Ry's Comic List

Subscribe
Archives
April 22, 2025

Frog Talk 2

newsletter logo transparent.png

a stack of Excalibur comics from 1-34. Issue 1 of the series is on top
What a weird fucking book this was.

I recently put together a run of the Claremont issues of that book (1-34 including the fill-in issues and a one-shot) that is a piece of a larger Claremont reread that I have been building towards the past few years. The first time I read these comics, I was a child that liked the X-Men but got all their comics from Goodwill. At that time, most of the comics in there were Excalibur, Generation X, and various 90s excesses. In retrospect this does explain a lot about my taste. Regardless, I did not ‘get’ Excalibur at the time. I know that I’m missing big parts of the puzzle still not having read the original Alan Moore Captain Britain comics. But I can safely say that these comics are miraculous. Some of the best work put out by Marvel at the time that found both Claremont and co-creator/artist Alan Davis stretching their respective talents wide. Claremont for one seems to be writing in a Moore pastiche combined with his own predilections for verbosity and internecine character connections. The book was ostensibly a comedy, with numerous letter writers commenting on the humor of it, but let’s face it, Claremont is not as funny as Moore. That being said, the decision to cast Captain Britain as a dumb himbo—and actually sticking to it should be lauded.

a page from Excalibur illustrated by Ron Lim. Captain Britain is walking through NYC outof costume and semi-nude. The scene is played for laughs as he tries to figure out why his powers don't work
art by Ron Lim— one of many guest artists in this initial run.

Going into this I recalled “The Cross-Time Express” as being the centerpiece of the series. While that may be true in a broad sense, it’s much less of a grand narrative story than it is a collection of one and done stories anchored by a similar plot device. This is not a bad thing and in fact results in some of the high points of the series (Davis/Claremont parodying Judge Dredd; Nightcrawler, warlord of Mars; etc), but it doesn’t really go anywhere, marred no doubt by the proliferation of fill in issues that interrupted the flow of the story’s finale. Rather, I found the first twelve issues or so to be the most vibrant of the series, filled as they are with the creative team introducing some of the more esoteric elements of MarvelUK into the American market.

a page from Excalibur by Alan Davis. The scene is set at Brighton Pier. There are some dinosaur tourists walking in the rain. The bottom panel shows the Technet-- a collection of alien bounty hunters from the Alan Moore days on Captain Britain
Pages like this are pretty amazing, full of weird alien designs in service of social satire. Art by Davis and Neary

Another thing that stood out to me in this reread is the affection both authors have for the characters. Davis revels in drawing these people and populating the world(s) contained within. Claremont meanwhile invested so much of himself into the characters over however many decades that he still to this day identifies with them on a deeply personal level as evident in every interview. The tenor of the book then is much closer to the feeling I get from reading really well crafted fan fiction rather than corporate books made to move units.

a page from Excalibur by Alan Davis. Kitty Pryde and Lockheed are going through the interdimensional train they are aboard. Widget the robot is eating trash. The middle panel is not colored realistically. It is instead colored with flat, schoolyard primaries of red, yellow and blue.
Sidebar: I don’t know why the middle panel has such wild coloring— it doesn’t look like a typical separation error to me but it IS gorgeous.

As the series rounded the corner of year two, guest artists and writers became ubiquitous. First Davis, then Claremont left the book and it passed through multiple hands before Davis would return in the mid 40s of the series. My collection ends with issue 34— the last issue Claremont wrote. Within this chaotic period are of course a few diamonds. Terry Austin writes a one off story illustrated by Colleen Doran for example, but the real miracle is issue 27. This is a preposterous crossover with Nth Man (a Frogs favorite!) illustrated by the artistic team of Barry Windsor-Smith and Bill Sienkiewicz!!

a page from Excalibur by BWS and Bill Sienkiewicz. Jamie Braddock is sitting mostly nude staring at the reader.
another page from Excalibur by BWS and Sienkiewicz. Everyone has that BWS face, but inked with Sienkiewicz ideas
Their two styles blend together so nice

How freaking cool is this? Luckily I have two copies, so in addition to its inclusion in the set, I have listed just this issue separately for any BWS curious/completists.

