Book Time

Book Time

Archives
Subscribe
October 25, 2026

Book Time #32: Maybe That's How the Apes Do It

book_time_logoyellow_bg.png

Indecent Exposure: A True Story of Hollywood and Wall Street, David McClintick

The Studio, John Gregory Dunne

The key to the success of both these books is the authors’ staggering degree of access to the principal subjects. In the preface of the 1982 edition of The Studio, which is the one I happened to get from eBay, Dunne acknowledges this. In 1967, he met with Twentieth Century Fox Studios vice president of production Richard Zanuck and asked for full access to the studio. In Dunne’s telling, he was granted it on the spot. “There was no reason for him to give it to me,” Dunne wrote, “And to this day I do not know why he did.”

Much like any endeavor in which the myth of meritocracy smooths over the contours of privilege, journalists have a habit of understating the importance of personal connections in the backstories of their work. But by my cursory read of Dunne’s Wikipedia page, I don’t see any obvious reason his request should have met with great favor from Zanuck. Dunne went to Princeton, but Zanuck didn’t. Dunne was married to Joan Didion, but she wasn’t a household name then. Dunne was a reporter for Time, but so were a lot of other people. Dunne would go on to write screenplays and acclaimed novels, but that was all in the future. Maybe he simply caught Zanuck in a good mood.

As for Indecent Exposure (a title more worthy of softcore romantasy than a serious bit of reportage) you can read about the backstory in a 1982 New York Times article about “the summer's most talked about book.” McClintick was a financial reporter for the Wall Street Journal and broke the story of the head of Columbia Pictures getting suspended for forging checks. What ought to have been a straightforward bit of low-key financial crime became a tortured saga “of psychological bloodshed at the highest level of corporations” (McClintick’s [apt] words). Amazingly, McClintick was able to get detailed accounts of virtually every event no matter how minute from almost all the participants, even though much of it occurred in the supposed sanctity of corporate board rooms.

These two books have a great deal in common, aside from both being about Hollywood studios. They’re fundamentally interested in the un-reality of Hollywood, the way in which the movie business exists in and of itself yet retaining an uneasy relationship with the outside world. Indecent Exposure is about how studio executives accustomed to operating solely in their own lucrative sandbox are forced to reckon with the corporate and legal world. The Studio is a series of vignettes about making movies. The subtext of every vignette is how to make your fake world real, or the real world fake.

There is one aspect of Indecent Exposure I feel I must address: the quotes. McClintick discloses that the quotes are not, you know, real things people said. He says they are recreations of real conversations that should be regarded as more accurate than paraphrases but less than verbatim. More than one subject took issue with this. One complained to the Times, “Any number of meetings are telescoped into a single conversation or selectively edited so that the meaning is distorted. I'd like to know what exactly constitutes a quote.”

McClintick defended his practice by arguing that he never condensed several conversations into one but “that to have paraphrased conversations or written ‘according to’ after every quotation ‘would have become unwieldy in a 500-page book.’” So instead he hired a kick-ass libel lawyer and dared the subjects to sue. They never did. Another subject summarized the whole controversy by saying, “I'm certainly not covered in glory in the book, but I think it is 95 percent accurate in terms of content and spirit…It's just that the truth hurts some people more than others.”

I couldn’t help but think about this as I read The Studio’s portrayal of the shooting of The Boston Strangler, a movie adaptation of a book about a real serial killer. The producer and screenwriter freely discussed changing characters and facts to fit what they thought the narrative ought to have been to please a hypothetical audience; a practice I imagine, based on the historical inaccuracies of basically every picture, is common. So there is something deliciously ironic about studio executives taking issue with the way a journalist took liberties with timelines and conversations for storytelling expediency.

Ultimately, regarding this Quotegate affair, I ended up landing on two conclusions:

  1. McClintick identified a very real gap in English punctuation. There ought to be something that denotes The Essential Context Of Something Someone Said But Not The Exact Words.

  2. McClintick straight up admits to making up quotes at the beginning of his book.

Anyhow, both books were fantastic reads and well worth tracking down. So I will conclude by sharing my two favorite anecdotes from The Studio.

My second-favorite is when the director of Tora! Tora! Tora! (one of the greatest war films ever made) confidently asserts that no matter where they film in Hawaii, the Japanese planes must always come into the frame “from the left,” because Americans think Japan is “to the left” of America.

My favorite anecdote was when Zanuck and a few underlings watched the dailies from Planet of the Apes. In the film, Charleton Heston was getting a blood transfusion from another human, overseen by an ape doctor. The transfusion was a direct link via a tube. One studio underling observed that isn’t how blood transfusions are done. They take the blood out of the donor then pump it into the recipient. Zanuck shrugged it off. “Maybe,” he replied, “that’s how the apes do it.”

Don't miss what's next. Subscribe to Book Time:
← Newer Book Time #33: China, Revisited Older → Book Time #31: The End of (My) Reading
Powered by Buttondown, the easiest way to start and grow your newsletter.