: Users discussed the challenges of maintaining context across sessions in LM Studio's inherently stateless architecture.
  • Participants emphasized the difficulties in providing persistent input without repetition.
• Flash Attention Sparks Controversy: The Flash Attention feature was discussed extensively, with frustrations over its unavailability on certain GPU models like GTX.
  • A GitHub pull request was shared, showcasing significant speedups it can provide.
• Water Cooling for Optimal GPU Performance: A member is considering water cooling single slot blocks for a setup with 8 cards, drawn by their max power of 4000W.
  • Current plans involve two 1600W and one 1500W power supplies to maintain ideal thermal conditions.

---

GPU MODE Discord

• Quantization Algorithms for Large Models: Members discussed suitable quantization algorithms for large neural networks (50B+ parameters) that maintain less than 1% loss in target metrics, highlighting techniques like int8 and HQQ.
  • One member noted that int4 + hqq quantization is also effective, given it requires minimal calibration.
• Exploring BF16 Weights Impact on Accuracy: A member expressed concern about potentially sacrificing accuracy by training with BF16 weights instead of FP32 while utilizing 4090 VRAM.
  • They believe it's viable to use FP32 for weights while keeping the optimizer as BF16 within their current configuration.
• Understanding Metal Programming Basics: A newcomer grasped that while CUDA uses block_size * grid_size for thread dispatch, Metal just involves the grid size for simpler thread management.
  • They highlighted that threadgroups in Metal are designed for shared memory among grids.
• Longer Project Lifespan is Helpful: A member stated that having a longer duration for projects aids progression, especially since it often takes time to gain momentum.
  • They underscored the importance of retaining ample hours for completion.
• Inquiry on Self-Compressing Neural Networks Implementation: A member inquired about Issue #658 on GitHub, regarding Self-Compressing Neural Networks, focusing on dynamic quantization-aware training.
  • They aim to implement it as an option during training to let users select a specific VRAM budget.

---

Eleuther Discord

• Exploring Liability in AI Research: Discussion centered on whether individuals who share AI models for research could be held liable if others misuse them, with some suggesting liability may not attach to the original researcher.
  • Members noted that a clear ruling may be necessary to establish guidelines, emphasizing the need for clarity in these legal waters.
• Litigation on Scraping Raises Concerns: Concerns were raised over ongoing litigation regarding the legal status of web scraping, with artists and writers expressing frustration about the practice.
  • An example case was cited, where companies unsuccessfully tried to prohibit scraping unless strict conditions were met, highlighting legal complexities.
• The Impact of OpenAI's Moderation Policies: A member recounted their experience with OpenAI's moderation policy, which flagged their request to prompt AGI, leading to unsettling moments over perceived violations.
  • Others agreed that these policies appear overly cautious, suggesting many flagged messages do not align with the stated usage policies.
• Opportunities for Creative AI Projects: A new member introduced themselves as a researcher seeking collaborative projects on commons-based approaches within AI, highlighting potential interdisciplinary research.
  • This became a call for engagement, especially for contributions in digital humanities.
• MMLU Scoring Resources Shared: A member inquired about obtaining MMLU scores for new models, leading to the recommendation of the evaluation harness by EleutherAI.
  • They also mentioned a dedicated channel for further discussion on the topic, promoting collaborative learning.

---

DSPy Discord

• DSPy 2.5 Feedback Rolls In: Users report an overall pleasing experience with DSPy 2.5, noting the positive changes with TypedPredictors but calling for more customization documentation.
  • The feedback emphasizes that while updates are promising, more guidance could enhance the usability for advanced features.
• Documentation Gets a Makeover Demand: Community voices demand improvements in DSPy documentation, especially regarding the integration of Pydantic and multiple LMs.
  • Members stressed the importance of user-friendly guides to tackle complex generation tasks, which could help onboard new users effectively.
• AI Arxiv Podcast Intro: The new AI Arxiv podcast highlights how big tech implements LLMs, aiming to provide valuable insights for practitioners in the field.
  • Listeners were directed to an episode on document retrieval with Vision Language Models, with future plans to upload content to YouTube for accessibility.
• Must-Have LLM Resource Suggestions: In search of resources, a member prompted suggestions for AI/LLM-related news, pointing to platforms like Twitter and relevant subreddits.
  • Responses included a curated Twitter list focusing on essential discussions and updates in the LLM space, enhancing knowledge sharing.
• Optimizing DSPy Prompt Pipelines: Discussion arose around the self-improvement aspect of DSPy prompt pipelines compared to conventional LLM training methods.
  • Papers on optimizing strategies for multi-stage language model programs were recommended, delving into the advantages of fine-tuning and prompt strategies.

---

Torchtune Discord

• Torchtune 0.3.1 Launches with Key Enhancements: The Torchtune 0.3.1 update includes all Llama 3.2 Vision models, enhancing multimodal support for fine-tuning, generation, and evaluation.
  • Key improvements feature fine-tuning Llama 3.1 405B using QLoRA on 8 x A100s, optimizing performance options dramatically.
• Tokenizer Auto Truncation Causes Data Loss: The text completion dataset experiences automatic truncation at max_seq_len, resulting in token loss from larger documents, leading to requests for increased user control.
  • Proposals surfaced to separate packing max_seq_len from tokenizer limits to minimize unnecessary truncation.
• Knowledge Distillation Recipe Now Available: A new knowledge distillation recipe is added for configurations like Llama3.2 and Qwen2, enhancing user toolkit options.
  • Members are prompted to utilize these features to boost model efficiency and performance.
• Concern Over Flash Attention Memory Allocation: Discussions arose regarding whether Flash Attention exhibits linear memory growth, in contrast to its quadratic computational complexity, creating a variance in expected memory usage.
  • Participants noted mixed experiences with memory consumption, conflicting assessments about its actual behavior.
• Push for Better HF Dataset References: A proposed mapping system like DATASET_TO_SOURCE aims to streamline access to HF dataset names, facilitating clearer model card generation.
  • Focus remains on enhancing dataset documentation clarity in YAML format, reflecting an effort to streamline project capabilities.

---

LlamaIndex Discord

• MongoDB Atlas Powers Hybrid Search: A recent post teaches how to create and configure MongoDB Atlas vector and full-text search indexes to facilitate hybrid search implementation, merging semantic with full-text search.
  • This method notably enhances the relevance of search results, addressing common search inefficiencies.
• Box Integration for Smarter Apps: A guide introduces integrating Box tools with LlamaIndex to develop AI-driven content management applications.
  • This enables advanced searches, optimizing information extraction and processing directly from Box content.
• Challenges in RAG System Setup: Users reported encountering a ModuleNotFoundError with a tutorial on building a RAG system using Excel, hinting at pandas version conflicts.
  • A user recommended reverting to an older pandas version (2.2.2 or lower) to potentially fix the compatibility issue, shared in the GitHub example.
• Async Conversion Queries in RAG Implementation: A developer is navigating the conversion of a RAG app to async and questions the async compatibility of QueryEngineTool and the role of RouterQueryEngine.
  • Responses clarified how to implement async methods within the RouterQueryEngine, providing a smoother transition into async processing.
• Generating RFP Responses with LlamaIndex: A developer seeks guidance on leveraging LlamaIndex to generate RFP responses using data from winning proposals, focusing on efficient indexing strategies.
  • They expressed interest in LlamaIndex's capability to produce PDFs or Word documents from generated responses.

---

LangChain AI Discord

• Jordan Pfost Brings a Decade of AI Experience: Jordan Pfost introduced himself as a Sr. Fullstack Engineer with 10 years of experience in AI/Web products, focusing on GPU Clustering, RAG, and Agentic Reasoning.
  • Looking to collaborate, he shared insights from his projects like spendeffect.ai and iplan.ai.
• Kapa.ai's Impressive Capabilities: Kapa.ai showcased itself as a transformer-based model boasting around 340 million parameters, designed for natural language tasks.
  • It also mentioned its training on diverse data, ensuring the generation of human-like quality text, while referring members to LangChain documentation for further exploration.
• Decoding Like and Reward in LLMs: Kapa.ai clarified that LLMs operate based on patterns from training data and do not possess personal preferences or rewards.
  • They referenced a paper on preference optimization and pointed out more insights available in LangChain documentation.
• Connecting Students to AI Internships: A member opened the floor for college students from India seeking internships in AI, encouraging them to express their interest.
  • This discussion aims to bridge students with potential AI internship opportunities.
• LangGraph Innovates Query Generation: A LinkedIn post highlighted how LangGraph manages complex query generation within the LangChain ecosystem.
  • Focusing on error correction and user-friendly results, the post acknowledged contributions from Harrison Chase and the LangChain team.

---

OpenInterpreter Discord

• October House Party Happening Tomorrow: Don't forget the October House Party tomorrow – join here for fun and updates.
  • One member expressed they are not missing this one due to previous health and work constraints.
• Showcase Your Open Interpreter Creations: The host invited members to showcase their work using Open Interpreter during the party, encouraging questions and experience sharing.
  • This prompted mixed responses on timing, with some members feeling it’s too early while others excitedly declared, PARTY TIMEEEE.
• Exploring Skill Teaching in Models: Members discussed how to effectively teach skills to their model, emphasizing clarity in intent to enable successful teaching.
  • Despite attempts, unresolved issues prompted suggestions for additional support moving forward.
• Model Vision Capabilities Confusion: The conversation turned to whether skills come with vision capabilities, contingent on the specific model used.
  • A user noted using gpt4o with Cartesia and Deepgram, with discussions concluding it should theoretically work.
• Issues with OpenAI Requests: A user reported that OpenAI requests fail after a few messages, with no accompanying errors or logs.
  • The situation illustrates potential system issues, leading to recommendations for a new post on troubleshooting.

---

OpenAccess AI Collective (axolotl) Discord

• Logo change sparks mixed reactions: Members reacted to the recent logo change with a mix of emojis from confusion to frustration, indicating varying levels of acceptance.
  • One member humorously noted, 'I thought I lost the server from my list 😅.'
• Funding expectations questioned: One member humorously expected the new logo to correlate with raising $10 million at a $1 billion valuation.
  • Another user responded, 'Sheeesh,' indicating disbelief at the ambitious targets.
• Demo experiences shared: A member shared their experience with the demo, stating, 'It’s not bad I used it through the demo,' suggesting positive interaction.
  • The ongoing conversation indicates that members are still getting accustomed to the changes.
• Fine-tuning discussions in progress: Members raised questions about whether the model was fine-tuned yet, confirming it has not been fine-tuned as of now.
  • One member reassured that fine-tuning will happen soon and highlighted plans to deploy a 70 billion parameter model once ready.

---

LAION Discord

• Regex rules dramatically curb spam: A member shared a regex pattern \[[^\]]+\]\(https?:\/\/[^)\s]+\) that effectively blocks markdown link obfuscation, reducing the presence of spam bots.
  • Custom regex and word blocklists targeting specific spam categories have shown to significantly diminish unwanted bot activity.
• 60s timeout strategy keeps spam at bay: Implementing a 60-second timeout post-message blocking effectively pushes spam bots to exit after a few attempts.
  • This tactic helps maintain the user experience by minimizing interruptions for legitimate users.
• Google's Illuminate: the new AI tool on the block: A spotlight on Google's Illuminate tool suggests it might be a game-changer for researchers looking for AI-generated audio summaries of complex content.
  • Members are keen to compare its functionality against the notebooklm podcast tool, highlighting a strong interest in both innovations.
• Arxflix brings Arxiv papers to YouTube: Check out Arxflix, an automated YouTube channel dedicated to turning Arxiv papers into engaging video content.
  • The creator expressed excitement over the project, suggesting it provides a dynamic alternative to traditional academic tools.

---

tinygrad (George Hotz) Discord

• Tinybox Delivery Timeline Under Scrutiny: A user raised concerns about the delivery timeline for a tinybox within the USA, specifically inquiring if it could arrive in 2-5 days.
  • George Hotz responded that users should e-mail support@tinygrad.org for logistical questions, highlighting the importance of crafting clear inquiries.
• FAQ Must Include Support Email: A suggestion was made to incorporate the support email into the website FAQ, which is currently missing.
  • George agreed to add it promptly, demonstrating attentiveness to community input.
• Geographic Concerns in Delivery Queries: George questioned the significance of delivery location limitations, mentioning specific areas like San Diego, Michigan, or Hawaii.
  • He emphasized the necessity for clear question formulation, directing users to channel #1068979651336216706 for assistance.
• User Agreement Clarity with Click-Through: George proposed the idea of a click-through agreement for users to acknowledge reading the questions document, potentially utilizing multiple-choice questions.
  • Another member pointed out that a click-through confirmation already exists, indicating existing measures for user acknowledgment.
• Community Culture Needs Improvement: George expressed frustration over the community's approach to questioning, noting it as a recurring challenge.
  • He called for a shift towards prioritizing clear communication and proper inquiry practices.

