Where Do Jewish Democrats Fit in Today’s Democratic Party?
When Jewish voters’ concerns about antisemitism are dismissed as a distraction, the Democratic Party needs to ask what that means for its relationship with Jewish Americans.
The following was written prior to Haley Stevens announcing her decision to endorse Mike Rogers. It is a decision that I do not agree with. If Stevens were smart, she would have just said nothing about who she was voting or publicly announce that she was abstaining. There is nothing brave or courageous about her decision to endorse Mike Rogers.
Abdul El-Sayed has done little to earn the trust of Jewish voters. His refusal to heed Haley Stevens’ calls to condemn an antisemitic advertisement produced by Rebellion PAC in support of his Senate campaign was troubling enough. His subsequent dismissal of the controversy as irrelevant to Michigan voters only reinforced why Jewish voters have reason to question his commitment to confronting antisemitism.
Subscribe now Upgrade nowCosts were rising in America long before Trump pushed the country into war with Iran. The war certainly hasn’t helped oil prices, and anyone arguing that it has contributed to increasingly expensive air travel has a point. Blaming U.S. support for Israel for higher grocery prices, however, ignores the impact of Trump’s tariffs, which businesses regularly pass along to consumers through higher prices.
There is a serious problem with scapegoating Israelis—or Jews, for that matter—for America’s economic anxieties. Blaming Jews for economic hardship has a long and ugly history, including the Nazi propaganda campaigns of the early 1930s. Exploiting economic frustration to turn Jews into convenient scapegoats is hardly a new political tactic.
Let me be clear: My problem with Abdul El-Sayed has absolutely nothing to do with his religious faith. He is entitled to practice whatever religion he chooses. That’s a fundamental freedom protected by the First Amendment, and I would defend his right to exercise it. My objection is to his initial unwillingness to condemn the antisemitic messaging in the Rebellion PAC advertisement. Someone seeking a seat in the United States Senate should have no difficulty condemning an advertisement that scapegoats Jews and Israel.
El-Sayed’s comments on Saturday only reinforced my concerns. Asked whether he condemned the advertisement, he dismissed the calls to do so as playing the “condemn game.” He maintained that the advertisement wasn’t produced by his campaign and that he disagreed with its contents. But disagreeing with an advertisement and explicitly condemning its antisemitic messaging are two different things.
Asked whether he wanted Stevens to appear alongside him at Sunday’s event with Rep. James E. Clyburn, El-Sayed said he didn’t want to distract from the campaign's key issues. He went further, dismissing the controversy as something that wasn’t really relevant to Michigan voters. Apparently, confronting antisemitism is considered a distraction rather than something deserving the attention of someone seeking to represent Michigan in the United States Senate.
After Hasan Piker compared West Bloomfield’s Jewish community to a Ku Klux Klan neighborhood and described its residents as Jewish supremacists, El-Sayed called the comparison “utterly inappropriate and flat out wrong.” That is an unequivocal condemnation of Piker’s comments, even if El-Sayed stopped short of naming him or criticizing him personally. But it raises an obvious question: Why was he able to speak so plainly about Piker’s remarks while refusing to use similarly direct language about the Rebellion PAC advertisement? Piker was a prominent campaign surrogate for El-Sayed during the Democratic primary, making the distinction all the more difficult to ignore.
Criticism of Israeli government policies is perfectly legitimate. That doesn’t establish a connection between U.S. support for Israel and the cost of American groceries. Blaming Israel for domestic economic problems is scapegoating, plain and simple.
It’s not asking too much of political candidates to condemn antisemitism. If it were up to me, either Haley Stevens or Mallory McMorrow would have received Michigan’s Democratic nomination for the U.S. Senate. Outgoing U.S. Sen. Gary Peters had initially planned to remain neutral, but announced his endorsement of Stevens less than a month before the August primary. Unfortunately, Stevens fell short by less than 1% of the vote—she earned 47.55% to El-Sayed’s 48.45% of the vote. After McMorrow suspended her campaign, her name remained on the ballot, where she received 4% of the vote. Stevens ultimately lost by just 13,792 votes. We’ll never know how McMorrow would have performed if she hadn’t been forced to suspend due to rigged polling.
I’ve identified with the Democratic Party since before registering to vote in late 2001. I supported President Clinton’s reelection in 1996, and by 2000, I was already considering a career in politics. I considered myself a proud Democrat, even during the years when the political climate was challenging for Democrats.
Yet as more elements of the Democratic Party, along with politicians and activists aligned with the Democratic Socialists of America, embrace rhetoric that I consider antisemitic, identifying myself as a proud Democrat becomes increasingly difficult. I can’t comfortably support candidates whose rhetoric I consider antisemitic, particularly when opposition to Zionism becomes a central component of their campaigns. You cannot tell me that you stand with Jewish Americans when you embrace rhetoric that questions Israel’s right to exist. Israel is home to roughly half of the world’s Jewish population. When politicians turn Israel into a scapegoat or suggest that its existence is the problem, they contribute to an environment in which Jewish communities outside Israel can also become targets.
I’m glad I don't live in Michigan because I would be forced to abstain from voting in this Senate race—it’s the same case with the Ohio governor’s race where Amy Acton has decided to turn her back on transgender Ohioans. Mike Rogers would be another vote supporting the Trump administration’s agenda, including its policies targeting transgender Americans and immigrants. I’ll be curious to see the difference in vote totals between the Senate and governor races.
Taking back the United States Senate is important. So is ensuring that Jewish voters aren’t expected to overlook antisemitism for the sake of political expediency. Democrats cannot claim to stand against hatred while dismissing legitimate concerns from Jewish Americans about rhetoric that scapegoats Israel and the Jewish people. I’ve spent over 30 years identifying with the Democratic Party, including more than 25 years since making that identification official when I registered to vote. Yet I increasingly find myself questioning where I fit in a party that seems unwilling to confront this problem. That should concern Democrats far beyond Michigan.
Upgrade now