I have also listed a three issue run in the late 30s written by Scott Lobdell and illustrated by Mark Badger! Badger is a favorite artist, anytime he works on a book it is worth looking at. His series Mars for First Comics is a favorite 80s indie. His style here is like a more developed version of that. Really cool stuff and the whole story revolves around Dr. Doom trying to take over Limbo so there is plenty of opportunity for Badger’s particular brand of mutant Looney Tunes art style.

the covers of Excalibur 37, 38, 39 that form one big image if the team and Dr. Doom and The West Coast Avengers fighting Limbo demons. Art by Mark Badger
A page from Excalibur by Mark Badger. Shadowcat is wielding the SoulSword through limbo with Dr. Doom behind her. He tricks her and in the last panel takes the sword from her
Always nice when an artist does not have to compromise their style for a mainstream book (Art by Badger)

Parallel to this childhood reread, I have been looking through all the small(er) press books in my library and unearthing quite a few forgotten gems that are now posted to the shop. For example, I recently spent a lovely morning with The Complete Jack Survives by Jerry Moriarty. I can’t remember where or when exactly I got this volume, but suffice to say it has always been one of those books that I got and then seemed to sit eternally on the to be read pile. The scale of the book lends itself to this. Released in 2016 by the much missed Buenaventura Press, Jack Survives is a gorgeous presentation of the original boards. Moriarty’s strip would appear intermittently in RAW and would be a motif that seemingly followed him throughout his career. Here you get to see his work evolve in the passage of time, which makes the introduction of color in the final quarter of the book particularly effective. (unfortunately my copy sold just as this newsletter went out!)

a page from Jack Survives by Jerry Moriarty. Jack cleans up the yard with his wife and then lies on the ground looking at clouds. He sees a horse in one of them
A beautiful book that is well worth seeking out!

I have highlighted various Simpsons/Bongo comics in the past. My feelings on the publisher can be put broadly as this: Bongo is unfairly overlooked for consistent formal inventiveness of its books that is combined with a deep knowledge of comics history by the writers and artists who worked on these books. Case in point, Grampa Simpson Comics #1, a choose your own adventure story that opens with a Wally Wood homage. That is the kind of sentence that entire careers were made upon not so long ago.

a page from a Simpson's one shot. Grampa Simpson is sitting in a spaceship cockpit modeled after a famous EC Comics page by Wally Wood. Abe does not remember how he got here. This is the title page of a choose your own adventure Simpsons Comic

four comics arrranged in a row. Cap'n Quick & a Foozle 1-2, The Foozle 3 and Eclipse Monthly 1, all featuring Marshall Rogers
Cap’n Quick & a Foozle by Marshall Rogers.

Here's the thing, this is probably the best thing Marshall Rogers ever did, he did all of it himself, and it's never gonna be back in print.

a page by Marshall Rogers from Eclipse Monthly 1. it is composed of color overlays on the line art in abstract patterns with a big set of eyes in the middle of the page.

In addition to the three issues represented here, I have included a copy of Eclipse Monthly 1, which featured the first adventure of both characters together. Rogers also appeared in issues 2 and 3 of that series before launching in this solo book. If you get that set and want these too reach out to make a deal!

A dense page of 12 panels in a non-standard grid from The Foozle by Marshall Rogers
Issue 3 consists of reprints from the black and white Eclipse Magazine, which featured only the Foozle. The pages were colored and printed in a regular size comic, hence the bars at top and bottom of the page.

Issue 3 consists of reprints from the Eclipse Magazine, which featured only The Foozle, hence the name change.

With that business out of the way, look at those pages!!! masterful craft. Amazingly complex yet clear page composition. perfect tertiary color combinations. perfect screentone applications (any moiré you see is from my capture NOT the printed comic). They're a joy to look at and read, and I'm thankful for what IS out there.

a page from Static by Steve Ditko.
My love/hate relationship with Ditko persists. Great looking comics, horrific ideology, but when he can’t help himself and has his characters stop all action to lecture each other about objectivism, it’s compelling in how pathetic it is.

And the rest of that Eclipse Monthly is pretty good too! Ditko's Static is wild. A pretty pure expression of his ideology, but the dude can't help from making a FUNKY looking comic!

These comics and MORE are available now on the bigcartel! combined shipping is encouraged! any extra costs will be refunded! See you all in a month!

to purchase these books and more, visit me online at https://mostlyfrogs.bigcartel.com/

Read more:

  • Frog Talk 1

    What is Frog Talk? It’s when I don’t have a theme for the newsletter and I’m just vibing putting books up. Most of these I read in the last ~three months or...

Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to Ry's Comic List:
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.