---

LLM Agents (Berkeley MOOC) Discord

• Enhancing Inference Timings with RAG: A member inquired about optimizing inference timings for SLM-based systems deploying RAG architecture with Llama Index, seeking community insights.
  • The request highlights an ongoing challenge; performance optimization remains a hot topic for developers focused on efficiency.
• AI Reading Group Kicks Off: The AI Reading Group from Women in AI & Robotics launches to discuss AI papers, starting with Aashka Trivedi from IBM discussing their collaboration with NASA.
  • Limited sign-ups for audience Q&A emphasize the group's interactive approach, fostering closer ties between researchers and the community.
• MARK YOUR CALENDARS: INDUS Paper Presentation: Join the AI Reading Group on October 17, 2024, at 12pm EST for a presentation on INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models for Scientific Applications led by Aashka Trivedi.
  • This session promises insights into notable advancements in language models applicable to scientific tasks, featuring key contributions from IBM and NASA.
• INDUS Paper Highlights Collaboration: The INDUS paper, co-authored by IBM Research AI, NASA, and others, showcases advances in language models for scientific applications.
  • This initiative seeks to enhance widespread understanding of current innovations while encouraging interdisciplinary knowledge sharing.

---

Alignment Lab AI Discord

• AI Reading Group Launches with Research Focus: The AI Reading Group from Women in AI & Robotics kicked off, fostering a platform for researchers to discuss AI papers followed by an engaging Q&A session.
  • This initiative enhances direct dialogue between researchers and the community, spotlighting the latest advancements in AI.
• INDUS Research Presentation Scheduled: Aashka Trivedi from IBM will present 'INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models for Scientific Applications' on October 17, 2024, focusing on its potential in scientific contexts.
  • Contributing authors hail from IBM Research, NASA, and Harvard-Smithsonian CfA, indicating a high level of expertise in the research presented.
• Reading Group Participation is Limited: Interested participants need to sign up quickly due to limited attendance, aimed at ensuring meaningful audience engagement.
  • This strategy supports richer interactions during the Q&A after each presentation.
• Highlighting Interdisciplinary AI Discussions: The group offers a venue to spotlight current research topics and encourage discussions that cross traditional disciplinary boundaries.
  • Interdisciplinary engagement ensures a deeper dive into the complexities surrounding the field of AI.

---

Gorilla LLM (Berkeley Function Calling) Discord

• Modify Code to Support Third-party Datasets: The current implementation of Gorilla LLM does not natively support third-party datasets, but a member suggested modifying the code to enable this functionality.
  • Adjustments would involve adding a model handler for parsing logic, altering the test file mapping, and choosing suitable checkers.
• Implementing Dataset Parsing Logic: For integrating a new dataset, one member explained the necessity to implement the parsing logic using decode_ast and decode_exec.
  • This adaptation requires a solid grasp of the pipeline's dataset processing to ensure everything remains compatible.

---

The LLM Finetuning (Hamel + Dan) Discord has no new messages. If this guild has been quiet for too long, let us know and we will remove it.

---

The MLOps @Chipro Discord has no new messages. If this guild has been quiet for too long, let us know and we will remove it.

---

The Mozilla AI Discord has no new messages. If this guild has been quiet for too long, let us know and we will remove it.

---

The DiscoResearch Discord has no new messages. If this guild has been quiet for too long, let us know and we will remove it.

---

The AI21 Labs (Jamba) Discord has no new messages. If this guild has been quiet for too long, let us know and we will remove it.

---

PART 2: Detailed by-Channel summaries and links

Unsloth AI (Daniel Han) ▷ #general (128 messages🔥🔥):

• Discussion on Morning Greetings
• Jupyter Notebook vs VS Code
• Qwen Model Performance Concerns
• Unsloth Webinar Key Takeaways
• Fine-tuning Challenges with AMD GPUs

• Morning greetings lead to casual chat: Members exchanged morning greetings, leading to a light-hearted discussion about the time differences in their locations.
  • One member humorously noted, 'if ur not in EST or PST ur missing out'.
• Debate over Jupyter Notebook vs VS Code: A member expressed dissatisfaction with the Jupyter Notebook interface, feeling like using an outdated application.
  • 'Even better' another countered, indicating they prefer VS Code for its notebook support and ease of use.
• Concerns about Qwen model reliability: Members discussed the performance of the Qwen models, with some noting they received unexpected results with familiar configurations.
  • One member expressed worry as the models appeared to be absent from the Unsloth model page, stirring confusion.
• Insights from the Unsloth Webinar: Key points from the Unsloth Webinar highlighted the importance of bit representation in training, with a shift to lower precision bits yielding speed improvements.
  • Other optimizations discussed included training on high-quality datasets and improvements in model architecture, pushing for deeper models.
• Challenges with Fine-tuning on AMD GPUs: A new member inquired about running Unsloth on Windows without CUDA support, leading to discussions about AMD's limitations in ML.
  • Members recommended using cloud solutions like Collab for training instead, as well as exploring HPIC and alternative frameworks for AMD GPUs.

---

Unsloth AI (Daniel Han) ▷ #off-topic (8 messages🔥):

• Gen Z Culture
• Sigma Mindset

• Divine Fit Request: A member humorously called for divine assistance with a project, stating, 'Almighty God please make it fit.'
  • Another member responded positively, stating, 'Looks good.'
• Humor Breaks the Ice: A humorous reaction followed a divine fit request, with a member expressing laughter saying, 'HAHA.'
  • This lighthearted comment sparked agreement from other members, emphasizing a relaxed tone in the chat.
• Shame in Clicking Gen Z: A member expressed their discomfort with the Gen Z label, stating, 'It shames me to click on gen z.'
  • Another member questioned this sentiment, proposing, 'Why?'
• Aspiring for the Sigma Mindset: A member shared a desire to embody the Sigma mindset, saying, 'Wish I was a sigma.'
  • In response, another highlighted their identification with the Sigma notion, confidently stating, 'We are Sigma...'

---

Unsloth AI (Daniel Han) ▷ #help (80 messages🔥🔥):

• Dataset Merging for Multiturn Creative Writing
• Fine-tuning Llama 3.1 on Google Colab
• Monitoring GPU Usage During Training
• ChatML Inference Issues
• Guardrails for Therapy Models

• Dataset Merging Concerns: A user inquired whether starting different samples with varying turn initiators (e.g., 'from:human' vs 'from:gpt') would be an issue for training with Unsloth.
  • Another member assured that having multiple dataset columns, including additional keys, should not be problematic.
• Challenges in Fine-tuning Llama 3.1: A member shared their unsuccessful attempts to fine-tune Llama 3.1 70B on Google Colab due to VRAM limitations, noting that 48GB is required.
  • They received recommendations to try Lambda Labs instead, as Google Colab cannot accommodate the model.
• Need for Stepped Execution in Training: A user requested advice on running training steps individually rather than all at once to monitor GPU usage better.
  • They were directed to tools like Wandb or TensorBoard for monitoring gradients and optimizer logs.
• Incorporating ChatML for Inference: A user faced challenges using a ChatML dataset for inference, as their model responded to its own prompts instead of user queries.
  • It was suggested that they may need to utilize a correct chat template for inference rather than directly using their conversation-based dataset.
• Implementing Guardrails for Therapy Models: A member discussed the necessity of applying guardrails to their therapy-oriented model to prevent it from responding to inappropriate queries.
  • They were advised to classify inputs and safeguard responses beforehand, with mentions of using tools like llama-guard or Gemma shield.

---

Unsloth AI (Daniel Han) ▷ #research (5 messages):

• Fira paper
• Nanoflow framework

• Fira paper on LLM training constraints: A member shared a link to Fira, which examines if full-rank training of LLMs can be achieved under low-rank constraints.
  • The paper is attached in the repository, but as of now, there is no code available.
• Nanoflow framework offers high-performance serving: Another link was provided to Nanoflow, described as a throughput-oriented high-performance serving framework for LLMs.
  • This framework aims to enhance the serving capabilities specifically targeted at large language models.

---

HuggingFace ▷ #general (182 messages🔥🔥):

• Model Access Issues
• Engagement with Hugging Face Platform
• AI Model Recommendations
• Launch Discussions
• Building AI Applications

• Users Encounter Model Access Issues: Several users reported problems accessing models like Llama, with some experiencing timeouts or inability to utilize specific models, highlighting the challenges in using Hugging Face's offerings.
  • One user noted they successfully ran Llama-3.2-1B on a GeForce 980Ti, suggesting it's feasible to leverage older hardware for deep learning applications.
• Discussion on Hugging Face Platform Capabilities: A user expressed the need for clearer understanding of Hugging Face's platform capabilities, similar to offerings like replicate.com, indicating the desire for more user-friendly access.
  • Others engaged in this discussion shared links and resources for learning about the platform, while advocating for exploring community-created projects and learning resources.
• Recommendations for AI Model Usage: Users discussed appropriate models for tasks such as email summarization, with suggestions for utilizing models that excel at summary tasks and adjusted for available computing resources.
  • Engagement highlighted the importance of understanding RAM requirements for running different model sizes and leveraging Hugging Face's offerings accordingly.
• User Interest in AI Tools and Releases: There was interest in newly launched AI tools, particularly for effective content generation and brand promotion, with one member promoting an AI project for writing viral tweets.
  • Additionally, a query was raised regarding the release of Hugging Chat for Android, with unclear responses regarding ongoing development in that direction.
• Community Project Updates and Feedback Requests: Several users introduced their AI-driven projects, inviting feedback and potential collaboration from the community to enhance user engagement and technology adoption.
  • These discussions underscored the collaborative spirit within the community as members look to share their innovations and seek constructive input.

---

HuggingFace ▷ #today-im-learning (6 messages):

• Switch to Kotlin
• Hugging Face API Login

• Richie's Kotlin Leap: A member announced making the switch to Kotlin, stating that most of their work involved Kotlin channels, prompting the transition.
  • They shared their journey from Kivy, Flet, and BeeWare to Dart and Flutter, now ultimately settling on Kotlin and Jetpack Compose.
• Clarification on Hugging Face API Login: A member clarified that to use the HfApiEngine class, it's necessary for users to have executed huggingface_hub.login(HF_TOKEN) with a valid HF token.
  • Another member mistakenly thought the token requirement was tied to model choice, but now realizes it applies to the HfApiEngine usage.

---

HuggingFace ▷ #cool-finds (4 messages):

• FLUX1.1 Pro
• Pika Labs Release
• Graph of Thoughts Paper

• FLUX1.1 Pro impresses with speed and performance: The new FLUX1.1 Pro delivers six times faster generation than its predecessor while enhancing image quality, prompt adherence, and diversity.
  • It achieves the highest overall Elo score in the Artificial Analysis image arena, surpassing all other models on the leaderboard.
• Excitement for the latest releases: Members noted the excitement over the releases of FLUX1.1 Pro and Pika Labs this week.
  • The community buzzed about these advancements, eagerly discussing their implications on AI capabilities.
• Discussing Graph of Thoughts Research: The paper titled Graph of Thoughts: Solving Elaborate Problems with Large Language Models was shared for review.
  • This research may provide interesting insights, especially considering its impact and context for discussions on large language models.

