I had a strange, and wonderful, experience this week.
I'm currently working on the chapter that includes Sagaris, which was one of 1975-est things that happened in 1975. In brief (for a longer treatment wait a couple of years for the release of my biography of Rita Mae Brown!), a couple of very early women's studies teachers, frustrated by the way they were treated in academia, set up an “independent institute for the study of feminist thought,” which they dubbed Sagaris. There would be two five-week sessions, hosted at Lyndon State College in Lyndonville, Vermont, over the summer of 1975. As one of the founders told me, driven by the DIY spirit of the times, they just made it happen. They said to themselves: "Let's hire every feminist we have ever heard of who has any radical clout. Let's write to them all and tell them we're going to start this.” Among the women who accepted their invitation to teach at the institute were Charlotte Bunch, Mary Daly, Ti-Grace Atkinson, Alix Kates Schulman, Margo Jefferson, Bertha Harris, and ... Rita Mae.
If people know anything about Sagaris, it tends to be the dissolution of the second session. In order to raise money for scholarships, the organizing collective applied for grants, and they got $10,000 from the Ms. Foundation. Does that seem innocuous? Well, earlier that summer, a group using the name Redstockings1 had published an extensive exposé, noting that Ms. editor Gloria Steinem had spent several years working for the Independent Research Service, a CIA front. There had always been reasonable concern about agents infiltrating the women's movement, but those anxieties were heightened in 1975 because of the June release of the report of the President’s Commission on CIA Activities Within the United States, better known as the Rockefeller Commission, which confirmed that intelligence agencies had infiltrated anti-war, civil rights, and feminist groups.
Some Sagaris students and faculty members felt that Steinem's historical ties tainted the Ms. Foundation's philanthropy with the whiff of government interference, and the result was a fractious split in the midst of the second session. As the New York Times put it in a story with the all-time great headline, "The Women Activists Found Little Peace at Bucolic School": "the community was separated into two equally strong wills. A flurry of statements and counterstatements were written, votes taken, and finally 25 out of about 75 faculty members and students, some mothers with children in tow, marched down to the valley to form an alternative school in the Bemis Community Church Center."
Rita Mae taught in the first session, so while I'll have to deal with the breakdown of the second session, the first was my main focus. There were a couple of key figures I wanted to talk with, and in the way things sometimes work out, all the women I was able to connect with and arrange to interview were members of the organizing collective. I didn't have the student perspective. Then, as I was reading through some letters from Rita Mae's archive, I found a note from 1988 that mentioned the author had been at Sagaris. It felt kind of random, but I Googled the name, which led me to a web site, which provided me with an email, which soon enough led to an interview being scheduled.
The woman was Jacqueline St. Joan, who is now retired as a judge and lawyer and has recently published a memoir. I prepared my questions, and then as I was re-reading the stories about Sagaris in off our backs and Big Mama Rag, I realized that the author of Big Mama Rag's excellent coverage was ... Jackie St. Joan! I was going to be talking with the woman who had provided a first-hand report of what it was like to attend Sagaris' first session.
Jackie hadn't had a chance to re-read her stories (she wrote two--one describing life at the summer school and one summarizing the issues that arose and the way students raised them), so it was fascinating to see what she remembered and what had faded from memory. It turned out, she had no recollection of the students' complaints, but she had clear and joyful memories of the classes, the bare-bones dorm rooms, and of traveling from Denver to Vermont with her two small children by train. She also told me about the lifelong friendships that had been forged at Sagaris--she had spoken with three of the women she first met there, 51 years earlier, in the week that we spoke.
I mention all this not to undermine the benefit of talking to people long after things have happened. I'm massively grateful to Jackie and all the women who have spoken to me about events that are deep in the past, and I always get something--often a lot--out of those interviews. BUT it also reminded me that contemporaneous coverage is key (all the professional historians reading this are weeping a little now), and that the ideal combination is what I had with Jackie: someone who could tell me what she remembers now, while JSTOR could show me how she described the experience back when it happened.
LISTEN TO ME: Actually, that's not quite accurate. I don't appear in this podcast, which is a no-guest show where the two hosts talk about a topic, but my research informed the discussion. The BBC podcast Here for the History recently did an episode with the title "Do Brits Have Bad Teeth?" so I'm duty-bound to mention it here! (And if you haven't heard it yet, don't miss my episode of Slate's Decoder Ring podcast, "The Bad-Mouthing of British Teeth," which is, as they say, comprehensive.)
RECOMMENDATION: I really loved my pal Brandon Tensley's new book (his first of many, I very much hope), Whitney Houston's I'm Your Baby Tonight. It's part of the 33 1/3 series, which each go deep on one album. It's a perfect format for Brandon, since it allows him to explore several aspects of Whitney and this album's historical context. I blurbed the book, and I will shout said blurb from the rooftops, or indeed, this newsletter: “In I'm Your Baby Tonight, Brandon Tensley gives 'R&B Whitney' the respect she deserves and was too long denied. Tensley writes beautifully about the music, the recording industry, the political era, and the miracle of that singular voice and steadfast personality. Most of all, it is a loving tribute to Whitney the performer, Whitney the star who lifted up a chosen family of Black women artists, Whitney who raised money for AIDS research and spoke lovingly of friends lost to the disease at a time when fear was the dominant response, and Whitney who refused to be pushed around and pigeonholed. An utter delight.” (I didn't have room to mention his fabulous analysis of MTV and Whitney's music videos. So good!)
ALSO, a bit crass, perhaps, but the season of giving is upon us, and it seems to me that A PLACE OF OUR OWN: SIX SPACES THAT SHAPED QUEER WOMEN'S CULTURE would make a great gift! I always feel a bit guilty mentioning Amazon--especially in light of Chapter 2 of the aforementioned title--but I will just mention that, for some reason, the Kindle edition is always shockingly cheap. In the U.K., it's just £2.99, and while I can't check the U.S. cost right now (since I can't buy Kindle books there, the site doesn't show me an exact price), it seems to be available "from $3.29." If money is tight, those are amazing prices. But also, support your local feminist/queer/radical/indie bookstore!
-
This awkward locution is necessary because by this point Redstockings was a rump organization. Very few of the women who had been there at the group's creation were still involved, and some were mad that the group was waging a campaign they didn't agree with under the name they'd come up with. Which is a pretty good distillation of the problems of institutional politics generally. ↩
You just read issue #79 of Where Are All the Emails?. You can also browse the full archives of this newsletter.