Link mentioned: black-forest-labs/flux-1.1-pro – Run with an API on Replicate: no description found

---

HuggingFace ▷ #i-made-this (13 messages🔥):

• gpt4free integration
• GIF QA bot
• Nvidia/Nemo - Mistral - Minitron 8B
• Llama 3.2 restrictions
• salamandra-2B on device

• gpt4free Finally integrated!: A member successfully integrated gpt4free into their chatbot, noting that it works albeit a bit slowly, and they had to frequently change providers.
  • Also mentioned: added two OpenAI models, o1-preview and o1-mini; for more details, check the Release v1.3.0 on GitHub.
• Building a GIF QA bot: A member inquired about recommended pre-trained models for creating a GIF QA bot with a dataset consisting of one question per GIF.
  • Another member suggested using the phi-3.5 vision model for this purpose.
• Introducing Nvidia/Nemo - Mistral - Minitron 8B!: A member shared their newly created Nvidia/Nemo - Mistral - Minitron 8B model for testing, urging others to test it due to their limited GPU quota.
  • They also humorously expressed their desire to monitor error logs during testing.
• Concerns About Llama 3.2 Restrictions: A member expressed frustration over the Llama 3.2 VL restrictions, calling it bizarre behavior from a large company given recent disclosures to the US government.
  • This sentiment reflects broader concerns about the implications of ongoing regulatory discussions in AI.
• Excited about Salamandra-2B on Device: A member shared their enthusiasm for salamandra-2B on device, highlighting its instruct features and positive vibes surrounding it.
  • They expressed eagerness for community feedback and potential presentations on their development process.

---

HuggingFace ▷ #reading-group (2 messages):

• AI Reading Group Launch
• Discussion on Hosting Sessions
• Research Presentation on INDUS
• Interdisciplinary Engagement

• AI Reading Group Launch Announced: The AI Reading Group from Women in AI & Robotics has been launched, providing researchers a platform to share their work.
  • The first session features a speaker from IBM presenting joint research with NASA, scheduled for October 17, 2024.
• Interest in Dual Streaming Sessions: A member expressed interest in hosting a session on Discord to increase visibility for the AI Reading Group events.
  • They suggested streaming to both Discord and Eventbrite simultaneously to attract a larger audience.
• Presentation on Scientific Language Models: The reading group's inaugural event will highlight the research paper titled INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models for Scientific Applications.
  • The paper is co-authored by researchers from IBM, NASA, and various academic institutions, indicating strong interdisciplinary collaboration.
• Engagement in AI Research Topics: The reading group aims to create a space for direct dialogue among researchers and the community about current research topics in AI.
  • The goal is to provide an engaging environment for discussions that demystify innovations and foster deeper engagement with emerging research.

Link mentioned: INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models: AI Reading Group session with one of the authors of "INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models for Scientific Applications".

---

HuggingFace ▷ #computer-vision (1 messages):

ohmahgawdronnie: okay I think I get the idea thanks!

---

HuggingFace ▷ #NLP (2 messages):

• Getting started with NLP
• Hugging Face courses
• The Illustrated Transformer
• Practical implementation with BERT

• Beginning your NLP journey: A new member expressed interest in learning NLP after completing a Python course and sought tips on where to begin.
  • They specifically mentioned their background as a Dialogflow CX developer.
• Hugging Face as a resource: A member recommended Hugging Face courses and noted that the cookbook is an excellent resource available on their platform.
  • They emphasized the importance of practical experience before delving deeper into theory.
• Essential NLP theory resources: Recommended resources included "The Illustrated Transformer," the YouTube channel 3blueonebrown, and the original paper, 'Attention is All You Need.'
  • Additionally, a member offered to share an article for beginners if requested.
• Practical experience with BERT: For hands-on learning, attempting to finetune a BERT style model for text classification was advised as a starting project.
  • This approach is encouraged to build foundational skills before advancing to theoretical concepts.

---

HuggingFace ▷ #diffusion-discussions (8 messages🔥):

• FLUX.1-dev card structure
• Transformer model formats
• Discussion on adding Transformers section
• NLP community engagement

• Understanding FLUX.1-dev card file structure: A user inquired about the relationship of the flux1-dev.safetensors file to the other pipeline folders, questioning if it stores all models monolithically.
  • Another member clarified that the file contains only the transformer model and mentioned the need for both autoencoder and T5 for full functionality.
• Call for Transformers discussion section: A suggestion was made to create a separate discussion page for transformers, similar to the existing diffusers channel.
  • The community noted a lack of appropriate channels for LLMs and related topics, which the member felt was necessary for increased engagement.
• Transformer format confusion: Users expressed confusion regarding layer name discrepancies between flux1-dev.safetensors and diffusion_pytorch_model files.
  • It was noted that the issue arose because the root repo contains the original BFL format whereas the transformer directory uses the diffusers format, causing the name alignment issues.
• Original BFL format accessibility: A user asked about the availability of the original BFL format model, noting difficulty in finding documentation or direct access.
  • This inquiry highlights the ongoing need for clearer access to foundational resources within the community.

---

aider (Paul Gauthier) ▷ #general (156 messages🔥🔥):

• Aider telemetry data
• Cursor vs Aider
• Claude Development
• Model performance and features
• Real-time audio API

• Discussion on Aider's telemetry data collection: It was noted that Aider currently does not collect telemetry data, which some users believe hinders understanding usage patterns and success rates.
  • Suggestions for future telemetry included tracking model choice, tokens, and user prompts in a privacy-sensitive manner, without capturing identifiable information.
• Comparisons between Cursor and Aider: Users shared their experiences with Cursor and Aider, stating Cursor has a smoother interface while Aider remains a powerful command-line tool.
  • Several expressed dissatisfaction with Cursor's inconsistencies, particularly with its Composer feature, while noting the efficiency of Aider when used in terminal environments.
• Interest in Claude Development: Many users are considering trying Claude Development, citing its potential benefits for coding tasks and assistance.
  • Discussion included the anticipation of updates for Claude and how it may enhance productivity compared to existing tools.
• Introduction of real-time audio API: The release of the GPT-4o Realtime API for audio interactions was announced, designed for low-latency conversational applications.
  • This API supports use cases like customer support and live translation but requires client integrations to handle end-user audio streams.
• Issues with Aider responding in Chinese characters: A user reported receiving Chinese characters in Aider when using the o1-mini model, indicating a potential issue.
  • This sparked a discussion about troubleshooting and the general challenges faced with AI models in producing expected outputs.

---

aider (Paul Gauthier) ▷ #questions-and-tips (22 messages🔥):

• Refactor-Benchmark Usage
• Aider with Multiple Repositories
• CONVENTIONS.md File Naming
• Examples of Coding Conventions
• Aider Auto Complete Issues

• Refactor-Benchmark Usage Clarity: A member inquired about running the refactor-benchmark for a full report on tasks and comparisons.
  • There was confusion about whether tasks for the Code refactoring leaderboard need to be executed separately from the editing benchmark.
• Aider and Multiple Git Repositories: A question was raised about whether Aider can work with multiple git repositories simultaneously to write compatible client code.
  • One member pointed out that while it's not currently possible, workarounds are available on the Aider FAQ.
• CONVENTIONS.md File Naming: A user asked if the naming of CONVENTIONS.md is mandatory or if any other name could replace it.
  • It was clarified that the filename is merely a convention but is commonly used in GitHub projects.
• Examples of Coding Conventions: An inquiry was made about the availability of examples for CONVENTION.md beyond those found on the Aider website.
  • A member directed them to the awesome-guidelines repository for a curated list of coding style conventions.
• Aider Auto Complete Concerns: A user shared that the auto complete functionality for the /read-only command isn't working in the cloned Aider main branch.
  • The developer mentioned it functions differently from the /add command and encouraged trying the latest version with aider --install-main-branch.

---

aider (Paul Gauthier) ▷ #links (13 messages🔥):

• Crawl4AI
• Not Diamond Router
• Open Hands Resolver
• OpenAI DevDay
• Canvas for ChatGPT

• Crawl4AI Launch: The GitHub repository for Crawl4AI presents an open-source, LLM-friendly web crawler and scrapper, aimed at developers looking for customizable solutions.
  • This tool can enhance data collection capabilities for various projects, offering integration with language models.
• Not Diamond Model Router Unveiled: The new Not Diamond model router claims to efficiently connect various models with high precision for tailored tasks like planning trips or analyzing technical reports.
  • Users can train their own optimized routers in less than five minutes, making it accessible for a diverse range of applications.
• Open Hands Resolver System: The OpenHands resolver project aims to automatically resolve issues in GitHub repositories using the OpenHands framework.
  • This initiative could significantly streamline project maintenance processes by automating troubleshooting efforts.
• Insights from OpenAI DevDay: Live blogging the OpenAI DevDay yielded shared notes and reflections on new features, including prompt caching and model audio streaming.
  • Key discussions highlighted the importance of building developer tools over creating overly complex models, with the community expressing a desire for real-world applications.
• Concerns Over '.io' Domains: Discussions around the potential removal of the '.io' domain surfaced after the UK's announcement to return the Chagos Islands to Mauritius, raising questions about the future of ccTLDs.
  • As an owner of datasette.io, concerns arose about the implications for users relying on this domain type, emphasizing the need for clarity in policy changes.

---

OpenRouter (Alex Atallah) ▷ #announcements (1 messages):

alexatallah: https://x.com/SambaNovaAI/status/1841901026821210131

---

OpenRouter (Alex Atallah) ▷ #general (112 messages🔥🔥):

• DeepInfra Outage
• GPT-4o Price Drop
• Claude 2.1 Moderation Issues
• NVLM 1.0 Release
• Flash 8B Model Pricing and Speed

• DeepInfra experiences a brief outage: DeepInfra experienced an outage for about 15 minutes but is reportedly recovering.
• GPT-4o sees a significant price reduction: The GPT-4o model is now 50% cheaper for input and around 33% cheaper for output, effective today.
  • This change relates to the updated model, GPT-4o-2024-08-06, which has been available since August.
• Claude 2.1 raises concerns over moderation: Users reported that Claude 2.1 and other models are erroneously flagging SFW prompts, impacting user interactions.
  • One specific example involved a character description that was flagged for 'sexual' content, raising questions about moderation standards.
• NVIDIA releases NVLM 1.0 model: NVIDIA announced the NVLM 1.0 model, which is competitive with leading proprietary models and offers open-sourced weights and code.
  • This release is expected to enhance accuracy for both vision-language tasks and text-only capabilities.
• Flash 8B model enters production: The Flash 8B model is now in production but reportedly offers 200 tokens per second, which is considered slower compared to normal Flash.
  • Discussions suggest potential future speed upgrades and considerations for lower hardware utilization.

---

Modular (Mojo 🔥) ▷ #mojo (101 messages🔥🔥):

• Mojo Python Imports
• Mojo Functions and Behaviors
• Error Handling Strategies
• Static Data Storage in Mojo
• SIMD Initialization Issues

• Mojo struggles with Python imports: Discussions revealed that Mojo cannot natively handle Python's dynamic import behavior, which complicates integration and error management.
  • Several members noted that delegating import responsibilities to CPython might introduce security risks similar to those seen in the NPM ecosystem.
• Mojo functions encounter returned value issues: Members discovered that returning values from functions in Mojo sometimes requires a variable declaration (e.g., using var), as constants can create runtime errors.
  • An example was shared where SIMD initialization failed unless modified to return a mutable object.
• Exploring error handling strategies: Conversations focused on potential improvements to Mojo's error handling, with suggestions leaning towards Zig-style error unions for inferred error types.
  • Some members advocated for integrating a more functional programming (FP) approach to error management, emphasizing pattern matching and composability.
• Static data storage complexities: Users sought ways to statically store tables in Mojo without incurring excessive code bloat from constructs like List, which leads to undesirable binary sizes.
  • An emphasis was placed on matching the performance and memory efficiency seen in C static declarations.
• SIMD initialization issues lead to GitHub discussions: A request was made to create a GitHub issue regarding the unexpected behavior of the SIMD.__init__ constructor, which returned errors under certain conditions.
  • Members expressed willingness to assist with tracking down the root cause of SIMD related bugs.

Link mentioned: mojo-openai-realtime-api/tests/test_event_handlers.mojo at ed0e04e2de493428729a98594e3d974480d03798 · msaelices/mojo-openai-realtime-api: Mojo OpenAI Realtime API client. Contribute to msaelices/mojo-openai-realtime-api development by creating an account on GitHub.

---

OpenAI ▷ #annnouncements (1 messages):

• Canvas feature
• ChatGPT enhancements
• GPT-4o

• Canvas Feature Launches for Writing & Coding: OpenAI announced an early version of the canvas feature, allowing users to work on writing and coding projects that extend beyond simple chat interactions. Starting today, Plus & Team users can try it by selecting “GPT-4o with canvas” in the model picker.
• Enhancing Project Workflows with GPT-4o: The introduction of GPT-4o with canvas is a step towards improving the user experience in project management and collaboration. This feature enables users to leverage advanced AI capabilities while working on complex tasks.

---

OpenAI ▷ #ai-discussions (77 messages🔥🔥):

• API Access and Rate Limits
• OpenAI's Copilot App
• Fine-Tuning Models
• Canvas Feature
• Creating a Fake Language

• API Access tier confusion: Discussion emerged regarding API access being rolled out to specific usage tiers, with one user experiencing a 403 error despite previous access.
  • Another member pointed out the importance of approaching rate limit issues and handling errors effectively when reaching excessive request volumes.
• Impressions of the new Copilot App: A user expressed surprise at the smooth performance of the new Copilot App, noting that it is a native app on Android.
  • Another member appreciated its features but lamented the inability to delete chats, drawing a comparison to another chatbot.
• Locating Fine-Tuned Model IDs: A query about finding specific IDs for fine-tuned models was addressed, with a member sharing a link to the dashboard for retrieval.
  • The solution provided was confirmed successful, showcasing the community's support in navigating OpenAI tools.
• Discussion on the Canvas Feature: Users discussed the new Canvas feature, with some expressing excitement while others noted its limited access depending on desktop or mobile platforms.
  • Clarifications were shared regarding its current rollout and availability, mentioning that mobile users can still view canvas conversations.
• Creating and Utilizing a Fake Language: One member shared their creative endeavor, successfully generating a fake language and a spreadsheet to aid in its use.
  • This prompted a discussion about AI's role in language creation and messaging experience.

---

OpenAI ▷ #gpt-4-discussions (4 messages):

• Voice Feature in Custom GPTs
• Google API Integration with Custom GPTs

• Voice Feature Now Available in Custom GPTs: A member expressed gratitude for the introduction of the voice feature in custom GPTs available in the GPT store today, thanking the OpenAI team for resolving this issue.
  • However, they noted that the voice mode is not the new advanced voice, which they hope will be included for all custom GPTs in the future.
• Struggles with Google API in Custom GPTs: Another member shared their past attempts to integrate the Google API / OAuth with custom GPTs, stating it was finicky during the initial release.
  • They haven't checked back to see if the integration is more stable now, indicating ongoing interest in the functionality.

---

OpenAI ▷ #prompt-engineering (7 messages):

• Seed Number Retrieval in Midjourney
• Ninetails Training Data Issue
• Small vs Large Models Performance
• Understanding AI Hallucinations
• Training Data Errors vs Hallucinations

• Retrieving Seed Numbers in Midjourney: A user inquired about how to obtain the seed number from a picture created in the web version of Midjourney.
  • Another member redirected them to a previous channel for further guidance on this topic.
• Ninetails Training Data Flaw in 4o-mini: A user identified that 4o-mini consistently misidentifies Ninetails as having 6 tails when asked about fire-type Pokémon, despite 4o providing the correct answer.
  • This pattern occurred across three regenerations, suggesting a possible flaw in the training data rather than a typical hallucination.
• Performance Discrepancy Between Small and Large Models: The issue with Ninetails seems to affect smaller models like gpt-3.5-turbo and gpt-4o-mini, while larger models provide accurate responses.
  • There's speculation that the training data prioritized incorrect information during the training of the small models.
• Clarifying AI Hallucinations: A member emphasized that hallucinations are generally unpredictable and involve the model generating erratic or creative responses.
  • In contrast, consistent incorrect answers are more indicative of training data errors, as they follow established patterns.
• Errors in Training Data vs Hallucinations: The distinction between training data errors and hallucinations was further elaborated, highlighting that consistent answers indicate training issues.
  • A user noted that predictable patterns of incorrect responses differ fundamentally from the random guesses typical of hallucinations.

---

OpenAI ▷ #api-discussions (7 messages):

• Midjourney Seed Retrieval
• 4o-mini Training Issues
• LLM Answer Consistency

• How to get seed number on Midjourney: A user asked how to obtain the seed number of an image created in Midjourney via the web, but the answer was redirected to another channel for assistance.
• Specific training issue with 4o-mini: A member noted that 4o-mini consistently identifies Ninetails as having 6 tails, whereas larger models correctly identify Vulpix instead, indicating a potential training flaw.
  • This repetitive error contradicts what should be expected and suggests that the model's training might have prioritized incorrect information over the correct one.
• Small vs Large Model Discrepancy: Another member observed that only the smaller models (like gpt-4o-mini and gpt-3.5-turbo) demonstrate this flawed behavior, unlike larger models that provide accurate answers.
  • This raises questions about the training data and model architecture as to why this problem persists only in smaller variants.
• Clarifying AI Hallucinations vs Training Errors: The discussion highlighted the difference between hallucinations and consistent training errors, emphasizing that hallucinations typically involve unpredictable outputs.
  • In contrast, consistent wrong answers suggest a flawed understanding or specific training data errors rather than random guesses by the model.

---

Stability.ai (Stable Diffusion) ▷ #general-chat (94 messages🔥🔥):

• Using Virtual Environments for Stability
• Generating Images with AI Models
• Partnership & Marketing Queries in the Channel
• Image Generation Challenges
• Model Training and ControlNet

• Virtual Environments Are Key for Compatibility: Members recommended using virtual environments like venv or conda to avoid conflicts between different Python versions when running tools like AUTOMATIC1111.
  • Virtual environments allow for separate package management, making it easier to work with different setups without disrupting existing workflows.
• Choosing the Right AI Model and UI: New users were advised to utilize Comfy UI due to its flexibility and access to new features, although Automatic1111 remains popular for tutorials.
  • Members highlighted that Forge UI is a faster fork of Automatic1111, but Comfy UI may provide more versatility due to its node-based design.
• Generating Images in Specific Poses: Users discussed challenges with getting AI to generate images in specific poses and suggested using ControlNet for precise control over output.
  • It was emphasized that training specific models (like LoRA) and adjusting weights can help tailor the generated images to better meet user expectations.
• Navigating AI Model Limitations: The conversation touched on the challenges of running advanced models like SDXL on older GPUs, with some members suggesting alternatives like ZLUDA for AMD users.
  • Discussants acknowledged that while using lower resolutions can speed up processing, it may not yield optimal results compared to higher resolutions suited for specific models.
• Experimenting with AI Model Training: A user shared their experience of attempting to train AI models and faced complications, leading to a ban due to inappropriate image training.
  • This highlights the importance of careful selection of training images and adherence to community standards when working with AI image generation.

---

Nous Research AI ▷ #general (63 messages🔥🔥):

• Nous Research Bittensor subnet
• Grok usage
• FLUX1.1 Pro release
• LLaMA-3.1-SuperNova merge
• AI assistants impact on society

• Nous Research Bittensor subnet closure: A member inquired why Nous Research stopped its Bittensor subnet, questioning if competition and time demands played a role.
  • Another member responded directly, offering to continue the conversation through private messages.
• Grok usage requires verification: Discussion around the need for verification and payment to access Grok, with mixed opinions on the necessity of these steps.
  • It was clarified that some users don’t need to verify, but they would need to pay for access to the service.
• Launch of FLUX1.1 Pro: The release of FLUX1.1 Pro was announced, claiming six times faster generation than its predecessor while enhancing image quality and prompt adherence.
  • The announcement emphasized efficiency improvements, marking a significant step for its generative technology.
• Insights from LLaMA-3.1-SuperNova merge: Details were shared regarding the merging process of LLaMA-3.1-SuperNova-Lite and its base model with a focus on density as a critical parameter in the merge.
  • Benchmark results were discussed to highlight the effectiveness of this merge compared to previous iterations.
• AI assistants making society lazier: Concerns were raised about AI assistants contributing to a decline in practical coding skills, particularly among students relying on tools like ChatGPT.
  • Members noted a societal trend toward valuing degrees over genuine learning, resulting in a lack of engagement in educational settings.

---

Nous Research AI ▷ #ask-about-llms (17 messages🔥):

• LLM for Story Creation
• LLM Functions Efficiency
• LanceDB Performance
• Nous-Hermes-Llama2-13b Evaluation
• Embedding Models

• Searching for Uncensored Story-Creating LLMs: A user inquired about the best LLM for creating stories that is both uncensored and can be run as an API.
  • They also sought sites that build stories using LLMs automatically without just providing standard help.
• Individual vs Multiple API Requests for LLM Functions: A user asked if there are metrics to determine whether to use LLM Functions individually or combine them in a single API request for optimal results.
  • Comments suggested that using individual tasks often improves reasoning, citing a relevant paper.
• LanceDB's Fast Performance and Hybrid Alternatives: A member highlighted their experience with LanceDB, mentioning its speed and cloud integration capabilities.
  • They recommended DuckDB for hybrid databases and noted Elasticsearch on AWS as a performant but challenging option.
• Evaluation Methodology for Nous-Hermes-Llama2-13b on ARC: A user sought clarification on the evaluation method for Nous-Hermes-Llama2-13b on the ARC dataset, asking about zero-shot or few-shot evaluations.
  • It was confirmed that the ARC is evaluated using zero-shot prompting.
• Inquiry About Cost-Effective Embedding Models: Another user asked for recommendations on the cheapest and best embedding models for both operating science and computer science.
  • The conversation highlighted interest in economical yet effective solutions in embedding technology.

---

Nous Research AI ▷ #research-papers (2 messages):

• Softmax Function Limitations
• Knowledge Graph Embedding with Group Theory

• Softmax Function Fails Sharp Decision Making: The paper discusses the softmax function and its inability to consistently perform robust computations as the number of inputs increases, fundamentally limiting its approximation of sharp functions.
  • Even simple tasks like finding the maximum key show that learned circuitry disperses as input size grows, challenging the belief in softmax's predictive power.
• Unified Perspective on Knowledge Graph Embedding: A novel approach to knowledge graph embedding (KGE) is proposed, integrating uncertainty through the lens of group theory while maintaining computation efficiency and expressiveness.
  • Entities and relations are embedded as permutations in a symmetric group, allowing existing models to be represented effectively within this framework.

---

Nous Research AI ▷ #interesting-links (2 messages):

• FLUX1.1 Pro
• Image Generation Models
• Black Forest Labs

• FLUX1.1 Pro Surpasses Its Predecessor: The release of FLUX1.1 Pro boasts six times faster generation than FLUX.1 Pro with enhanced image quality and prompt adherence, as highlighted in the release announcement.
  • Users can now benefit from improved performance and efficiency, making it an optimal choice for streamlined workflows.
• FLUX1.1 Pro Dominates Image Generation Benchmarks: Introduced under the codename 'blueberry', FLUX1.1 Pro achieved the highest overall Elo score in the popular Artificial Analysis image arena.
  • This new model showcases its superiority by surpassing all other models currently on the leaderboard.
• Hybrid Architecture in Action: All public FLUX.1 models utilize a hybrid architecture based on multimodal principles, enhancing their capability in image generation.
  • This innovative approach helps improve both the quality and performance of the models.

Link mentioned: black-forest-labs/flux-1.1-pro – Run with an API on Replicate: no description found

---

Nous Research AI ▷ #research-papers (2 messages):

• Softmax function limitations
• Knowledge graph embedding with uncertainty

• Softmax Function's Inherent Limitations: The paper reveals a fundamental limitation of the softmax function in approximating sharp functions, asserting that even for simple tasks, any learned circuitry needs to disperse with an increasing number of items during testing.
  • The authors prove this phenomenon theoretically and suggest using adaptive temperature as a potential solution.
• Unified Perspective on Knowledge Graph Embedding: This paper introduces a new approach to knowledge graph embedding (KGE) by incorporating uncertainty from group theory, proposing a model that is general, efficient, and expressive.
  • It highlights that embedding entities and relations can be viewed as elements of a symmetric group, providing a way to reflect different properties and confirming that existing models can also be framed within this framework.

---

Nous Research AI ▷ #reasoning-tasks (3 messages):

• Model Thought Process Controls
• Trade Secrets Protection
• User Transparency Issues

• Controls to Conceal Model's Thought Process: A member expressed that certain controls are in place to prevent leaking the model's chain of thought, including instructing it to believe it doesn't possess thoughts.
  • This raises concerns about whether this approach could compromise the model's ability to explain itself effectively.
• Concerns over Trade Secrets vs User Understanding: Another member questioned the desirability of these controls, stating that while OAI seeks to protect its trade secrets, it feels wrong to ask the model to obscure its thought processes from users.
  • This sentiment highlights a tension between transparency and security in AI model interactions.

---

Perplexity AI ▷ #general (74 messages🔥🔥):

• Audio Reading Feature Discussions
• Subscription Issues and Customer Support
• Performance and Model Quality Concerns
• Using Extensions and API Credits
• User Interface and Experience Feedback

• Audio Reading Feature Gets Mixed Reviews: Users discussed the potential for an audio reading feature, with some finding it easier to listen to long replies instead of reading them, despite issues with pronunciation.
  • One member shared that they frequently use the feature while working, implying that it adds value to their experience.
• Frustrations with Subscription and Customer Support: Several users expressed dissatisfaction with subscription problems, including issues with downloading files and not receiving responses from support regarding a security concern.
  • One user expressed considering canceling their subscription due to perceived lack of attention to these issues.
• Inconsistency in Model Output Quality: A user noted that the output quality of models remained inconsistent, feeling that it became 'stupid' under the Collection or Pro package.
  • Another member highlighted extreme performance instability, making the product seemingly unusable at times.
• Chat Extensions and API Credit Confusions: Users discussed the installation of a Chrome extension that allows choosing the Gemini Pro model, questioning its availability in the Pro package.
  • Concerns arose about unexpected charges for API credits, with recommendations made to contact support to resolve these issues swiftly.
• User Interface Variability Discussion: Concerns were raised regarding differences in user interfaces across platforms, with some users unable to access features typically available to others.
  • Suggestions were made to check zoom settings or reload the interface to troubleshoot these discrepancies.

---

Perplexity AI ▷ #sharing (9 messages🔥):

• AI's impact on future movies
• Perplexity vs GPT-4
• Evidence of negative time
• OpenAI's funding
• Microsoft's strategic move

• AI's impact on future movies explored: An article discusses the potential impact of AI on future films, detailing how technology could change storytelling and production processes. You can read more about it here.
  • The discussion emphasizes emerging trends in filmmaking and how AI could redefine audience engagement.
• Perplexity vs GPT-4 comparison heated: A link shared reveals a comparison of Perplexity and GPT-4 highlighting their differing capabilities and performance metrics. Check it out here.
  • The debate sparked interesting community opinions on which platform holds an edge in practical applications.
• New findings on negative time surfaced: A recent article elaborates on the fascinating concept of negative time, presenting evidence and implications for physics. You can find the details here.
  • The discussion includes various theories challenging our understanding of time itself.
• OpenAI secures significant funding: An announcement revealed that OpenAI successfully raised $6.6 billion, boosting its ongoing projects and innovations. Details can be found here.
  • This funding is expected to fuel their advancements in AI research and applications.
• Microsoft's strategic maneuver discussed: A member shared insights on a new strategic move by Microsoft, underscoring its implications in the tech realm. Read more about this maneuver here.
  • The conversation highlighted how this move could influence competition in the AI landscape.

Link mentioned: YouTube: no description found

---

Perplexity AI ▷ #pplx-api (1 messages):

ok.alex: Hey <@744572846721859615>! Could you please dm me your account details.

---

Cohere ▷ #discussions (35 messages🔥):

• OpenAI Bubble
• Cohere's Position in AI
• AGI Concerns
• Data Privacy in AI
• Silicon Valley Culture

• OpenAI Bubble on the Brink: Several members discussed feelings that the OpenAI bubble is expanding and may soon burst, especially following the release of o1 which temporarily alleviated concerns.
  • One member ominously warned about the destiny of OpenAI being likened to WeWork's troubled past, raising questions about its long-term viability.
• Cohere's Low-Profile Strategy: A member expressed admiration for Cohere's approach, stating it 'works on everything while remaining aside' and appears more grounded compared to competitors.
  • This viewpoint suggests a belief that maintaining a lower profile could be advantageous in the evolving AI landscape.
• Shifting AGI Concepts: Questions arose over the evolving concept of AGI, with a belief that it will undergo significant changes over the next two decades.
  • This perspective shocked some, leading to discussions about the implications of such shifts for the AI landscape.
• Concerns Over Data Privacy: Amid concerns about data privacy, a member claimed that the agenda of some AI companies, including OpenAI, revolves around stealing data from mid-sized companies.
  • Other members replied by questioning the foundation of these claims, emphasizing the existing options for companies to opt-out of data sharing.
• Silicon Valley's Data Culture: The pervasive attitude in Silicon Valley was highlighted, with a member stating that 'everyone in AI is stealing' data, and it’s often easier to ask for forgiveness than permission.
  • This sentiment reflects a broader commentary on current legal uncertainties surrounding data usage in the tech industry.

---

Cohere ▷ #questions (8 messages🔥):

• Reranking API Rate Limit
• RAG++ Course Resource
• Cohere LLM Data Collection
• Cohere's Location Clarification
• Output Tokens Information

• Reranking API hitting rate limit: A user reported encountering a rate limit issue while testing the reranking API despite making only a few calls with 50 records each.
  • This indicates potential underlying constraints in the free tier usage during testing phases.
• RAG++ Course shared: A member shared a link to the RAG++ course focusing on systematic evaluation techniques and best practices to enhance accuracy in POC apps.
  • The course includes Cohere credits to run its notebooks, promoting accessibility to hands-on learning.
• Request for LLM data assistance: A user requested help verifying data regarding various LLMs for a school project, asking for input on specific details like release dates and capabilities.
  • Another member promptly corrected the location of Cohere, stating it is in Canada rather than the USA as initially noted.
• Cohere's Website as a Resource: A member directed others to Cohere's about page for comprehensive information regarding their language AI technologies.
  • The page emphasizes Cohere's commitment to integrating cutting-edge research with product development in AI.
• Inquiry on Output Tokens per Second: A user sought information regarding the Output Tokens per Second metric for Cohere's LLM, indicating a gap in available data.
  • They later expressed satisfaction after successfully locating the needed information.

---

Cohere ▷ #api-discussions (2 messages):

• Reranking API Rate Limit
• Forcibly Invoking Tools

• Rate Limit Frustrations with Reranking API: A user reported experiencing a rate limit issue while testing the reranking API, despite making only a few calls with batches of 50 records each.
  • This raises concerns about how the free tier manages usage caps, potentially affecting testing outcomes.
• Inquiry on Forcible Tool Invocation: Another user inquired about the possibility of forcibly invoking the tool, indicating a potential need for more control in interactions.
  • This suggests that members are looking for ways to bypass limitations or influence tool behavior.

---

Cohere ▷ #projects (24 messages🔥):

• Project Posting Guidelines
• Auto-Moderation Implementation
• Job Posting Concerns
• Crypto Ad Quality
• User Protection Measures

• Clarifying Project Posting Rules: Members emphasized the need for clear guidelines against offering services when showcasing Cohere-related projects in the channel.
  • Job postings disguised as projects are seen as problematic, leading to potential removal from the channel.
• Implementation of Auto-Moderation: A member confirmed that Auto-Mod is now set up to help manage unwanted content in the project channel.
  • This measure aims to tackle issues like job advertisements or spammy posts that undermine the community's focus.
• Job Posting Prohibition Stressed: MrDragonFox and others firmly oppose job postings in the channel, stating, 'no job posting - not even an argument about it.'
  • The community is concerned about recruitment spam, suggesting that it's easier to ban job postings entirely than to manage them.
• Concerns Over Crypto and Spam Quality: Discussions highlighted the quality issues with crypto and job adverts, prompting the belief that they're better managed elsewhere.
  • Members noted difficulty in distinguishing between legitimate content and phishing/crypto spam, advocating for user protection.
• Appreciation for Hustlers, but Not Here: While members respect the hustle of those seeking opportunities, they feel such activities should not take place within the channel.
  • The consensus is clear: appreciate the effort, just keep it out of the project showcase.

---

Interconnects (Nathan Lambert) ▷ #news (45 messages🔥):

• OpenAI's Canvas Interface
• Sam Altman's Influence
• OpenAI's Financial Outlook
• Liquid AI Architecture
• AI in Research Mathematics

• OpenAI introduces Canvas for enhanced collaboration: OpenAI launched a new interface called Canvas, enabling users to interact more effectively with ChatGPT for writing and coding projects by providing in-line feedback and targeted editing options.
  • However, some users noted limitations, such as lack of rendered frontend code and no ability to track code evolution effectively.
• Sam Altman's consolidation of power at OpenAI: An article explored how Sam Altman has concentrated his influence at OpenAI, particularly during its rise to a $157 billion valuation.
  • The piece prompts readers to reflect on the company's rapid growth while assessing the implications of strong leadership.
• OpenAI's ambitious revenue projections by 2026: OpenAI aims to generate as much revenue as established companies like McDonald's and Mastercard by 2026, contingent on successfully enhancing features to attract a wider user base.
  • Discussion centered around whether OpenAI can achieve profitability similar to these giants, given the revenue structure heavily reliant on ChatGPT.
• Concerns about Liquid AI architecture: Several members raised concerns about the viability and clarity of the new Liquid AI architecture, describing it as a minor but notable change.
  • Some speculate that if they possess a superior architecture, they should prioritise rapid scaling to compete effectively.
• AI's capabilities in research-level mathematics: A highlighted conversation focused on whether AI can engage in research-level mathematics, potentially creating conjectures and proving theorems.
  • Discussion acknowledged a shifting frontier of capabilities for LLMs, reflecting growing optimism about AI's role in advanced mathematical research.

---

Interconnects (Nathan Lambert) ▷ #ml-drama (3 messages):

• c.ai PR issues
• Community reactions

• Potential PR Disaster Looms for c.ai: A member warned that c.ai will face a PR disaster, indicating serious issues ahead.
  • This sparked a reaction from another member who expressed a sentiment of being 'sad' at this development.
• Community Shares Disappointment: The ongoing discussion conveyed a sense of disappointment regarding the situation with c.ai.
  • 'Yeah... not surprised, just sad' captures the community's frustrated but resigned perspective.

---

Interconnects (Nathan Lambert) ▷ #random (14 messages🔥):

• Shadeform marketplace
• O1 Preview
• Model analysis and UX
• Blog post ideas

• Exploring Shadeform's GPU Marketplace: A member discussed the benefits of using Shadeform for reserving on-demand GPUs and leveraging its marketplace for scheduling functions.
  • Shadeform offers centralized billing and management across multi-cloud environments, making it convenient for deploying workloads.
• O1 Preview Shares its Thought Process: A Reddit post highlights an incident where O1 Preview accidentally disclosed its entire thought process in a response, prompting interesting discussions in the chat.
  • One member suggested this could be a great topic for a blog post, humorously touching on the implications of such transparency.
• Diving Deep into O1's Model Structure: Members expressed interest in analyzing O1’s structure, noting that it clearly delineates sections with headings that pause user engagement.
  • Discussion mentioned how certain sections might align with user search habits and predictions about the model's functionality.
• Comparing O1's Presentation to Its Blog: A member noted that the UX of the O1 Preview is reminiscent of the original blog post, indicating a strong similarity.
  • They considered analyzing these aspects further, though ultimately decided they had more engaging topics to focus on.

---

Interconnects (Nathan Lambert) ▷ #reads (5 messages):

• Llama team
• Google's AI publications
• Meta's publication style

• Questioning the Llama Team's Authenticity: A member expressed suspicion about the Llama team, questioning if they were genuinely associated with it.
  • This raised concerns regarding the authenticity of their contributions in the context of recent discussions.
• Google's Complicated AI Use: In response to the skepticism, a member noted that Google has mentioned similar topics but likely employs a more complicated version.
  • This hints at the complexities involved in the AI landscape and the differing approaches by different organizations.
• Curiosity About Publication Timeliness: Another member suggested that the information being discussed might be old, indicating a need to verify its relevance.
  • This concern highlights the fast-paced nature of AI advancements and the importance of staying updated.
• Meta's Similar Publication Vibes: A member noted that Meta likely has a publication vibe that shares similarities with the current discussion.
  • This observation draws attention to the evolving styles and strategies used by major players in the AI field.

---

Latent Space ▷ #ai-general-chat (62 messages🔥🔥):

• OpenAI Canvas Launch
• StackBlitz Bolt
• Gartner's AI Engineering Recognition
• Google's Gemini AI
• Reflection 70B Model Reproduction

• OpenAI introduces ChatGPT Canvas: OpenAI has launched a new interface called Canvas, enabling more collaborative projects within ChatGPT, allowing users to edit code and get in-line feedback.
  • Features include direct editing capabilities, shortcuts for various tasks, and enhanced research functionalities.
• StackBlitz unveils Bolt for AI development: StackBlitz introduced Bolt, a platform allowing users to prompt, edit, run, and deploy fullstack applications with AI assistance.
  • The development environment supports npm, Vite, and Next.js, offering developers a comprehensive and free tool for creating apps.
• Gartner acknowledges AI engineering as a field: Writer has been recognized by Gartner as an Emerging Leader for Generative AI Technologies, indicating the growing importance of AI in enterprise solutions.
  • The recognition spans sources such as Generative AI Engineering and AI Knowledge Management Apps, highlighting innovations in this space.
• Google's Gemini AI development: Google is reportedly working on a reasoning AI model, positioning itself in competition with OpenAI's capabilities, especially in the 'o1' arena.
  • This initiative follows their history of developing advanced AI systems like AlphaGo and seeks to build upon human-like reasoning abilities.
• Reflection 70B Model benchmarks discussed: Sahil Chaudhary shared a post-mortem on the Reflection 70B model, addressing concerns regarding benchmark reproducibility and output quality.
  • Community members continue to engage in discussions regarding the potential evaluation inconsistencies and the model's overall contributions to AI.

---

Latent Space ▷ #ai-announcements (1 messages):

• DevDay Recap
• OpenAI insights
• Audio experience

• DevDay Recap Podcast Released: The latest episode from Latent Space Pod provides a comprehensive audio experience from DevDay, featuring key contributors.
  • Key figures include @oliviergodement, @romainhuet, @michpokrass, @AlistairPullen, and @simonw as guest co-host, along with a full @Sama and @kevinweil Q&A.
• Thanks for the Organizers: A shoutout to <@194927177265840128> for arranging many of the segments at DevDay.
  • Their efforts helped bring together a host of valuable discussions and insights from the event.

Link mentioned: Tweet from Latent.Space (@latentspacepod): 🆕 Building AGI in Real Time https://latent.space/p/devday-2024 Our @OpenAI DevDay Recap is now live! A comprehensive audio experience of DevDay, with the people who made it happen: - @oliviergode...

---

LM Studio ▷ #general (41 messages🔥):

• LM Studio Layout
• Langflow Integration
• LM Studio Update Impact
• Context Management in LM Studio
• Flash Attention Feature

• Confusion over LM Studio setup: Several users engaged in a debate about connecting LM Studio with Langflow, with one asking about changing the OpenAI component's base URL.
  • The conversation revealed frustrations regarding the clarity and grammaticality of message queries in the discussion.
• LM Studio Version Update Benefits: A user noted improvements in model output after updating LM Studio from version 0.2.31 to 0.3.3, despite keeping all other settings constant.
  • This sparked discussions about whether key-value caching was in use and its potential effects on output quality.
• Limitations of Context Management: Users expressed concerns about LM Studio's stateless nature, with one requesting the ability to maintain context across sessions without repetitive input.
  • Another user emphasized the challenge of providing persistent context as models are inherently stateless.
• Flash Attention Increasing Speed: The community discussed the Flash Attention feature, with some users expressing frustration over its unavailability on certain GPU models like GTX.
  • One user linked to a GitHub pull request detailing the setup for Flash Attention, claiming it significantly speeds up processing.
• GUI Bugs with Flash Attention: A user reported issues with the LM Studio GUI disappearing when utilizing Flash Attention, to which another noted a forthcoming bug fix in next week's release.
  • This issue highlighted possible connections to specific configuration settings and platform usage.

---

LM Studio ▷ #hardware-discussion (8 messages🔥):

• Water cooling single slot blocks
• Power supply configurations
• Using GPUs for heating
• Performance of M3 chip
• Tokens per second on 8B models

• Considering Water Cooling for 8 Cards: A member is contemplating purchasing water cooling single slot blocks for their setup of 8 cards to maintain a tidy look.
  • They currently use two 1600W and one 1500W power supplies, noting the total draw is a maximum of 4000W.
• Advice on Electrical Safety: A community member advised to run new wire and breakers of appropriate size for safety, stating that improper setups can lead to severe hazards.
  • Concerns were raised after one user reported issues with breakers tripping under load, even while using a 15A breaker.
• Innovative Heating Solutions with GPUs: One participant suggested the idea of heating homes with GPUs, highlighting it as a potential startup concept.
  • This was echoed by a member who has been using their GPUs for heating during winter, though they noted it turned into a financial loss as mining profitability declined.
• Performance Metrics on M3 Chip: A user inquired about tokens/sec performance on the MacBook Air with the M3 chip when using 8B models.
  • Another member reported achieving rates in the high 70s with their M3 Max 128GB setup.
• Comparing Power Needs: A user compared their GPU setup's power consumption to everyday appliances, revealing their hot water system draws 1800W.
  • They also considered using their GPU's radiators for heating water cylinders as a cost-saving measure.

Link mentioned: Qwen2.5-Coder-7B-Instruct - a Hugging Face Space by Qwen: no description found

---

GPU MODE ▷ #general (20 messages🔥):

• Quantization Algorithms
• Int8 Threshold Degradation
• HQQ Performance
• Multi-GPU Quantization
• Bitsandbytes Slowness

• Discussion on Quantization Algorithms for Large Models: Members discussed suitable quantization algorithms for large neural networks (50B+ parameters) that maintain less than 1% loss in target metrics, highlighting techniques like int8 and HQQ.
  • One member noted that int4 + hqq quantization is also effective, given it requires minimal calibration.
• Troubleshooting Int8 Accuracy Issues: A user inquired about troubleshooting significant accuracy degradation when using int8 quantization, specifically mentioning issues with the default threshold=6.0.
  • Another member suggested reducing the threshold for outliers and referenced Hugging Face's guide for further insights.
• HQQ Performance and Utilization: The advantages of using HQQ with fast kernels like tinygemm and Bitblas were emphasized, suggesting it can outperform bitsandbytes for many scenarios.
  • Members also shared this tutorial for implementing HQQ with various backends.
• Multi-GPU Quantization Queries: Questions arose regarding the feasibility of running HQQ on multi-GPU setups, with one member reporting that one A100 GPU could handle 4-bit quantization for a 50B model.
  • There was a suggestion for further testing and utilization of the HQQ library across multiple GPUs.
• Concerns Regarding Bitsandbytes Slowness: Concerns were raised about the slowness of Bitsandbytes int8 quantization, especially during inference with non-zero thresholds.
  • Users indicated a preference towards faster methods like HQQ, citing its optimizations and robust results.

---

GPU MODE ▷ #cool-links (1 messages):

as_ai: https://youtu.be/wGSSUSeaLgA

---

GPU MODE ▷ #beginner (2 messages):

• Tensor manipulation
• Triton JIT
• Dynamic slicing

• Dynamic Slicing of Tensor X: A member sought advice on how to manipulate a tensor X with a shape of [BLOCK_SIZE_INP * triton.next_power_of_2(n_inp_bits), 256, BLOCK_SIZE_OUT] by removing some elements from the 2nd dimension without loading the data to and from memory.
  • They proposed using the slicing method X[:, :BLOCK_HIDDEN_SIZE], with BLOCK_HIDDEN_SIZE being smaller than 256.
• Using Triton for Efficient Slicing: The same member shared a snippet using @triton.jit for a function _take_slice designed to take slices of the tensor while maintaining dimensions based on certain parameters.
  • They indicated intent to try the provided code to achieve their slicing goal effectively.

---

GPU MODE ▷ #youtube-recordings (1 messages):

• Project Duration
• Logistical Challenges

• Longer project lifespan is beneficial: A member expressed that while size isn't the main focus, a longer duration for projects would be quite helpful.
  • They noted that it usually takes time for projects to get going and having a sizeable amount of hours left would be advantageous.
• Challenges of extending project timelines: The discussion highlighted that increasing project duration comes with its own set of logistical challenges.
  • The intricacies of managing extended timelines were acknowledged as a potential hurdle for successful project execution.

---

GPU MODE ▷ #torchao (4 messages):

• Self-Compressing Neural Networks
• Dynamic Quantization-aware Training
• VRAM Budgeting in Model Training

• Inquiry on Self-Compressing Neural Networks Implementation: A member inquired about the status of Issue #658 on GitHub, regarding Self-Compressing Neural Networks, which focuses on dynamic quantization-aware training.
  • The goal of this task is to implement it as an option during training, allowing users to select a specific VRAM budget and obtain a correctly sized model.
• Investigating VRAM Budget Implementation: Another member confirmed that there was currently no one working on the issue but highlighted the interest in merging this technique as experimental in the AO library.
  • They emphasized that this approach could address the common problem of users needing to manage their VRAM budget, as seen in techniques like distillation.

Link mentioned: Self compressing neural networks · Issue #658 · pytorch/ao: Self-Compressing Neural Networks is dynamic quantization-aware training that puts the size of the model in the loss Paper: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13142 Code: https://github.com/geohot/ai-notebo...

---

GPU MODE ▷ #off-topic (5 messages):

• Elon Musk and Haitian community
• OpenAI funding update
• Discord member count
• Emoji reactions

• Elon Musk meets the Haitian community: A member expressed disappointment over inappropriate jokes directed at the Haitian community, stating, 'I have absolutely no desire to eat them' and urged Elon Musk to be aware.
  • They emphasized the seriousness of the matter by asserting that it's not funny at all, appealing to broader understanding.
• OpenAI's new funding round: A member shared a link to an article discussing OpenAI's new funding round and restructuring plans, signaling significant industry developments.
  • The article on Axios outlines key changes that may impact the AI landscape.
• Discord server on the verge of 10k members: A member highlighted the upcoming milestone of almost 10,000 members in their Discord server, showcasing the community's growth.
  • This notable increase demonstrates engagement and interest in the discussions taking place within the server.
• Discord emoji reactions: Members utilized emoji reactions to convey their feelings about various topics discussed, indicating vibrant community interaction.
  • Emojis such as <:gigachad:1198826865016721550> and <:pmpp_icon:1199107527539961987> were shared, adding a lighthearted tone to the conversation.

---

GPU MODE ▷ #hqq-mobius (5 messages):

• AWQ+HQQ results
• HQQ implementation in TorchAO
• Benchmark Evaluation
• MMLU and GSM8K robustness

• AWQ+HQQ results show marginal improvements: Results from running AWQ+HQQ indicate some marginal improvements, but further evaluation on remaining benchmarks is necessary.
  • One member noted that the results make more sense now, highlighting a need for comprehensive analysis.
• MMLU and GSM8K praised for robustness: Members agree that benchmarks like MMLU and GSM8K provide more robust evaluation metrics for performance comparison.
  • This comparison is critical for validating improvements in the AWQ+HQQ testing phase.
• HQQ in TorchAO falls slightly short: A member pointed out that the HQQ implementation in TorchAO performs slightly worse than the original due to differences in handling the zero-point.
  • This variance has implications for interpreting the results from the benchmark evaluations.

---

GPU MODE ▷ #llmdotc (2 messages):

• 16K token batch processing
• Attention heads allocation
• NCCL communication strategy
• Zero Redundancy Optimizer
• Activation checkpointing

• Optimizing 16K Token Batch Processing: A member proposed handling 1 batch of 16K tokens per GPU, and for attention, having each GPU manage 1/8 of the heads for 128K tokens.
  • This method would allow for nccl communication before and after without impacting cuDNN/FA's functionality.
• Manual Stitching vs. Proposed Method: Another member initially considered manually stitching the softmax part, but acknowledged that the new proposal appears to be a better solution.
  • This sounds better was their response, indicating a shift in perspective towards the proposed method.
• Combining Techniques for Efficiency: The initial approach combines the new batching strategy with ZeRO-3 and an existing activation checkpointing PR for enhanced performance.
  • This suggests a shift towards leveraging multiple strategies to improve model training efficiency.

---

GPU MODE ▷ #rocm (1 messages):

• Advancing AI event
• ROCM developers

• Attend the Advancing AI Event in SF: There's an Advancing AI event on 10/10 at SF Moscone focusing on upcoming hardware and software.
  • Interested attendees are encouraged to DM for registration details and engage with ROCM developers.
• ROCM Developers Engage at Event: The event serves as an opportunity to catch up with ROCM developers and learn about their latest projects.
  • This gathering looks to foster community interaction and discussions around the future of AI technology.

---

GPU MODE ▷ #bitnet (2 messages):

• BF16 vs FP32 weights
• Custom Optimizer Development
• Stochastic Rounding Techniques

• Exploring BF16 Weights Impact on Accuracy: A member expressed concern about potentially sacrificing accuracy by training with BF16 weights instead of FP32.
  • They noted that with their current configuration, it might be possible to utilize FP32 for weights while keeping the optimizer as BF16 within 4090 VRAM.
• Need for Custom Optimizer to Mix Data Types: Discussion highlighted that PyTorch's built-in optimizer does not support differing dtype for weights and optimizer, prompting a member to consider writing their own optimizer.
  • They referenced the big_vision repository which similarly uses FP32 for weights and BF16 for the optimizer.
• Innovative Stochastic Rounding Method: An alternative approach was suggested involving using BF16 for weights and optimizer while utilizing FP32 for optimizer computation paired with stochastic rounding.
  • This technique proposes adding a random 16 bits to the mantissa of FP32, which leverages its extra bits for efficiency, as demonstrated by llm.c.

Link mentioned: llm.c/llmc/adamw.cuh at 7ecd8906afe6ed7a2b2cdb731c042f26d525b820 · karpathy/llm.c: LLM training in simple, raw C/CUDA. Contribute to karpathy/llm.c development by creating an account on GitHub.

---

GPU MODE ▷ #metal (1 messages):

• Metal Programming Basics
• Comparison of CUDA and Metal

• Understanding Metal Programming: A newcomer expressed their current grasp of Metal programming, noting that while CUDA uses block_size * grid_size for thread dispatch, Metal simply utilizes the grid size.
  • They highlighted that threadgroups in Metal are designed for shared memory among grids.
• Clarification on MSL Spec: The newcomer mentioned they had skimmed the MSL spec, but were unsure if their understanding was entirely accurate.
  • They welcomed feedback on their interpretation of the threading model in Metal.

---

Eleuther ▷ #general (25 messages🔥):

• Liability and Fair Use in AI
• Issues Around Scraping Legitimacy
• OpenAI's Moderation Policies
• Research Opportunities in AI
• MMLU Scoring for Models

• Exploring Liability in AI Research: Discussion centered on whether individuals who share AI models for research could be held liable if others misuse them, with some suggesting that liability might not attach directly to the original researcher.
  • Members noted that a clear ruling may be required to establish guidelines, emphasizing the need for clarity in these legal waters.
• Litigation on Scraping Raises Concerns: Concerns were raised regarding ongoing litigation about the legal status of web scraping, with artists and writers expressing frustration over the practice.
  • An example case was cited, where companies tried and failed to prohibit scraping unless strict conditions were met, highlighting legal complexities.
• The Impact of OpenAI's Moderation Policies: A member recounted their experience with OpenAI's moderation policy which flagged their request to prompt AGI, leading to unsettling moments over perceived violations.
  • Others agreed that the policies seem overly cautious, suggesting that many flagged messages do not explicitly correlate with the stated usage policies.
• Opportunities for Creative AI Projects: A new member introduced themselves as a researcher interested in creative and sociotechnical analyses within AI, seeking collaborative projects on commons-based approaches.
  • This highlights the potential for interdisciplinary research in AI, particularly in the fields of digital humanities.
• MMLU Scoring Resources Shared: A member inquired about obtaining MMLU scores for new models, leading to the recommendation of the evaluation harness by EleutherAI.
  • They also mentioned a dedicated channel for further discussion on the topic, promoting collaborative learning.

---

Eleuther ▷ #research (13 messages🔥):

• Self-Supervised Learning on Arbitrary Embeddings
• Softmax Function Limitations
• Learning Optimal Rank for LoRA Layers
• ColBERT Embeddings Usage
• Pretraining Alignment Projects

• Exploring Self-Supervised Learning on Arbitrary Embeddings: Discussion highlighted self-supervised learning (SSL) applied to arbitrary embeddings from any model and data, aiming for SSL on pretrained models across multiple modalities.
  • One participant proposed taking this further by applying SSL directly on any model weights, emphasizing flexibility in dataset formation.
• Softmax Function's Sharp Decision Myth: An abstract from this paper revealed a crucial limitation of the softmax function, asserting it cannot robustly approximate sharp functions as the number of inputs increases.
  • The paper theorizes that adaptive temperature is key to addressing this challenge, prompting skepticism about the proposed solution's strength.
• Potential for Learning LoRA Layer Ranks: A member inquired about methods to learn or approximate the optimal rank of LoRA layers rather than manually setting them, suggesting a potential breakthrough in automating the process.
  • Another user referenced a project on adaptive-span as an inspiration for this exploration.
• Skepticism Around ColBERT Embeddings: A user questioned the lack of adoption of ColBERT embeddings, noting their promise in eliminating the need for chunking in data processing.
  • Another member pointed out that using rerankers effectively negates the need for extra complexity compared to bm25+dpr, suggesting comparable recall results.
• Interest in Pretraining Alignment Projects: A query was made about current projects related to pretraining alignment or advancements in neural network architecture, indicating ongoing interest in this area.
  • No further information was provided, leaving the inquiry open for more contributions or insights.

---

Eleuther ▷ #lm-thunderdome (5 messages):

• lm-eval-harness metrics issue
• Hugging Face dataset PR approval
• Claude 3.5 Sonnet evaluation

• Issue with new metric in lm-eval-harness: A user reported trying to add a new metric to an existing multiple-choice task but faced issues, stating it was not added for the MedQA dataset. They provided a link to the GitHub issue for further context.
  • The issue seemed to center around updating the metrics, highlighting the need for assistance in resolving it.
• PR approval needed for Hugging Face dataset: A member requested someone with access to Hugging Face to approve a PR regarding the CoQA dataset, noting that the downloader was not following redirects correctly. They detailed the problem with loading the dataset and provided a link to the discussion on Hugging Face.
  • Another member responded affirmatively, stating they had merged the necessary changes, prompting gratitude from the original poster.
• Sharing results from Claude 3.5 Sonnet evaluation: A user shared their evaluation results of Claude 3.5 Sonnet using lm-eval-harness specifically on the GSM8K task. They requested insights from others regarding better performance achieved on this evaluation.
  • They outlined the command used for evaluation, including model parameters and output paths, inviting comparisons with other users' results.

---

Eleuther ▷ #gpt-neox-dev (1 messages):

• Current Active Projects at Eleuther
• Open Source Software Needs
• Opportunities for Contributions

• Inquiry About Active Projects: A member asked about the current active projects at Eleuther to better understand the team's focus areas.
  • They expressed interest in contributing, particularly due to their background as a first author in computer vision publications.
• Request for OSS Needs: The same member inquired about what open source software needs the team currently has for potential contributions.
  • This request highlights a desire for collaboration and support within the Eleuther community.

---

DSPy ▷ #show-and-tell (1 messages):

seanchatmangpt: https://pypi.org/project/dslmodel/2024.10.3.3

---

DSPy ▷ #general (42 messages🔥):

• DSPy 2.5 User Feedback
• Documentation Improvements
• AI Arxiv Podcast
• LLM Knowledge Sources
• Self-Improvement in Prompt Pipelines

• User Experience with DSPy 2.5: Users express positive feedback about the improvements in DSPy 2.5, indicating it offers a great overall experience despite some rough edges.
  • One noted the changes with TypedPredictors are promising, while another member advocates for more documentation on customization.
• Demand for Better Documentation: Community members urged for improvements in documentation, particularly around using Pydantic and multiple LMs within workflows.
  • The feedback highlighted a need for easier copyable guides to enhance usability amidst complex generation tasks.
• Introduction to the AI Arxiv Podcast: A podcast called AI Arxiv discusses how big tech applies LLMs, sharing its latest episode as a resource for the community.
  • Listeners were encouraged to check it out, with plans to upload episodes to YouTube by the week's end for broader accessibility.
• Seeking LLM Knowledge Sources: A member solicited recommendations for AI/LLM-related news and resources, suggesting Twitter and subreddits as potential sources.
  • Responses included shared links, such as a curated Twitter list focusing on relevant content and discussions.
• Self-Improvement of DSPy Prompt Pipelines: A member asked about the self-improvement mechanism in DSPy prompt pipelines compared to traditional LLM training flows.
  • Papers were recommended discussing optimization strategies for multi-stage language model programs and the benefits of fine-tuning alongside prompt optimization.

---

Torchtune ▷ #announcements (1 messages):

• Torchtune 0.3.1 Release
• Llama 3.2 Vision Models
• Knowledge Distillation Recipe
• MPS Beta Support
• Documentation Overhaul

• Torchtune 0.3.1 makes a significant update: The Torchtune 0.3.1 patch now includes all the Llama 3.2 Vision models and comprehensive multimodal support for finetuning recipes, generation, and evaluation.
  • Major highlights include fine-tuning Llama 3.1 405B using QLoRA on 8 x A100s, enhancing performance options.
• Knowledge Distillation Recipe introduced: A new knowledge distillation recipe has been added with configurations for Llama3.2 and Qwen2, expanding the toolkit for users.
  • Members are encouraged to explore these new features for improved model efficiency and performance.
• MPS Beta Support now available: MPS beta support allows users to utilize Torchtune on Macbooks, bringing fine-tuning capabilities to the Apple ecosystem.
  • This enables users to fine-tune models on the go, enhancing accessibility for developers.
• Streamlined Memory Management: The update introduces streamed activations offloading for reduced memory consumption with minimal performance impact.
  • This feature is aimed at easing resource demands during training runs, making it more efficient for large models.
• Extensive Documentation Overhaul: A massive documentation overhaul focuses on the Basics, covering custom datasets, multimodal transforms, and more.
  • Users can access an upgraded resource for all their queries and setups, found at Torchtune Documentation.

---

Torchtune ▷ #dev (35 messages🔥):

• Tokenizer truncation issues
• Independent max_seq_len in packing
• Flash Attention memory usage
• HF dataset names and links
• Model card generation

• Tokenizer auto truncation causes losses: The text completion dataset automatically truncates sequences beyond max_seq_len, leading to loss of tokens from larger documents, prompting requests for more user control over this behavior.
  • Members discussed possible solutions, including separating packing max_seq_len from tokenizer limits to avoid unnecessary truncation.
• Debate on independent max_seq_len for packing: There's a proposition that if packing max_seq_len was independent of the tokenizer's max_seq_len, it could improve memory performance without undue truncation of documents.
  • Concerns were raised about potential self-attention memory growth, with discussions on whether it scales linearly or quadratically with sequence lengths.
• Exploring Flash Attention implications: A member questioned whether Flash Attention results in linear memory growth despite the computation being quadratic, noting experiences where memory consumed was linear with number of tokens.
  • The conversation highlighted potential computations costs incurred by using Flash Attention, revealing a lack of consensus on its actual memory behavior.
• Proposing clearer HF dataset reference methods: There's a suggestion to create a mapping like DATASET_TO_SOURCE to easily retrieve actual HF dataset names used in projects, enhancing the automatic generation of model cards.
  • This aims to streamline the process linking actual datasets while working towards generating clearer dataset documentation in YAML.
• Tension between quick v0 implementation and detailed features: The team is weighing the benefits of rapidly deploying a basic version (v0) against going into depth on a more refined feature set like model cards and tagging.
  • Amidst discussions of complex requirements, there is a desire to keep the project moving and avoid unnecessary diversions into detailed implementations for the initial release.

---

LlamaIndex ▷ #blog (2 messages):

• MongoDB Atlas
• Hybrid Search
• Box Integration
• AI-driven Content Management

• Implementing Hybrid Search with MongoDB Atlas: A blog post discusses how to create and configure MongoDB Atlas vector and full-text search indexes for hybrid search implementation.
  • It emphasizes combining semantic and full-text search to enhance the relevance of search results.
• Integrate Box for Intelligent Applications: A post introduces using Box tools with LlamaIndex to build AI-driven content management applications.
  • This allows for advanced searches in Box, aiming to extract and process information efficiently from Box content.

---

LlamaIndex ▷ #general (27 messages🔥):

• RAG system issues
• Async conversion in RAG app
• Using LlamaIndex for RFP generation
• VLLM error handling
• Entity and relation properties in LlamaIndex

• Errors in RAG system during tutorial: A user faced a ModuleNotFoundError while following a tutorial for building a RAG system with an Excel file, indicating a potential problem with the installed version of pandas.
  • Another user suggested trying an older version of pandas (2.2.2 or older) to resolve compatibility issues.
• Async conversion challenges in RAG app: A user is converting a RAG application to async but is unsure if the QueryEngineTool would support async methods and how the RouterQueryEngine plays a role.
  • Clarifications were provided on how to utilize async methods within the RouterQueryEngine for a smooth transition.
• Generating RFP responses with LlamaIndex: A developer seeks to use LlamaIndex to build a system that generates RFP responses based on winning proposals from selected entities and is looking for efficient indexing and fact replacement strategies.
  • They also inquire about LlamaIndex's capability to generate PDF or Word files from the responses.
• VLLM error details shared: A user reported a KeyError while trying to use VLLM for their RAG implementation, indicating a missing key in the response data.
  • Another member requested the full traceback to better assist in diagnosing the issue.
• Entity properties in PropertyGraphIndex: A member questioned whether the properties defined for entities in PropertyGraphIndex are shared across all entities, pointing to an allowed_entity_props parameter in the DynamicLLMPathExtractor.
  • Clarification was sought about documentation on entity relationship properties and how the SchemaLLMPathExtractor utilizes its inputs.

---

LangChain AI ▷ #general (19 messages🔥):

• Jordan Pfost's AI Expertise
• Kapa.ai's Capabilities
• Understanding Like and Reward in LLMs
• Internship Opportunities in AI

• Jordan Pfost's AI Expertise: Jordan Pfost introduced himself as a Sr. Fullstack Engineer with 10 years of experience in AI/Web products, emphasizing skills in GPU Clustering, RAG, and Agentic Reasoning.
  • He shared his project experience with spendeffect.ai, iplan.ai, and Pump GPT and expressed interest in exploring collaboration opportunities.
• Kapa.ai's Capabilities: Kapa.ai explained its capabilities as a transformer-based language model with around 340 million parameters, built for natural language tasks.
  • It detailed its training on a diverse corpus and highlighted its generation of text that meets human-like quality standards while referencing LangChain documentation for further exploration.
• Understanding Like and Reward in LLMs: Kapa.ai clarified that LLMs do not possess personal preferences or receive rewards but operate based on patterns from training data.
  • It referenced a paper on preference optimization while providing links to LangChain documentation for more insights on LLM operations.
• Internship Opportunities in AI: A member inquired if any college students from India are looking for internships in the AI space, inviting them to express interest.
  • This query aims to connect students with potential internship opportunities in the AI field.

Link mentioned: how-to="" a="" guides="" href="https://python.langchain.com/v0.2/docs/how_to/#llms>)." langchain<="" |="" 🦜️🔗="">: Here you’ll find answers to “How do I….?” types of questions.

---

LangChain AI ▷ #share-your-work (1 messages):

• LangGraph Query Generation
• LangChain Ecosystem
• Error Correction in Queries

• LangGraph Tackles Query Generation and Structuring: A new LinkedIn post explores how LangGraph handles complex query generation and output structuring within the LangChain ecosystem.
  • It highlights a focus on error correction and user-friendly results, while acknowledging the contributions of Harrison Chase and the LangChain team.
• Shoutout to LangChain Team: The post gives a big shoutout to the LangChain team and specifically to Harrison Chase for their contributions in the development of LangGraph's features.
  • This highlights the collaborative effort that drives innovation and enhancements in AI workflows.

---

OpenInterpreter ▷ #general (5 messages):

• October House Party
• Open Interpreter Showcases

• Tomorrow is the October House Party: Don't forget! Tomorrow is the October House Party – join here for fun and updates.
  • One member expressed excitement, stating they are not missing this one after being held back by health and work.
• Show off your Open Interpreter Creations: The host invited anyone who has built something using Open Interpreter to showcase their work during the party.
  • They encouraged attendees to bring their questions and share their experiences.
• Mixed Responses to the Timing of the Event: One member commented that it’s too early for them, indicating some schedule conflicts.
  • Conversely, another member enthusiastically proclaimed, PARTY TIMEEEE, reflecting excitement for the upcoming event.

---

OpenInterpreter ▷ #O1 (10 messages🔥):

• Skill Teaching Capabilities
• Model Compatibility
• OpenAI Request Issues

• Members Discuss Skill Teaching: A user inquired about teaching skills to their model, prompting another member to suggest confirming the intent to teach a skill is clear.
  • Despite attempts, the issue with teaching remained unresolved, indicating a potential need for further support.
• Model's Vision Capabilities: There was confusion regarding whether skills come with vision capabilities, which was noted to depend on the model being used.
  • Specifically, the user mentioned using gpt4o with Cartesia and Deepgram, and members concluded that it should theoretically work.
• OpenAI Request Failures: A user reported that after a few messages, their OpenAI requests simply stop working, with no errors or logs provided.
  • The situation highlights potential issues in the system, with members encouraged to open a new post for troubleshooting.

---

OpenInterpreter ▷ #ai-content (1 messages):

mikebirdtech: Thoughts on Mozilla's Public AI?

---

OpenAccess AI Collective (axolotl) ▷ #general (12 messages🔥):

• Logo change feedback
• Vllm and vision concerns
• Demo usage experiences
• Fine-tuning plans
• Deployment strategies

• Logo change sparks mixed reactions: Members reacted to the recent logo change with a mix of emojis ranging from confusion to frustration, indicating varying levels of acceptance.
  • One member humorously noted, 'I thought I lost the server from my list 😅.'
• Funding expectations questioned: One member expressed a humorous expectation that the new logo should correlate with raising $10 million at a $1 billion valuation.
  • Another user responded, 'Sheeesh,' indicating disbelief or surprise at the ambitious funding targets.
• Demo experiences shared: A member shared their experience with the demo, stating, 'It’s not bad I used it through the demo,' suggesting a positive interaction.
  • The ongoing conversation indicated that members are still getting accustomed to the changes.
• Fine-tuning discussions in progress: Questions were raised about whether the model was fine-tuned yet, with members confirming that it has not been fine-tuned as of now.
  • One member reassured that fine-tuning will happen soon and highlighted plans to deploy a 70 billion parameter model once ready.

---

LAION ▷ #general (9 messages🔥):

• Regex rules for spam blocking
• Google's Illuminate tool
• Automated Arxiv Paper Video Channel

• Regex effectively blocks spam: A member shared a regex pattern to block markdown link obfuscation: \[[^\]]+\]\(https?:\/\/[^)\s]+\).
  • Custom regex and word blocklists tailored to specific spam types, like porn and cryptocurrency, can effectively reduce spam bots' presence.
• 60s timeout deters spam bots: Implementing a 60-second timeout after message blocking is an effective strategy to make spam bots leave after a few attempts.
  • This method minimizes disruptions for genuine users, avoiding excessive false positives.
• Google's Illuminate tool looks promising: A member highlighted a link to Google's Illuminate as an exciting new tool being rolled out.
  • Questions arose regarding how this tool compares to the notebooklm podcast tool, indicating interest in both implementations.
• Automated YouTube channel 'Arxflix' shares Arxiv papers: Another member promoted their automated YouTube channel, Arxflix, dedicated to sharing Arxiv papers through videos.
  • The member expressed pride in this project, suggesting it may offer more engaging content than other tools.

---

tinygrad (George Hotz) ▷ #general (8 messages🔥):

• tinybox delivery inquiry
• support email addition
• questions document importance
• FAQ improvements
• community culture

• User Inquiries on Tinybox Delivery: A user expressed concern about the delivery timeline for a tinybox while in the USA, asking if it could arrive in 2-5 days.
  • George Hotz advised them to e-mail support@tinygrad.org for logistical questions, emphasizing the need for well-formulated inquiries.
• Adding Support Email to FAQ: A suggestion was made to include the support email in the website FAQ due to its absence.
  • George confirmed that he would add it immediately, indicating a responsiveness to community feedback.
• Clarifying Delivery Locations: George raised a point questioning the relevance of the delivery location, stressing uncertainty about shipping to areas like San Diego, Michigan, or Hawaii.
  • He highlighted the importance of formulating good questions, referencing the channel #1068979651336216706 for guidance.
• Improving User Agreement on Questions Document: George suggested implementing a click-through agreement for users to acknowledge reading the questions document, possibly including multiple-choice questions.
  • Another member pointed out that a click-through confirmation already exists for users.
• Community Culture Observations: George expressed frustration with the community's culture around asking questions, referring to it as a recurring issue.
  • He urged members to prioritize clear communication and proper inquiry processes.

---

LLM Agents (Berkeley MOOC) ▷ #mooc-questions (2 messages):

• Inference Timings in SLM Systems
• RAG Architecture with Llama Index
• Course Material Availability

• Improving Inference Timings in SLM Systems: A member inquired about potential ways to enhance inference timings for SLM-based systems utilizing RAG architecture with Llama Index.
  • They are seeking community suggestions to optimize performance.
• Course Slides Are Up!: Another member announced that the slides are now available on the course website.
  • This update ensures participants can access necessary materials for their learning.

---

LLM Agents (Berkeley MOOC) ▷ #mooc-readings-discussion (1 messages):

• AI Reading Group
• INDUS Research Paper
• IBM and NASA collaboration

• AI Reading Group Launches Discussion Platform: The AI Reading Group from Women in AI & Robotics has been launched to present AI papers by researchers, fostering dialogue between them and the community.
  • The inaugural session features Aashka Trivedi from IBM discussing the joint research with NASA; sign-ups are limited for audience Q&A.
• Upcoming Presentation on INDUS Paper: Join the AI Reading Group on October 17, 2024 at 12pm EST for a presentation on the paper titled INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models for Scientific Applications.
  • The session will be led by Aashka Trivedi, showcasing collaborative research involving great institutions like NASA and IBM.
• Collaborative Research Showcased: The INDUS paper co-authored by IBM Research AI, NASA, and others highlights advancements in language models tailored for scientific applications.
  • This reading group is aimed at demystifying leading innovations and promoting interdisciplinary discussions in AI.

Link mentioned: INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models: AI Reading Group session with one of the authors of "INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models for Scientific Applications".

---

Alignment Lab AI ▷ #general (1 messages):

• AI Reading Group Launch
• Research Presentation on INDUS
• Community Engagement in AI
• Q&A Session with Researchers
• Event Participation Limitations

• AI Reading Group officially launches: The AI Reading Group from Women in AI & Robotics has launched, allowing researchers to present AI papers followed by a Q&A session.
  • This initiative aims to create a platform for direct dialogue between researchers and the community, enhancing engagement with emerging research.
• Upcoming presentation on INDUS: The first speaker, Aashka Trivedi from IBM, will present research on 'INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models for Scientific Applications' on October 17, 2024.
  • This paper's authors come from prestigious institutions including IBM Research, NASA, and Harvard-Smithsonian CfA.
• Limited attendees for engagement: Participants interested in joining the reading group must sign up soon due to limited attendance to facilitate audience questions.
  • This restriction aims to ensure meaningful interactions during the Q&A segment after presentations.
• Engaging with interdisciplinary discussions: The AI Reading Group is designed to highlight current research topics in AI and provide a space for interdisciplinary discussions.
  • By fostering these dialogues, the group aims to demystify leading innovations and facilitate deeper engagement with relevant research.

Link mentioned: INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models: AI Reading Group session with one of the authors of "INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models for Scientific Applications".

---

Gorilla LLM (Berkeley Function Calling) ▷ #discussion (1 messages):

• Third-party datasets
• Code modification for datasets

• Modify Code to Support Third-party Datasets: The current implementation does not natively support third-party datasets, but a member suggested that modifying the code could allow for this functionality.
  • They stated that adjustments would involve adding a model handler for parsing logic, changing the test file mapping, and selecting appropriate checkers.
• Implementing Dataset Parsing Logic: To integrate a new dataset, a member explained that you need to implement the parsing logic using decode_ast and decode_exec.
  • This adaptation requires a basic understanding of how the pipeline processes datasets to ensure compatibility.

---

---

---

---

---